| Gio Abreu | P | Rk | | 2014-2015 | --- |
| Elvis Alayon | OF | A- | | 1995-1997 | --- |
| Joe Albanese | P | MLB | 1958-1958 | 1958-1958 | --- |
| Jeff Albert | 3B | AA | | 1977-1979 | C.W. Post Campus/Long Island |
| Sam Alberts | P | NCAA | | 2007-2007 | Davidson College |
| Eric Alcantara | 3B-SS | NCAA | | 2013-2013 | Arkansas-Pine Bluff |
| Jose Alegria | C | A- | | 2010-2011 | --- |
| Daniel Alfonso | 3B | --- | | | --- |
| Pedro Alvarez | 3B | MLB | 2010-2018 | 2006-2018 | Vanderbilt |
| Erik Anderson | P | NCAA | | 2008-2009 | Nebraska, Barton County CC |
| Jose Antigua | C | Rk | | 1992-1996 | --- |
| Michael Antonio | 3B | A+ | | 2010-2016 | --- |
| Alex Arias | SS-3B | MLB | 1992-2002 | 1987-2005 | --- |
| Jose Ariza | 1B | A | | 2012-2014 | --- |
| Rudy Arroyo | P | MLB | 1971-1971 | 1971-1971 | Foothill College |
| Jon Avallone | 2B-SS | NCAA | | 2014-2017 | Massachusetts |
| Mike Aviles | 3B-SS | MLB | 2008-2017 | 2003-2017 | Concordia College |
| Stan Babieracki | P | --- | | | St. John's |
| Diogenes Baez | OF | A+ | | 1991-1994 | Connors State College |
| Grayson Bailey | P | NCAA | | 2013-2016 | East Carolina, Louisburg College, Lee University, Old Dominion |
| Jap Barbeau | 3B | MLB | 1905-1910 | 1905-1910 | --- |
| Gene Barisano | SS | --- | | | --- |
| Jose Barrios | 1B | MLB | 1982-1982 | 1975-1983 | --- |
| Aaron Bates | 1B | MLB | 2009-2009 | 2003-2014 | NC State |
| Chris Bates | P | NCAA | | 2011-2015 | Richmond |
| Alex Baumann | C-3B | NCAA | | 2017-2020 | Bucknell |
| Nestor Bautista | P | A+ | | 2011-2019 | Ball State |
| Buzzie Bavasi | EXEC | --- | | | DePauw |
| Larry Bearnarth | P | MLB | 1963-1971 | 1963-1971 | St. John's |
| Heinie Beckendorf | C | MLB | 1909-1910 | 1909-1910 | --- |
| Nolan Becker | P | AAA | | 2011-2018 | Yale |
| Bo Belinsky | P | MLB | 1962-1970 | 1962-1970 | --- |
| Carlos Belonis | OF | A+ | | 2012-2018 | --- |
| Marcus Beltrez | P | Rk | | 2012-2013 | --- |
| Richard Benes | 2B | Rk | | 1996-2007 | --- |
| Joe Bennett | 3B | --- | | | Missouri, New York |
| Dickens Benoit | OF | A+ | | 1987-1989 | St. Francis (NY) |
| Tommy Beres | C | --- | | | UCLA |
| Ben Berman | P | Indy | | 1999-1999 | --- |
| Bob Berman | C | --- | | | Fordham |
| David Bethea | P | NCAA | | 2005-2005 | Jackson State |
| August Biben | P | --- | | | Cornell |
| Josh Billings | P | MLB | 1927-1929 | 1927-1929 | Brown |
| Rivington Bisland | SS | MLB | 1912-1914 | 1912-1914 | --- |
| Pete Blohm | P | AAA | | 1987-1993 | Johns Hopkins |
| Bobby Bonilla | 3B-RF | MLB | 1986-2001 | 1981-2001 | New York Tech |
| Sam Boone | 3B-2B | NCAA | | 2005-2009 | Massachusetts, Xavier |
| Osvaldo Bosch | OF | --- | | | --- |
| Aaron Bouie | P | Rk | | 1998-2001 | St. Bonaventure |
| Russ Bove | SCOUT | --- | | | St. John's |
| Bill Brady | P | MLB | 1912-1912 | 1912-1912 | --- |
| Paul Branca | C | --- | | | --- |
| Tyler Brandon | P | --- | | | Maryland |
| Alan Brice | P | MLB | 1961-1961 | 1961-1961 | --- |
| Antone Brooks | P | AAA | | 1995-2001 | Norfolk State |
| Steven Brooks | LF-RF | Rk | | 2008-2011 | Wake Forest |
| Joe Brown | EXEC | --- | | | UCLA |
| Andrew Brunswick | OF | NCAA | | 2002-2002 | Harvard |
| Alfred Buchta | P | --- | | | New York |
| Stephen Bureau | P | Rk | | 1999-2000 | --- |
| Devin Burke | P | AAA | | 2010-2019 | Duke, Virginia Tech |
| Ryan Burke | P | NCAA | | 2008-2009 | Wake Forest |
| Enmanuel Cabreja | C | NCAA | | 2011-2013 | Columbia |
| Angel Cabrera | SS | A+ | | 2006-2008 | Connors State College |
| Tony Calabrese | OF | AA | | 1999-2003 | Seton Hall |
| Jim Campanis | C | MLB | 1966-1973 | 1966-1973 | --- |
| Mario Campos | OF | A- | | 2001-2003 | --- |
| Jeimer Candelario | 3B | MLB | 2016-2020 | 2011-2020 | --- |
| Pat Capri | 2B | MLB | 1944-1944 | 1944-1944 | Brooklyn College |
| James Cardasis | OF | --- | | | New York |
| Al Cardwood | P-1B | AA | | 1984-1987 | Ranger College, Long Island-Brooklyn |
| Daniel Carela | P | A+ | | 2008-2018 | Wallace CC |
| Duke Carmel | OF-1B | MLB | 1959-1965 | 1959-1965 | --- |
| Howie Carter | 2B-SS | MLB | 1926-1926 | 1926-1926 | Fordham |
| Alexander Cartwright | EXEC | --- | | | --- |
| Steven Caseres | 1B | A+ | | 2007-2012 | James Madison |
| Eric Castaldo | C | Rk | | 1994-1996 | Florida |
| Darwin Castillo | P | Rk | | 2011-2012 | --- |
| Ernest Castro | OF | A | | 1989-1997 | --- |
| Ramon Castro | 2B-SS | --- | | | --- |
| Kevin Cerda | 1B | Rk | | 2012-2013 | --- |
| Jake Chaplin | 1B | Rk | | 2012-2013 | Haverford College |
| Dariel Checo | P | Indy | | 2015-2019 | Central Methodist University, Kirkwood CC |
| Mariel Checo | P | A | | 2009-2019 | --- |
| Josh Chesler | P | Indy | | 2011-2013 | Georgia State, Bloomfield College, Phoenix College |
| Justin Chin | P | NCAA | | 2015-2018 | New Jersey Tech |
| Bob Chlupsa | P | MLB | 1970-1971 | 1970-1971 | Manhattan College |
| Ted Chmielinski | P | Indy | | 2002-2002 | McNeese State, Central Arizona College |
| Darryl Cias | C | MLB | 1983-1983 | 1978-1986 | --- |
| Boileryard Clarke | 1B-C | MLB | 1893-1905 | 1893-1905 | --- |
| Tommy Clarke | C | MLB | 1909-1917 | 1909-1917 | --- |
| Jack Coffey | SS-2B | MLB | 1909-1918 | 1909-1918 | Fordham |
| Alta Cohen | OF | MLB | 1931-1933 | 1931-1933 | --- |
| Rocky Colavito | OF | MLB | 1955-1968 | 1955-1968 | --- |
| Osmer Collado | IF-P | Indy | | 2011-2012 | Mitchell College |
| Jocko Collins | SCOUT | --- | | | --- |
| Jose Colon | OF | A+ | | 1995-2001 | Santa Fe CC |
| Louis Concato | P | NCAA | | 2011-2015 | Dartmouth |
| Elijah Connell | P | NCAA | | 2016-2016 | Pennsylvania |
| Edward Connors | P | A+ | | 1978-1980 | --- |
| Owen Conway | 3B | MLB | 1915-1915 | 1915-1915 | --- |
| Cole Cook | P | AAA | | 2008-2013 | Pepperdine |
| Phil Cooney | 3B | MLB | 1905-1905 | 1905-1905 | --- |
| Don Cooper | P | MLB | 1981-1985 | 1978-1987 | New York Tech |
| Danny Core | P | A+ | | 2000-2007 | Florida Atlantic |
| Edwin Corniel | P | NCAA | | 2013-2015 | Stony Brook, Odessa |
| Rob Costello | P | NCAA | | 2013-2013 | George Washington |
| Henry Cotto | CF-LF | MLB | 1984-1993 | 1980-1995 | --- |
| Jared Cozart | OF | NCAA | | 2007-2009 | Southern, Catonsville CC, Seminole Florida |
| Bob Crosby | P | --- | | | --- |
| Terry Crowley | SS | AA | | 1986-1992 | --- |
| Cirilo Cruz | 3B | AA | | 1995-2001 | Miami-Dade College |
| Billy Crystal | DH | --- | | | Marshall, Nassau CC, New York |
| Angelo Cuevas | OF | AAA | | 1984-1990 | --- |
| Liam Dalton | C | NCAA | | 2016-2016 | Notre Dame |
| Evan Danieli | P | Rk | | 2008-2011 | Notre Dame |
| Dave Daniels | P | AAA | | 1994-2001 | Vanderbilt |
| Tom Danulevith | P | --- | | | St. John's |
| Vic Davila | 2B | A+ | | 1982-2008 | Westchester CC |
| Bob Davis | P | MLB | 1958-1960 | 1958-1960 | Yale |
| Jonah Davis | OF | A | | 2016-2019 | California |
| Jason De La Cruz | OF | Rk | | 2005-2005 | --- |
| Jose De La Cruz | P-UT | NCAA | | 2017-2020 | Manhattan College, Westchester CC |
| Luis Arias De Los Santos | IF | NCAA | | 2016-2018 | Long Island-Brooklyn |
| Dean DeCillis | IF | AAA | | 1987-1994 | Miami-Dade College |
| Johnny Defendis | OF | A | | 2003-2006 | Rutgers |
| Mike Degerick | P | MLB | 1961-1962 | 1961-1962 | --- |
| Carlos Del Rosario | OF | NCAA | | 2008-2009 | St. John's, Indian River CC |
| Garton Del Savio | SS | MLB | 1943-1943 | 1943-1943 | --- |
| Manny DeLeon | OF | A- | | 2016-2017 | --- |
| Sandy Deleon | C | Indy | | 1998-2015 | Rockland CC |
| Andres Delgado | P | --- | | | --- |
| Bryan Delgado | P | NCAA | | 2018-2020 | Grambling State, Advanced Software Analysis |
| Sam Deluca | IF | Rk | | 2004-2009 | St. John's, Manhattan College |
| Ariel Deno | C | Rk | | 1993-1993 | --- |
| Tony DePhillips | C | MLB | 1943-1943 | 1943-1943 | Fordham |
| Christian Diaz | C | Rk | | 1996-1999 | --- |
| Ricky Digrugilliers | P | NCAA | | 2015-2018 | Western Illinois, Gateway CC, Minnesota State University-Mankato |
| Angelo Dilone | P | Rk | | 2012-2012 | --- |
| John Doherty | P | MLB | 1992-1996 | 1978-1996 | Concordia College |
| Charles Dragonetti | P | Indy | | 2009-2012 | County College of Morris |
| Bill Dreesen | 3B | MLB | 1931-1931 | 1931-1931 | --- |
| Chris Duffy | 1B | A+ | | 2007-2016 | Central Florida |
| Rodrigo Duluc | IF | NCAA | | 2018-2020 | Rice |
| Gabby Duran | P | Indy | | 2011-2011 | Dowling College |
| Gustavo Duran | P | --- | | | --- |
| Lery Duran | 3B | --- | | | --- |
| George Earnshaw | P | MLB | 1928-1936 | 1928-1936 | Swarthmore College |
| Damion Easley | 2B | MLB | 1992-2008 | 1989-2008 | Long Beach City College |
| Andrew Edwards | P | A- | | 2002-2007 | Florida Intl |
| Ted Eldredge | P | A+ | | 1987-1989 | California, UC Davis |
| Stephen Elmore | P | NCAA | | 2009-2011 | Princeton |
| Ralph Elpin | P | A | | 1981-1982 | County College of Morris |
| Bob Emmerich | OF | MLB | 1923-1923 | 1923-1923 | --- |
| Charlie Engle | SS-3B | MLB | 1926-1930 | 1926-1930 | --- |
| Theo Epstein | EXEC | --- | | | Yale |
| Gorky Estrella | 3B | A | | 1997-2000 | --- |
| Julio Eusebio | P | AAA | | 2014-2019 | --- |
| Billy Evers | C | AAA | | 1977-1979 | Eckerd College |
| Charlie Fallon | H | --- | | | --- |
| Steve Fanning | SS | AAA | | 1988-1995 | Troy |
| Frank Fanovich | P | MLB | 1949-1953 | 1949-1953 | --- |
| Harry Feldman | P | MLB | 1941-1946 | 1941-1946 | --- |
| Eric Feliz | OF | NCAA | | 2017-2020 | Notre Dame, Embry-Riddle |
| Michael Feliz | IF | NCAA | | 2017-2018 | Notre Dame, Chattahoochee Val |
| Jose Fernandez | C | AAA | | 1989-1994 | Florida |
| Mike Fernandez | OF-3B | AA | | 1991-1996 | New York Tech |
| Scott Ferrara | OF | NCAA | | 2008-2010 | St. John's |
| Tom Ferrick | P | MLB | 1941-1952 | 1941-1952 | --- |
| Edwin Figueroa | C | --- | | | --- |
| Peter Finnerty | C-1B | --- | | | Pace |
| William Fischer | C | MLB | 1913-1917 | 1913-1917 | --- |
| John Flaherty | C | MLB | 1992-2005 | 1988-2005 | George Washington |
| Jose Flores | 2B-SS | MLB | 2002-2004 | 1994-2006 | Texas, New Mexico JC |
| Rob Fondu | OF | NCAA | | 2008-2011 | Furman |
| Eddie Ford | SS | AAA | | 1977-1977 | South Carolina |
| Whitey Ford | P | MLB | 1950-1967 | 1950-1967 | --- |
| Isidro Fortuna | OF | NCAA | | 2003-2006 | Stony Brook |
| George Foussianes | SS | AAA | | 1980-1985 | Michigan |
| Jack Fowler | P | Indy | | 2013-2018 | Felician College |
| Charlie Fox | C | MLB | 1942-1942 | 1942-1942 | --- |
| Joe Foy | 3B | MLB | 1966-1971 | 1966-1971 | --- |
| Edwin Franco | P | A- | | 1998-1999 | Florida Intl |
| J.J. Franco | SS | AA | | 2011-2018 | Brown |
| Willie Fraser | P | MLB | 1986-1995 | 1985-1995 | Concordia College |
| Fernando Frias | OF | Indy | | 2014-2014 | --- |
| Raymond Frias | IF | Indy | | 2009-2016 | UNC-Greensboro, Northwestern State, Odessa |
| Bill Froats | P | MLB | 1955-1955 | 1955-1955 | Notre Dame |
| Jared Gaer | P | NCAA | | 2018-2019 | Pennsylvania, Emory |
| Santy Gallone | OF | A+ | | 1993-1995 | Fordham |
| Alvin Garcia | P | Rk | | 2006-2006 | --- |
| Christopher Garcia | P | Rk | | 2013-2015 | --- |
| Luis Garcia | SS | MLB | 2020-2020 | 2017-2020 | --- |
| Pierre Garcia | IF | --- | | | Southern, Iowa Central CC |
| Travis Garcia | 3B | AAA | | 2002-2015 | Iona College |
| Al Gardella | 1B | MLB | 1945-1945 | 1945-1945 | --- |
| Danny Gardella | OF | MLB | 1944-1950 | 1944-1950 | --- |
| Jim Gargiulo | C | A | | 1995-1997 | Miami |
| Chris Gaskin | 1B | A- | | 2002-2008 | Manhattan College |
| Alex Gaston | C | MLB | 1920-1929 | 1920-1929 | --- |
| Pedro Gavilian | C | AA | | 1977-1982 | --- |
| Frendy Gavin | P | Rk | | 2013-2015 | --- |
| Lou Gehrig | 1B | MLB | 1923-1939 | 1923-1939 | Columbia |
| Dave Gerard | P | MLB | 1962-1962 | 1962-1962 | --- |
| Chris Giglio | P | NCAA | | 2015-2017 | Princeton |
| Isaac Gil | P | A+ | | 2011-2018 | Advanced Software Analysis |
| William Gilbert | P | NCAA | | 2019-2019 | Cornell |
| Joe Gingras | P | --- | | | --- |
| Joe Ginsberg | C | MLB | 1948-1962 | 1948-1962 | --- |
| Scott Gleckel | P | AA | | 1978-1981 | --- |
| Jonah Goldman | SS | MLB | 1928-1931 | 1928-1931 | Syracuse |
| Raywilly Gomez | C | AA | | 2009-2016 | --- |
| Hidekel Gonzalez | C | AAA | | 2014-2019 | --- |
| Jesus Gonzalez | OF | --- | | | Triton College |
| Jonathan Gonzalez | P | A+ | | 2009-2013 | --- |
| Don Gordon | P | MLB | 1986-1988 | 1982-1991 | South Carolina, The Citadel |
| Tom Gorman | P | MLB | 1939-1939 | 1939-1939 | --- |
| Tom Gorman | P | MLB | 1952-1959 | 1952-1980 | Gonzaga |
| John Gracio | SCOUT | --- | | | Southern Illinois |
| Hank Grampp | P | MLB | 1927-1929 | 1927-1929 | --- |
| Hank Greenberg | 1B-OF | MLB | 1930-1947 | 1930-1947 | --- |
| Steve Greenberg | 1B | --- | | | Yale |
| Aaron Greenfield | C | NCAA | | 2003-2006 | Penn State |
| Bob Grim | P | MLB | 1954-1962 | 1954-1962 | --- |
| Mike Grippo | P | A+ | | 1999-2001 | Long Island-Brooklyn |
| Ramces Guerrero | 2B | Rk | | 1988-1989 | Dominican College |
| Mike Guy | C | NCAA | | 2008-2009 | Maryland-Eastern Shore, Salem CC |
| Wilton Guzman | UT | NCAA | | 2012-2014 | Arkansas-Pine Bluff |
| Keith Harris | OF | A | | 1987-1990 | Queensborough CC |
| Mickey Harris | P | MLB | 1940-1952 | 1940-1952 | --- |
| Andy Hasburn | SS | Rk | | 1997-1997 | --- |
| Robert Hassenfelt | P | NCAA | | 2004-2008 | Georgia State |
| Buddy Hassett | 1B | MLB | 1936-1942 | 1936-1942 | Manhattan College |
| Samuel Hauser | P | NCAA | | 2016-2017 | Brown |
| Matt Henkel | IF | NCAA | | 2012-2012 | Dartmouth |
| Jesus Hernandez | P | NCAA | | 2012-2013 | Maryland-Eastern Shore, Rockland CC |
| Nyan Hernandez | P | Rk | | 2019-2019 | --- |
| William Hernandez | OF-C | --- | | | College of Staten Island |
| Bill Herring | P | --- | | | --- |
| Keith Herring | IF | NCAA | | 2012-2013 | C.W. Post Campus/Long Island, Monroe CC |
| Liam Hibbits | IF | NCAA | | 2018-2020 | Va. Commonwealth |
| Colin Hinds | OF | A | | 1994-1997 | Loyola Marymount |
| Herb Hippauf | P | MLB | 1966-1966 | 1966-1966 | Pasadena City College |
| Jeff Hoffman | P | NCAA | | 2008-2009 | Campbell |
| Wally Holborow | P | MLB | 1944-1948 | 1944-1948 | --- |
| Bill Hollahan | 3B | MLB | 1920-1920 | 1920-1920 | --- |
| Jordan Holtz | P | NCAA | | 2012-2015 | Bucknell |
| Jonathan Hurst | P | MLB | 1992-1994 | 1987-1998 | Spartanburg Methodist College |
| Bryan Hwang | IF | NCAA | | 2006-2009 | George Washington |
| Raul Ibanez | LF | MLB | 1996-2014 | 1992-2014 | Miami-Dade College |
| Jose Infante | SS | Rk | | 2014-2015 | --- |
| George Isabel | P | Rk | | 2008-2013 | Northwood, Wallace CC |
| Stan Jefferson | CF-LF | MLB | 1986-1991 | 1983-1991 | Bethune-Cookman |
| Miguel Jimenez | P | MLB | 1993-1994 | 1991-1999 | Fordham |
| Tim Jordan | 1B | MLB | 1901-1910 | 1901-1910 | --- |
| John Kahn | OF | NCAA | | 2006-2009 | Fordham |
| Bill Kalfass | P | MLB | 1937-1937 | 1937-1937 | Columbia |
| Eric Katzman | P | Indy | | 2007-2014 | Michigan |
| Duke Kelleher | C | --- | | | Princeton |
| Joe Kelly | OF-1B | MLB | 1926-1928 | 1926-1928 | --- |
| Tate Kelly | P | Indy | | 2010-2010 | --- |
| Eli Kimbell | OF-P | NCAA | | 2017-2019 | Princeton |
| Chris Kitsos | SS | --- | | | --- |
| Gabe Kleiman | P | NCAA | | 2014-2018 | Pennsylvania, Bard |
| Matthew Kleinstein | C | NCAA | | 2014-2017 | Felician College |
| Donn Koch | C | A | | 1981-1982 | Florida Southern, Scottsdale CC |
| Chris Kono | P | NCAA | | 2011-2014 | Holy Cross |
| Mike Korchak | P-1B | NCAA | | 2015-2018 | Bucknell |
| Eric Kozak | C | Indy | | 2011-2019 | Rochester Institute of Technology, RPI |
| Ross Krakower | P | --- | | | Pennsylvania |
| Ed Kranepool | 1B | MLB | 1962-1979 | 1962-1979 | --- |
| Paul Krichell | C | MLB | 1911-1912 | 1911-1912 | --- |
| Todd Lamb | P | AA | | 1983-1986 | Duke |
| Willis Lancaster | C | --- | | | --- |
| Billy Lauder | 3B | MLB | 1898-1903 | 1898-1903 | Brown |
| Fred Lear | 3B-2B | MLB | 1915-1920 | 1915-1920 | Villanova |
| Al Lefevre | SS-2B | MLB | 1920-1920 | 1920-1920 | Fordham |
| Donny Leon | 3B | AAA | | 1995-2010 | Polk State |
| Zack Leone | C | NCAA | | 2014-2018 | Massachusetts, Susquehanna, Valparaiso |
| Ethan Liederman | OF | NCAA | | 2010-2012 | Minnesota |
| Lou Limmer | 1B | MLB | 1951-1954 | 1951-1954 | --- |
| Ernie Lindemann | P | MLB | 1907-1907 | 1907-1907 | --- |
| Jamie Loeb | OF | --- | | | New York Tech |
| Ed Lopat | P | MLB | 1944-1955 | 1944-1955 | --- |
| Paul Lopez | P | NCAA | | 2007-2010 | Long Island-Brooklyn |
| Eddie Lora | 1B | Rk | | 2008-2010 | --- |
| Matthew Lorenzetti | P | NCAA | | 2012-2016 | Quinnipiac |
| Willie Lozado | 3B | MLB | 1984-1984 | 1979-1988 | Miami-Dade College |
| Miller Lulow | P | Indy | | 2013-2013 | SUNY-Purchase |
| Harvey MacDonald | OF | MLB | 1928-1928 | 1928-1928 | Albright College |
| John Mackin | UMP | --- | | | --- |
| Bryce Maher | SS-2B | NCAA | | 2014-2017 | Massachusetts |
| Ivan Maldonado | P | AAA | | 2002-2016 | Indian Hills CC-Centerville |
| Jason Malefakis | OF | NCAA | | 2008-2008 | Michigan |
| Jim Maler | 1B | MLB | 1981-1983 | 1978-1986 | Miami-Dade College |
| John Malkin | C | AAA | | 1978-1985 | --- |
| Justyn-Henry Malloy | UT | NCAA | | 2019-2020 | Vanderbilt, Georgia Tech |
| George Maloney | UMP | --- | | | --- |
| Kelvin Mancebo | UT | --- | | | Kent State |
| Peter Mancini | 2B | A+ | | 1985-1985 | Seton Hall |
| Danny Mangual | IF | Indy | | 1996-1998 | --- |
| Victor Mangual | P | A- | | 1987-1989 | --- |
| James Manias | P | AA | | 1996-2002 | Fairfield |
| Ronald Marietta | P | A | | 1998-2001 | St. John's |
| Chris Marsicano | OF | NCAA | | 2006-2009 | George Washington |
| Edgar Martinez | DH-3B | MLB | 1987-2004 | 1983-2004 | --- |
| Jorge Martinez | OF | Rk | | 1996-1996 | --- |
| Victor Martinez | IF | AA | | 1996-1999 | --- |
| Xyruse Martinez | 3B | Indy | | 2012-2017 | Northwestern Oklahoma State, Central Arizona College |
| Julius Matos | 2B-3B | MLB | 2002-2003 | 1994-2006 | South Suburban College |
| Lee Mazzilli | OF-1B | MLB | 1976-1989 | 1974-1989 | --- |
| Kelvin McAllister | OF | NCAA | | 2006-2006 | Iona College |
| Jim McCollom | 1B | AAA | | 1982-1990 | Clemson |
| Frank McCormick | 1B | MLB | 1934-1948 | 1934-1948 | --- |
| Tim McCormick | OF | NCAA | | 2010-2013 | St. John's, Frederick CC, Florida Southern |
| Danny McDevitt | P | MLB | 1957-1962 | 1957-1962 | St. Bonaventure |
| Peter McEneaney | P | Indy | | 2008-2009 | Rochester |
| Dan McGee | SS | MLB | 1934-1934 | 1934-1934 | --- |
| Sean McGowan | UT | NCAA | | 2017-2018 | Dartmouth |
| Brian McKenna | P | A+ | | 2017-2019 | --- |
| Charlie Meara | OF | MLB | 1914-1914 | 1914-1914 | Manhattan College |
| Jesus Medina | IF-P | NCAA | | 2013-2016 | Sacred Heart |
| Walt Meinert | OF | MLB | 1913-1913 | 1913-1913 | --- |
| Dutch Mele | OF | MLB | 1937-1937 | 1937-1937 | --- |
| Hector Melendez | OF | Rk | | 1988-1988 | --- |
| Jose Mencia | P | NCAA | | 2020-2020 | Delaware State |
| Marc Mendel | P | NCAA | | 2020-2020 | Kansas |
| Randal Mendez | IF | NCAA | | 2014-2017 | Coppin State College, Mercy College |
| Sabah Mendez | P | A+ | | 1977-1977 | --- |
| Mike Meola | P | MLB | 1933-1936 | 1933-1936 | --- |
| Alberton Meran | OF | NCAA | | 2002-2003 | Bethune-Cookman, South Mountain CC |
| George Mercado | OF | --- | | | --- |
| Todd Merz | P | NCAA | | 2004-2004 | Pacific, Vanguard Southern California |
| Ben Metzner | OF | --- | | | Yale |
| Ernest Miller | P | AAA | | 1997-2004 | Methodist |
| Hack Miller | OF | MLB | 1916-1925 | 1916-1925 | --- |
| Greg Modica | P | A- | | 2001-2006 | Culver-Stockton College |
| Mikael-Ali Mogues | IF | Indy | | 2014-2019 | Seton Hall |
| Helpiz Moises | P | NCAA | | 2001-2002 | Bethune-Cookman, Connors State College |
| Izzy Molina | C | MLB | 1996-2002 | 1990-2003 | --- |
| Lucas Momo | OF | NCAA | | 2007-2007 | Fordham, Columbia |
| Paul Mondesi | C | Rk | | 2016-2019 | --- |
| Johnny Monell | OF | AAA | | 1985-2001 | --- |
| Ruben Monett | P | Rk | | 1983-1983 | --- |
| Lance Montano | IF | Indy | | 2013-2017 | Coppin State College, Skyline College |
| Ricardo Montas | IF | AA | | 1995-2002 | --- |
| Oscar Montes | P | Rk | | 2004-2004 | --- |
| Alvin Montila | OF | Rk | | 1997-1997 | --- |
| Abel Mora | P | Rk | | 2011-2014 | --- |
| Anthony Morel | SS | NCAA | | 2006-2009 | Riverside CC, UNLV |
| Hank Morgenweck | UMP | --- | | | --- |
| Carlos Moscoso | C | NCAA | | 2001-2004 | Marist |
| Andrew Muhlstock | P | AAA | | 1977-1978 | Pennsylvania |
| Jim Mullin | 2B-1B | MLB | 1904-1905 | 1904-1905 | Manhattan College |
| Marcos Munoz | P | Rk | | 1998-1998 | --- |
| Adrian Muoio | C | --- | | | Davidson College |
| Johnny Murphy | P | MLB | 1932-1947 | 1932-1947 | --- |
| Patrick Murphy | P | A+ | | 1983-1986 | Florida Atlantic |
| Peter Murphy | P-3B | AA | | 1986-1991 | Columbia |
| Walter Murphy | P | MLB | 1931-1931 | 1931-1931 | --- |
| Michael Murray | 3B-C | A- | | 1984-1984 | Kean |
| Damien Myers | P | A+ | | 2002-2007 | Concordia College |
| Sam Nahem | P | MLB | 1938-1948 | 1938-1948 | --- |
| Bots Nekola | P | MLB | 1929-1933 | 1929-1933 | Holy Cross |
| Kai Nelson | OF | NCAA | | 2018-2020 | Georgetown |
| Andrew Newfield | P | NCAA | | 2009-2011 | Towson |
| Rafael Novoa | P | MLB | 1990-1993 | 1989-1997 | Villanova |
| Jose Nunez | P-2B | Rk | | 1996-1997 | --- |
| Roman Nunez | C | Indy | | 1998-1998 | --- |
| Tirzon Nunez | 3B | Rk | | 2003-2003 | Cumberland |
| Cameron O'Brien | C | A- | | 2012-2017 | Louisville, Northeast Texas CC, West Virginia |
| Billy O'Connor | OF | A+ | | 1985-1986 | Adelphi |
| Alex O'Neill | IF | NCAA | | 2012-2016 | Bucknell, Fordham, Westchester CC |
| Gerald O'Neill | P | --- | | | --- |
| Walter Ockey | P | MLB | 1944-1944 | 1944-1944 | --- |
| Shane Ogren | IF | NCAA | | 2011-2013 | Dartmouth |
| Rube Oldring | OF | MLB | 1905-1918 | 1905-1918 | --- |
| Albert Ortiz | OF | A | | 1978-1979 | Baruch College |
| Bill Oster | P | MLB | 1954-1954 | 1954-1954 | New York |
| Billy Ott | OF | MLB | 1962-1964 | 1962-1964 | St. John's |
| Adam Ottavino | P | MLB | 2010-2020 | 2004-2020 | Northeastern |
| Jim Palmer | P | MLB | 1965-1984 | 1964-1984 | Arizona State |
| Greg Papageorge | C | A+ | | 1988-1989 | St. Francis (NY) |
| Luis Parache | 2B | A- | | 2010-2016 | --- |
| Brett Paulsen | IF | NCAA | | 2020-2020 | Stony Brook |
| Pedro Payano | P | MLB | 2019-2019 | 2012-2019 | --- |
| Gregory Pena | RF-CF | Rk | | 2010-2012 | --- |
| Ronald Pena | C | A | | 2007-2009 | --- |
| Kewpie Pennington | P | MLB | 1917-1917 | 1917-1917 | --- |
| Christian Perdomo | P | Rk | | 2013-2014 | Advanced Software Analysis |
| Andres Perez | OF | A+ | | 2003-2016 | Stony Brook, Lamar, Gulf Coast CC |
| Julio Perez | IF | AAA | | 1977-1983 | --- |
| Esterlin Perozo | OF-C | Indy | | 2008-2011 | Jacksonville, Wallace CC, Garden City CC |
| Monte Pfeffer | SS | MLB | 1913-1913 | 1913-1913 | --- |
| Morgan Phillips | SS | NCAA | | 2013-2016 | College of Charleston |
| Skyler Pichardo | P | NCAA | | 2017-2020 | Marist |
| Val Picinich | C | MLB | 1916-1933 | 1916-1933 | --- |
| Danton Pierre-Louis | 1B | Rk | | 1993-1994 | --- |
| Jake Pitler | 2B | MLB | 1917-1918 | 1917-1918 | --- |
| Frank Pol | P | Rk | | 2006-2006 | --- |
| Erik Poldroo | OF | Indy | | 2016-2016 | Concordia College |
| Arnie Portocarrero | P | MLB | 1954-1960 | 1954-1960 | --- |
| Adam Prida | P | NCAA | | 2002-2004 | Western Kentucky, Florida |
| Shawn Quezada | OF-P | --- | | | Marist |
| Jake Rabinowitz | P-IF | NCAA | | 2006-2009 | Fordham |
| Jimmie Reese | 2B | MLB | 1930-1932 | 1930-1932 | --- |
| Tucker Rekucki | P | NCAA | | 2012-2015 | Bucknell |
| Xavier Rescigno | P | MLB | 1943-1945 | 1943-1945 | Manhattan College |
| Dylan Resk | UT | NCAA | | 2016-2019 | Stony Brook |
| Otto Rettig | P | MLB | 1922-1922 | 1922-1922 | Seton Hall |
| Joseph Reyes | IF | Rk | | 2017-2019 | --- |
| Rowan Richards | OF | AA | | 1995-1999 | Notre Dame |
| Harry Riconda | 3B-2B | MLB | 1923-1930 | 1923-1930 | --- |
| Robert Riggio | 3B | Rk | | 1997-1997 | Lehman College, City New York |
| Joseph Rigoli | C | A | | 1978-1984 | Fairleigh Dickinson |
| Fred Riscen | P | Rk | | 1988-1988 | Los Angeles Pierce College, College of the Canyons, Texas A&M |
| Jim Rivera | OF | MLB | 1952-1961 | 1952-1961 | --- |
| Randy Rivera | P | A+ | | 1989-1990 | Ranger College, Oklahoma State |
| Robert Rivera | P | Rk | | 1978-1978 | --- |
| Vincent Roberto | OF | --- | | | Miami |
| Matt Robinson | OF | NCAA | | 2012-2012 | Dartmouth |
| Patrick Robinson | OF | NCAA | | 2016-2018 | Harvard |
| Alex Rodriguez | 3B | MLB | 1994-2016 | 1994-2016 | --- |
| Anthony Rodriguez | IF | A- | | 1999-1999 | --- |
| Carlos Rodriguez | SS | --- | | | --- |
| Diobel Rodriguez | C | NCAA | | 2017-2020 | Cornell, Mohawk Valley CC |
| Joe Rodriguez | P | Indy | | 2009-2010 | Indiana State, Clarendon College |
| John Rodriguez | OF | MLB | 2005-2006 | 1997-2013 | --- |
| Jonathan Rodriguez | P | Rk | | 2014-2014 | --- |
| Louis Rodriguez | 1B | --- | | | --- |
| Nellie Rodriguez | 1B | AAA | | 2012-2019 | --- |
| Nerio Rodriguez | DH | Rk | | 2017-2019 | --- |
| Raymond Rodriguez | P | Indy | | 2005-2005 | Central Florida, North Florida CC |
| Vic Rodriguez | 2B-3B | MLB | 1984-1989 | 1977-1994 | --- |
| Wesley Rodriguez | P | A | | 2016-2019 | --- |
| Chris Rodriquez | IF-C | NCAA | | 2015-2015 | Coppin State College |
| Dany Rojas | OF | Rk | | 2014-2014 | --- |
| Luis Rojas | P | AA | | 1981-1982 | Texas Christian |
| Jesus Roman | P | Rk | | 2014-2017 | --- |
| Norberto Roman | C | A | | 1977-1977 | --- |
| Joseph Rosa | SS | AAA | | 2015-2019 | --- |
| Jose Rosario | P | AAA | | 2009-2019 | --- |
| Stanley Rosario | OF | Rk | | 2018-2019 | --- |
| Max Rosenfeld | OF | MLB | 1931-1933 | 1931-1933 | Alabama |
| Eric Rossy | 3B | Indy | | 2000-2003 | Dowling College, Suffolk County CC-Ammerman |
| Dick Rudolph | P | MLB | 1910-1927 | 1910-1927 | Fordham |
| Joe Rullo | 2B | MLB | 1943-1944 | 1943-1944 | --- |
| Rex Rundgren | SS | AAA | | 2001-2012 | Sacramento City College |
| Ed Runge | UMP | --- | | | --- |
| James Ruocchio | 3B | A- | | 1991-1991 | Long Island-Brooklyn |
| Jacob Ruppert | EXEC | --- | | | --- |
| Chris Rusciano | P | A | | 1992-1997 | Brooklyn College |
| Colin Sabean | IF | NCAA | | 2007-2008 | Villanova |
| Liam Sabino | IF | A- | | 2015-2019 | Vanderbilt, Pittsburgh |
| John Sakellariadis | P | --- | | | Harvard |
| Salvador Sanchez | P | AAA | | 2005-2015 | --- |
| Brandon Santana | 3B | Rk | | 2013-2014 | --- |
| Rico Santana | OF | Indy | | 2000-2010 | Mercyhurst |
| Yigui Santana | 3B | Rk | | 2010-2010 | --- |
| Adalberto Santos | 3B | AAA | | 2009-2014 | New Mexico JC, Oregon State |
| Al Schacht | P | MLB | 1919-1921 | 1919-1921 | --- |
| Heinie Scheer | 2B | MLB | 1922-1923 | 1922-1923 | --- |
| Richie Scheinblum | OF | MLB | 1965-1974 | 1964-1974 | C.W. Post Campus/Long Island |
| Chris Schilling | C | Rk | | 1999-2000 | --- |
| Dan Schwartz | P | Indy | | 2005-2007 | Northwestern, Amherst College |
| Christian Sepulveda | IF | NCAA | | 2017-2020 | Texas-Pan American, Galveston College |
| Joe Shashaty | 2B | NCAA | | 2015-2016 | Hartford |
| Norm Sherry | C | MLB | 1959-1963 | 1959-1963 | --- |
| Richard Shubert | P | AA | | 1977-1977 | --- |
| Alex Siele | H | Indy | | 2003-2005 | Cal Poly Pomona |
| Walter Signer | P | MLB | 1943-1945 | 1943-1945 | New York |
| Nick Silber | P | NCAA | | 2017-2018 | Rice |
| Ken Singleton | OF | MLB | 1970-1984 | 1967-1984 | --- |
| Chris Skrypack | P | NCAA | | 2004-2004 | Central Ct State, St. Thomas Aquinas |
| Joe Smith | C | MLB | 1913-1913 | 1913-1913 | California |
| Robert Smith | P | --- | | | St. John's |
| Mose Solomon | OF | MLB | 1923-1923 | 1923-1923 | --- |
| Vin Soreca | P | AA | | 1981-1983 | Pace |
| Gamalier Sosa | 1B | Rk | | 1994-1994 | --- |
| Elvin Soto | C | AA | | 2012-2017 | Pittsburgh |
| Harry Spence | COACH | --- | | | --- |
| Mel Steiner | UMP | --- | | | --- |
| Paxton Stewart | 1B | A+ | | 1995-1999 | Florida Intl |
| Snuffy Stirnweiss | 2B | MLB | 1943-1951 | 1943-1951 | North Carolina |
| Peter Stonard | SS | A+ | | 2001-2003 | San Diego State, Alabama |
| Richard Stuart | OF | A+ | | 1994-2000 | --- |
| Iggy Suarez | SS | AAA | | 2002-2013 | Texas State |
| Michael Sudberg | OF | NCAA | | 2005-2005 | Long Island-Brooklyn |
| Norberto Susini | C | AAA | | 2011-2019 | Odessa |
| Bill Swanson | 2B-3B | MLB | 1914-1914 | 1914-1914 | --- |
| Tony Tarasco | RF-LF | MLB | 1993-2002 | 1988-2002 | --- |
| Don Taussig | OF | MLB | 1958-1962 | 1958-1962 | Hofstra |
| Mike Terhune | 3B | AA | | 1996-2002 | NC State, Virginia Tech |
| John Terista | SS | --- | | | Ithaca College |
| Nick Testa | C | --- | | | Florida |
| Denny Thomas | P | AA | | 1980-1983 | --- |
| Robert Thomas | P | A+ | | 1994-1995 | --- |
| Rich Thompson | P | MLB | 1985-1990 | 1980-1994 | Amherst College |
| Tom Thulin | OF | Rk | | 2000-2000 | Connecticut |
| Tim Timlin | P | A+ | | 1979-1981 | Pennsylvania |
| Tim Tisch | P | A | | 2002-2007 | San Diego Mesa College |
| Kevin Tise | P | NCAA | | 2015-2019 | Hartford, Mercy College |
| Specs Toporcer | SS-2B | MLB | 1921-1928 | 1921-1928 | --- |
| Brandon Torres | IF-P | NCAA | | 2015-2015 | Delaware State |
| Gil Torres | OF | --- | | | --- |
| Kevin Torres | P | NCAA | | 2013-2016 | St. John's, Western Oklahoma State College |
| Luis Torres | P | A+ | | 1994-1998 | --- |
| Sharbel Torres | IF | NCAA | | 2001-2003 | Bethune-Cookman, Garden City CC |
| Phillip Trombino | 1B | --- | | | Iona College |
| Dan Troncoso | 2B | Indy | | 2001-2002 | Indiana Tech |
| Jessie Tucker | P | NCAA | | 2004-2006 | Iona College |
| Eddie Turchin | 3B-SS | MLB | 1943-1943 | 1943-1943 | Brooklyn College |
| Mike Tyler | C | AAA | | 1977-1980 | St. John's |
| Scott Ullger | 1B | MLB | 1983-1983 | 1977-1987 | St. John's |
| Andrew Urena | P | Rk | | 2005-2006 | Mercer |
| Joel Urena | P | Rk | | 2017-2017 | Monroe CC |
| Bradley Valdez | 1B | Rk | | 2012-2015 | --- |
| Mike Vallarelli | C | A- | | 1994-1999 | --- |
| John Valle | 3B | AAA | | 1977-1984 | --- |
| Elvin Vargas | OF | Rk | | 2007-2009 | Connors State College, Alabama |
| Danny Vasquez | OF | A+ | | 1994-2000 | Rockland CC |
| Juan Vasquez | C | Rk | | 2017-2019 | --- |
| Miguel Vasquez | SS | Rk | | 2007-2008 | Seminole Florida, Indian River CC |
| James Vaughn | P | --- | | | Duke |
| Vince Ventura | OF | MLB | 1945-1945 | 1945-1945 | --- |
| Kelvin Vizcaino | LF | Rk | | 2010-2012 | --- |
| Heinie Wagner | SS | MLB | 1902-1918 | 1902-1918 | --- |
| Joe Wagner | 2B-SS | MLB | 1915-1915 | 1915-1915 | --- |
| David Wallace | SS-OF | A | | 1990-1992 | Howard College |
| B.J. Warner | IF | NCAA | | 2001-2002 | Stetson |
| John Warner | C | MLB | 1895-1908 | 1895-1908 | --- |
| Hal Warnock | OF | MLB | 1935-1935 | 1935-1935 | Arizona |
| Allen Watson | P | MLB | 1993-2000 | 1991-2002 | New York Tech |
| Randy Weisner | C | Rk | | 1995-1995 | --- |
| Jonny Weiss | IF | NCAA | | 2005-2008 | Boston College, Tulane |
| Lew Wendell | C | MLB | 1915-1926 | 1915-1926 | --- |
| Jack White | 2B-SS | MLB | 1927-1928 | 1927-1928 | Fordham |
| Austin Willis-Greene | P | Indy | | 2017-2019 | Alcorn State, Saint Catharine College |
| Tyler Wincig | P-IF | NCAA | | 2017-2020 | Bucknell |
| Bobby Wine | SS | MLB | 1960-1972 | 1960-1972 | --- |
| Alex Young | P | NCAA | | 2009-2011 | Yale |
| Sal Yvars | C | MLB | 1947-1954 | 1947-1954 | --- |
| Vince Zarate | OF-2B | A | | 1990-1995 | --- |
| Heinie Zimmerman | 3B-2B | MLB | 1907-1919 | 1907-1919 | --- |
| 544 record(s) |
