| 2013 | Cleveland | Indians | MLB-AL | Central | 26 | 18 | .591 | 1 | Terry Francona | Progressive Field | | dnq |
| 2012 | Cleveland | Indians | MLB-AL | Central | 68 | 94 | .420 | 4 | Manny Acta | Progressive Field | Tyler Naquin (#15) | dnq |
| 2011 | Cleveland | Indians | MLB-AL | Central | 80 | 82 | .494 | 2 | Manny Acta | Progressive Field | Francisco Lindor (#8) | dnq |
| 2010 | Cleveland | Indians | MLB-AL | Central | 69 | 93 | .426 | 4 | Manny Acta | Progressive Field | Drew Pomeranz (#5) | dnq |
| 2009 | Cleveland | Indians | MLB-AL | Central | 65 | 97 | .401 | 4 | Eric Wedge | Progressive Field | Alex White (#15) | dnq |
| 2008 | Cleveland | Indians | MLB-AL | Central | 81 | 81 | .500 | 3 | Eric Wedge | Progressive Field | Lonnie Chisenhall (#29) | dnq |
| 2007 | Cleveland | Indians | MLB-AL | Central | 96 | 66 | .593 | 1 | Eric Wedge | Jacobs Field | Beau Mills (#13) | Lost in ALCS (Boston) |
| 2006 | Cleveland | Indians | MLB-AL | Central | 78 | 84 | .481 | 4 | Eric Wedge | Jacobs Field | David Huff (#39) | dnq |
| 2005 | Cleveland | Indians | MLB-AL | Central | 93 | 69 | .574 | 2 | Eric Wedge | Jacobs Field | Trevor Crowe (#14) | dnq |
| 2004 | Cleveland | Indians | MLB-AL | Central | 80 | 82 | .494 | 3 | Eric Wedge | Jacobs Field | Jeremy Sowers (#6) | dnq |
| 2003 | Cleveland | Indians | MLB-AL | Central | 68 | 94 | .420 | 4 | Eric Wedge | Jacobs Field | Michael Aubrey (#11) | dnq |
| 2002 | Cleveland | Indians | MLB-AL | Central | 74 | 88 | .457 | 3 | Charlie Manuel Joel Skinner | Jacobs Field | Jeremy Guthrie (#22) | dnq |
| 2001 | Cleveland | Indians | MLB-AL | Central | 91 | 71 | .562 | 1 | Charlie Manuel | Jacobs Field | Dan Denham (#17) | Lost in 1st Round (Mariners) |
| 2000 | Cleveland | Indians | MLB-AL | Central | 90 | 72 | .556 | 2 | Charlie Manuel | Jacobs Field | Corey Smith (#26) | dnq |
| 1999 | Cleveland | Indians | MLB-AL | Central | 97 | 65 | .599 | 1 | Mike Hargrove | Jacobs Field | Will Hartley (#74) | Lost in 1st Round (Red Sox) |
| 1998 | Cleveland | Indians | MLB-AL | Central | 89 | 73 | .549 | 1 | Mike Hargrove | Jacobs Field | C.C. Sabathia (#20) | Lost ALCS (Yankees) |
| 1997 | Cleveland | Indians | MLB-AL | Central | 86 | 75 | .534 | 1 | Mike Hargrove | Jacobs Field | Tim Drew (#28) | Lost World Series (Marlins) |
| 1996 | Cleveland | Indians | MLB-AL | Central | 99 | 62 | .615 | 1 | Mike Hargrove | Jacobs Field | Danny Peoples (#28) | Lost in 1st Round (Orioles) |
| 1995 | Cleveland | Indians | MLB-AL | Central | 100 | 44 | .694 | 1 | Mike Hargrove | Jacobs Field | David Miller (#23) | Lost World Series (Braves) |
| 1994 | Cleveland | Indians | MLB-AL | Central | 66 | 47 | .584 | 2 | Mike Hargrove | Jacobs Field | Jaret Wright (#10) | dnq |
| 1993 | Cleveland | Indians | MLB-AL | East | 76 | 86 | .469 | 6 | Mike Hargrove | Cleveland Stadium | Daron Kirkreit (#11) | dnq |
| 1992 | Cleveland | Indians | MLB-AL | East | 76 | 86 | .469 | 5 | Mike Hargrove | Cleveland Stadium | Paul Shuey (#2) | dnq |
| 1991 | Cleveland | Indians | MLB-AL | East | 57 | 105 | .352 | 7 | Mike Hargrove John McNamara | Cleveland Stadium | Manny Ramirez (#13) | dnq |
| 1990 | Cleveland | Indians | MLB-AL | East | 77 | 85 | .475 | 4 | John McNamara | Cleveland Stadium | Tim Costo (#8) | dnq |
| 1989 | Cleveland | Indians | MLB-AL | East | 73 | 89 | .451 | 6 | Doc Edwards John Hart | Cleveland Stadium | Calvin Murray (#11) | dnq |
| 1988 | Cleveland | Indians | MLB-AL | East | 78 | 84 | .481 | 6 | Doc Edwards | Cleveland Stadium | Mark Lewis (#2) | dnq |
| 1987 | Cleveland | Indians | MLB-AL | East | 61 | 101 | .377 | 7 | Pat Corrales Doc Edwards | Cleveland Stadium | Albert Belle (#47) | dnq |
| 1986 | Cleveland | Indians | MLB-AL | East | 84 | 78 | .519 | 5 | Pat Corrales | Cleveland Stadium | Greg Swindell (#2) | dnq |
| 1985 | Cleveland | Indians | MLB-AL | East | 60 | 102 | .370 | 7 | Pat Corrales | Cleveland Stadium | Mike Poehl (#9) | dnq |
| 1984 | Cleveland | Indians | MLB-AL | East | 75 | 87 | .463 | 6 | Pat Corrales | Cleveland Stadium | Cory Snyder (#4) | dnq |
| 1983 | Cleveland | Indians | MLB-AL | East | 70 | 92 | .432 | 7 | Mike Ferraro Pat Corrales | Cleveland Stadium | Dave Clark (#11) | dnq |
| 1982 | Cleveland | Indians | MLB-AL | East | 78 | 84 | .481 | 7 | Dave Garcia | Cleveland Stadium | Mark Snyder (#12) | dnq |
| 1981 | Cleveland | Indians | MLB-AL | East | 52 | 51 | .505 | | Dave Garcia | Cleveland Stadium | George Alpert (#13) | dnq |
| 1980 | Cleveland | Indians | MLB-AL | East | 79 | 81 | .494 | 6 | Dave Garcia | Cleveland Stadium | Kelly Gruber (#10) | dnq |
| 1979 | Cleveland | Indians | MLB-AL | East | 81 | 80 | .503 | 6 | Jeff Torborg Dave Garcia | Cleveland Stadium | John Bohnet (#7) | dnq |
| 1978 | Cleveland | Indians | MLB-AL | East | 69 | 90 | .434 | 6 | Jeff Torborg | Cleveland Stadium | Phil Lansford (#10) | dnq |
| 1977 | Cleveland | Indians | MLB-AL | East | 71 | 90 | .441 | 5 | Jeff Torborg Frank Robinson | Cleveland Stadium | Bruce Compton (#11) | dnq |
| 1976 | Cleveland | Indians | MLB-AL | East | 81 | 78 | .509 | 4 | Frank Robinson | Cleveland Stadium | Tim Glass (#14) | dnq |
| 1975 | Cleveland | Indians | MLB-AL | East | 79 | 80 | .497 | 4 | Frank Robinson | Cleveland Stadium | Rick Cerone (#7) | dnq |
| 1974 | Cleveland | Indians | MLB-AL | East | 77 | 85 | .475 | 4 | Ken Aspromonte | Cleveland Stadium | Tom Brennan (#4) | dnq |
| 1973 | Cleveland | Indians | MLB-AL | East | 71 | 91 | .438 | 6 | Ken Aspromonte | Cleveland Municipal Stadium | Glenn Tufts (#5) | dnq |
| 1972 | Cleveland | Indians | MLB-AL | East | 72 | 84 | .462 | 5 | Ken Aspromonte | Cleveland Municipal Stadium | Rick Manning (#2) | dnq |
| 1971 | Cleveland | Indians | MLB-AL | East | 60 | 102 | .370 | 6 | Alvin Dark Johnny Lipon | Cleveland Municipal Stadium | David Sloan (#9) | dnq |
| 1970 | Cleveland | Indians | MLB-AL | East | 76 | 86 | .469 | 5 | Alvin Dark | Cleveland Municipal Stadium | Steve Dunning (#2) | dnq |
| 1969 | Cleveland | Indians | MLB-AL | East | 62 | 99 | .385 | 6 | Alvin Dark | Cleveland Municipal Stadium | Alvin McGrew (#15) | dnq |
| 1968 | Cleveland | Indians | MLB-AL | - | 86 | 75 | .534 | 3 | Alvin Dark | Cleveland Municipal Stadium | Robert Weaver (#6) | dnq |
| 1967 | Cleveland | Indians | MLB-AL | - | 75 | 87 | .463 | 8 | Joe Adcock | Cleveland Municipal Stadium | Jack Heidemann (#11) | dnq |
| 1966 | Cleveland | Indians | MLB-AL | - | 81 | 81 | .500 | 5 | Birdie Tebbetts George Strickland | Cleveland Municipal Stadium | John Curtis (#12) | dnq |
| 1965 | Cleveland | Indians | MLB-AL | - | 87 | 75 | .537 | 5 | Birdie Tebbetts | Cleveland Municipal Stadium | Ray Fosse (#7) | dnq |
| 1964 | Cleveland | Indians | MLB-AL | - | 79 | 83 | .488 | 7 | Birdie Tebbetts George Strickland | Cleveland Municipal Stadium | | dnq |
| 1963 | Cleveland | Indians | MLB-AL | - | 79 | 83 | .488 | 6 | Birdie Tebbetts | Cleveland Municipal Stadium | | dnq |
| 1962 | Cleveland | Indians | MLB-AL | - | 80 | 82 | .494 | 6 | Mel McGaha Mel Harder | Cleveland Municipal Stadium | | dnq |
| 1961 | Cleveland | Indians | MLB-AL | - | 78 | 83 | .484 | 5 | Jimmy Dykes Mel Harder | Cleveland Municipal Stadium | | dnq |
| 1960 | Cleveland | Indians | MLB-AL | - | 76 | 78 | .494 | 4 | Joe Gordon Jimmy Dykes Jo-Jo White | Cleveland Municipal Stadium | | dnq |
| 1959 | Cleveland | Indians | MLB-AL | - | 89 | 65 | .578 | 2 | Joe Gordon | Cleveland Municipal Stadium | | dnq |
| 1958 | Cleveland | Indians | MLB-AL | - | 77 | 76 | .503 | 4 | Joe Gordon Bobby Bragan | Cleveland Municipal Stadium | | dnq |
| 1957 | Cleveland | Indians | MLB-AL | - | 76 | 77 | .497 | 6 | Kerby Farrell | Cleveland Municipal Stadium | | dnq |
| 1956 | Cleveland | Indians | MLB-AL | - | 88 | 66 | .571 | 2 | Al Lopez | Cleveland Municipal Stadium | | dnq |
| 1955 | Cleveland | Indians | MLB-AL | - | 93 | 61 | .604 | 2 | Al Lopez | Cleveland Municipal Stadium | | dnq |
| 1954 | Cleveland | Indians | MLB-AL | - | 111 | 43 | .721 | 1 | Al Lopez | Cleveland Municipal Stadium | | Lost World Series (Giants) |
| 1953 | Cleveland | Indians | MLB-AL | - | 92 | 62 | .597 | 2 | Al Lopez | Cleveland Municipal Stadium | | dnq |
| 1952 | Cleveland | Indians | MLB-AL | - | 93 | 61 | .604 | 2 | Al Lopez | Cleveland Municipal Stadium | | dnq |
| 1951 | Cleveland | Indians | MLB-AL | - | 93 | 61 | .604 | 2 | Al Lopez | Cleveland Municipal Stadium | | dnq |
| 1950 | Cleveland | Indians | MLB-AL | - | 92 | 62 | .597 | 4 | Lou Boudreau | Cleveland Municipal Stadium | | dnq |
| 1949 | Cleveland | Indians | MLB-AL | - | 89 | 65 | .578 | 3 | Lou Boudreau | Cleveland Municipal Stadium | | dnq |
| 1948 | Cleveland | Indians | MLB-AL | - | 97 | 58 | .626 | 1 | Lou Boudreau | Cleveland Municipal Stadium | | Won World Series (Braves) |
| 1947 | Cleveland | Indians | MLB-AL | - | 80 | 74 | .519 | 4 | Lou Boudreau | Cleveland Municipal Stadium | | dnq |
| 1946 | Cleveland | Indians | MLB-AL | - | 68 | 86 | .442 | 6 | Lou Boudreau | Cleveland Municipal Stadium,League Park | | dnq |
| 1945 | Cleveland | Indians | MLB-AL | - | 73 | 72 | .503 | 5 | Lou Boudreau | Cleveland Municipal Stadium,League Park | | dnq |
| 1944 | Cleveland | Indians | MLB-AL | - | 72 | 82 | .468 | 6 | Lou Boudreau | Cleveland Municipal Stadium,League Park | | dnq |
| 1943 | Cleveland | Indians | MLB-AL | - | 82 | 71 | .536 | 3 | Lou Boudreau | Cleveland Municipal Stadium,League Park | | dnq |
| 1942 | Cleveland | Indians | MLB-AL | - | 75 | 79 | .487 | 4 | Lou Boudreau | Cleveland Municipal Stadium,League Park | | dnq |
| 1941 | Cleveland | Indians | MLB-AL | - | 75 | 79 | .487 | 5 | Roger Peckinpaugh | Cleveland Municipal Stadium,League Park | | dnq |
| 1940 | Cleveland | Indians | MLB-AL | - | 89 | 65 | .578 | 2 | Ossie Vitt | Cleveland Municipal Stadium,League Park | | dnq |
| 1939 | Cleveland | Indians | MLB-AL | - | 87 | 67 | .565 | 3 | Ossie Vitt | Cleveland Municipal Stadium,League Park | | dnq |
| 1938 | Cleveland | Indians | MLB-AL | - | 86 | 66 | .566 | 3 | Ossie Vitt | Cleveland Municipal Stadium,League Park | | dnq |
| 1937 | Cleveland | Indians | MLB-AL | - | 83 | 71 | .539 | 4 | Steve O'Neill | Cleveland Municipal Stadium,League Park | | dnq |
| 1936 | Cleveland | Indians | MLB-AL | - | 80 | 74 | .519 | 5 | Steve O'Neill | Cleveland Municipal Stadium,League Park | | dnq |
| 1935 | Cleveland | Indians | MLB-AL | - | 82 | 71 | .536 | 3 | Walter Johnson Steve O'Neill | Cleveland Municipal Stadium,League Park | | dnq |
| 1934 | Cleveland | Indians | MLB-AL | - | 85 | 69 | .552 | 3 | Walter Johnson | Cleveland Municipal Stadium,League Park | | dnq |
| 1933 | Cleveland | Indians | MLB-AL | - | 75 | 76 | .497 | 4 | Walter Johnson Roger Peckinpaugh Bibb Falk | Cleveland Municipal Stadium,League Park | | dnq |
| 1932 | Cleveland | Indians | MLB-AL | - | 87 | 65 | .572 | 4 | Roger Peckinpaugh | Cleveland Municipal Stadium,League Park | | dnq |
| 1931 | Cleveland | Indians | MLB-AL | - | 78 | 76 | .506 | 4 | Roger Peckinpaugh | League Park | | dnq |
| 1930 | Cleveland | Indians | MLB-AL | - | 81 | 73 | .526 | 4 | Roger Peckinpaugh | League Park | | dnq |
| 1929 | Cleveland | Indians | MLB-AL | - | 81 | 71 | .533 | 3 | Roger Peckinpaugh | League Park | | dnq |
| 1928 | Cleveland | Indians | MLB-AL | - | 62 | 92 | .403 | 7 | Roger Peckinpaugh | League Park | | dnq |
| 1927 | Cleveland | Indians | MLB-AL | - | 66 | 87 | .431 | 6 | Jack McCallister | League Park | | dnq |
| 1926 | Cleveland | Indians | MLB-AL | - | 88 | 66 | .571 | 2 | Tris Speaker | League Park | | dnq |
| 1925 | Cleveland | Indians | MLB-AL | - | 70 | 84 | .455 | 6 | Tris Speaker | League Park | | dnq |
| 1924 | Cleveland | Indians | MLB-AL | - | 67 | 86 | .438 | 6 | Tris Speaker | League Park | | dnq |
| 1923 | Cleveland | Indians | MLB-AL | - | 82 | 71 | .536 | 3 | Tris Speaker | League Park | | dnq |
| 1922 | Cleveland | Indians | MLB-AL | - | 78 | 76 | .506 | 4 | Tris Speaker | League Park | | dnq |
| 1921 | Cleveland | Indians | MLB-AL | - | 94 | 60 | .610 | 2 | Tris Speaker | League Park | | dnq |
| 1920 | Cleveland | Indians | MLB-AL | - | 98 | 56 | .636 | 1 | Tris Speaker | League Park | | Won World Series (Robins) |
| 1919 | Cleveland | Indians | MLB-AL | - | 84 | 55 | .604 | 2 | Lee Fohl Tris Speaker | League Park | | dnq |
| 1918 | Cleveland | Indians | MLB-AL | - | 73 | 54 | .575 | 2 | Lee Fohl | League Park | | dnq |
| 1917 | Cleveland | Indians | MLB-AL | - | 88 | 66 | .571 | 3 | Lee Fohl | League Park | | dnq |
| 1916 | Cleveland | Indians | MLB-AL | - | 77 | 77 | .500 | 6 | Lee Fohl | League Park | | dnq |
| 1915 | Cleveland | Indians | MLB-AL | - | 57 | 95 | .375 | 7 | Lee Fohl Joe Birmingham | League Park | | dnq |
| 1914 | Cleveland | Naps | MLB-AL | - | 51 | 102 | .333 | 8 | Joe Birmingham | League Park | | dnq |
| 1913 | Cleveland | Naps | MLB-AL | - | 86 | 66 | .566 | 3 | Joe Birmingham | League Park | | dnq |
| 1912 | Cleveland | Naps | MLB-AL | - | 75 | 78 | .490 | 5 | Harry Davis Joe Birmingham | League Park | | dnq |
| 1911 | Cleveland | Naps | MLB-AL | - | 80 | 73 | .523 | 3 | George Stovall Deacon McGuire | League Park | | dnq |
| 1910 | Cleveland | Naps | MLB-AL | - | 71 | 81 | .467 | 5 | Deacon McGuire | League Park | | dnq |
| 1909 | Cleveland | Naps | MLB-AL | - | 71 | 82 | .464 | 6 | Nap Lajoie Deacon McGuire | League Park | | dnq |
| 1908 | Cleveland | Naps | MLB-AL | - | 90 | 64 | .584 | 2 | Nap Lajoie | League Park | | dnq |
| 1907 | Cleveland | Naps | MLB-AL | - | 85 | 67 | .559 | 4 | Nap Lajoie | League Park | | dnq |
| 1906 | Cleveland | Naps | MLB-AL | - | 89 | 64 | .582 | 3 | Nap Lajoie | League Park | | dnq |
| 1905 | Cleveland | Naps | MLB-AL | - | 76 | 78 | .494 | 5 | Nap Lajoie Bill Bradley | League Park | | dnq |
| 1904 | Cleveland | Naps | MLB-AL | - | 86 | 65 | .570 | 4 | Bill Armour | League Park | | dnq |
| 1903 | Cleveland | Naps | MLB-AL | - | 77 | 63 | .550 | 3 | Bill Armour | League Park | | dnq |