| Farmingdale State | SUNY-Farmingdale | current stats | Rams | Farmingdale,New York | NY | Keith Osik | Farmingdale State Baseball Stadium | | 2014 |
| Manhattanville | Manhattanville College | current stats | Valiants | Purchase,New York | NY | Jeff Caulfield | Manhattanville Baseball Field | Middle Atlantic Conference (NCAA-3) | 2021 |
| Merchant Marine | U.S. Merchant Marine Academy | current stats | Mariners | Kings Point,New York | NY | Michael Notebaert | Bartoszek Field | Landmark Conference (NCAA-3) | 2017 |
| Mount St. Mary NY | Mount St. Mary College NY | current stats | Knights | Newburgh,New York | NY | Trevor Purcell | MSMC Baseball Complex | | 2016 |
| Mt. Saint Vincent | College of Mount Saint Vincent | current stats | Dolphins | Bronx,New York | NY | Matthew Rienzi | | | 2015 |
| St. Joseph's NY | St. Joseph's College-Long Island | current stats | Golden Eagles | Long Island,New York | NY | Tom Caputo | Gregg Alfano Field | | 2016 |
| St. Joseph's-Brooklyn | St. Joseph's College-Brooklyn | current stats | Bears | Brooklyn,New York | NY | Rich Pecoraro | | | 2015 |
| SUNY Maritime | SUNY-Maritime College | current stats | Privateers | Throggs Neck,New York | NY | Charlie Barbieri | Reinhart Baseball Field | | 2016 |
| SUNY Old Westbury | SUNY College at Old Westbury | current stats | Panthers | Old Westbury,New York | NY | Rod Stephan | Jackie Robinson Athletic Complex | | 2016 |
| SUNY Purchase | SUNY-Purchase | current stats | Panthers | Purchase,New York | NY | Adam Taraska | PC Baseball Field | | 2016 |
| Yeshiva | Yeshiva University | current stats | Maccabees | New York,New York | NY | Jeremy Renna | Breslin Field / FDU | | 2016 |
| 11 record(s) |
