American League Players Choice Comeback Player of the Year

Award history
Historical list of winners for the American League Players Choice Comeback Player of the Year. MLB award history should be complete while other leagues are skewed more recent.

If you notice recent award winners are missing or have not been updated in a reasonable time frame, please feel free to send us a link or information about the missing data.

Historical Winners

CSV
Glossary
🔒
Sign up to TBC PREMIUM. (1) Create TBC Account (2) Send Payment (3) Start researching like a pro!
yearplayeraward notesposhtwtbathbornplacehilvlmlb yearsstat yearsdraft infostatuscur-orgcur-lev
2025Jacob deGrom P6-4180LR1988-06-19DeLand,FLMLB2014-20252008-2025
2010-  9- 272-NYN
ActiveTEXMLB
2024Tyler O'Neill LF-RF5-10200RR1995-06-22Burnaby,BCMLB2018-20252013-2025
2013-  3-  85-SEA
ActiveBALMLB
2023Liam Hendriks P6-0235RR1989-02-10Perth,AUMLB2011-20252007-2025
2007-  UDFA  -MIN
Free Agt  
2021Trey Mancini 1B-DH6-4230RR1992-03-18Winter Haven,FLMLB2016-20232011-2025
2013-  8- 249-BAL
Free Agt  
2020Carlos Carrasco P6-4224RR1987-03-21Barquisimeto,VZMLB2009-20252004-2025
2003-  UDFA  -PHI
MinorsATLAAA
2019Hunter Pence RF6-4216RR1983-04-13Fort Worth,TXMLB2007-20202003-2020
2004-  2-  64-HOU
Retired  
2018Michael Brantley LF-DH6-2209LL1987-05-15Bellevue,WAMLB2009-20232005-2023
2005-  7- 205-MIL
Free Agt  
2017Mike Moustakas 3B-1B6-0230LR1988-09-11Los Angeles,CAMLB2011-20232007-2023
2007-  1-   2-KCA
Free Agt  
2016Mark Trumbo 1B6-4225RR1986-01-16Anaheim,CAMLB2010-20192005-2019
2004- 18- 533-ANA
Free Agt  
2015Prince Fielder 1B5-11275LR1984-05-09Ontario,CAMLB2005-20162002-2016
2002-  1-   7-MIL
Free Agt  
2014Chris Young P6-10255RR1979-05-25Dallas,TXMLB2004-20172000-2017
2000-  3-  89-PIT
Free Agt  
2013Mariano Rivera P6-2195RR1969-11-29Panama City,PNMLB1995-20131990-2013
1990-  UDFA  -NYA
Retired  
2012Adam Dunn DH-1B6-6285LR1979-11-09Houston,TXMLB2001-20141998-2014
1998-  2-  50-CIN
Retired  
2011Jacoby Ellsbury CF6-1195LL1983-09-11Madras,ORMLB2007-20172003-2017
2005-  1-  23-BOS
Free Agt  
2010Vladimir Guerrero LF6-3235RR1975-02-09Nizao,DRMLB1996-20111994-2012
1993-  UDFA  -MON
Retired  
2009Aaron Hill 2B5-11200RR1982-03-21Visalia,CAMLB2005-20172001-2017
2003-  1-  13-TOR
Free Agt  
2008Cliff Lee P6-3205LL1978-08-30Benton,ARMLB2002-20142000-2014
2000-  4- 105-MON
Free Agt  
2007Carlos Pena 1B-DH6-2225LL1978-05-17Santo Domingo,DRMLB2001-20141996-2014
1998-  1-  10-TEX
Free Agt  
2006Frank Thomas 1B-DH6-5275RR1968-05-27Columbus,GAMLB1990-20081987-2008
1989-  1-   7-CHA
-  
2005Jason Giambi DH6-3240LR1971-01-08West Covina,CAMLB1995-20141992-2014
1992-  2-  58-OAK
Retired  
2004Orlando Hernandez P6-2220RR1965-10-11Guaji,CUMLB1998-20071998-2010
1998-  UDFA  -NYA
-  
2003Esteban Loaiza P6-2230RR1971-12-31Tijuana,MXMLB1995-20081991-2013
1991-  UDFA  -PIT
-  
2002Tim Salmon RF6-3235RR1968-08-24Long Beach,CAMLB1992-20061989-2006
1989-  3-  69-CAL
-  
2001Ruben Sierra RF6-1220BR1965-10-06Rio Piedras,PRMLB1986-20061983-2006
1982-  UDFA  -TEX
-  
2000Frank Thomas 1B-DH6-5275RR1968-05-27Columbus,GAMLB1990-20081987-2008
1989-  1-   7-CHA
-  
yearplayeraward notesposhtwtbathbornplacehilvlmlb yearsstat yearsdraft infostatuscur-orgcur-lev
1999John Jaha 1B6-1215RR1966-05-27Portland,ORMLB1992-20011985-2001
1984- 14- 358-MIL
-  
1998Eric Davis CF-LF6-3200RR1962-05-29Los Angeles,CAMLB1984-20011980-2001
1980-  8- 201-CIN
-  
1997David Justice RF-LF6-3215LL1966-04-14Cincinnati,OHMLB1989-20021985-2002
1985-  4-  94-ATL
-  
28 record(s)