| Year | Team Name | League | Division | W | L | Pct | Rank | Overall | Managers | Stadium | Top Draft Pick | Playoffs | |
| 2012 | Wagner College | Seahawks | NEC | - | 15 | 17 | .469 | 6 | 22-33 | Jim Carone | Richmond County Bank Ballpark | dnq | |
| 2011 | Wagner College | Seahawks | NEC | - | 12 | 20 | .375 | 6 | 18-33 | Joe Litterio | Richmond County Bank Ballpark | dnq | |
| 2010 | Wagner College | Seahawks | NEC | - | 17 | 15 | .531 | 4 | 26-31 | Joe Litterio | Richmond County Bank Ballpark | dnq | |
| 2009 | Wagner College | Seahawks | NEC | - | 17 | 9 | .654 | 1 | 31-21 | Joe Litterio | Richmond County Bank Ballpark | Kyle Morrison (#952) | dnq |
| 2008 | Wagner College | Seahawks | NEC | - | 17 | 11 | .607 | 3 | 27-28 | Joe Litterio | Richmond County Bank Ballpark | dnq | |
| 2007 | Wagner College | Seahawks | NEC | - | 11 | 17 | .393 | 6 | 17-34 | Joe Litterio | Dr. Bill Willetts Field | Joseph Digeronimo (#1248) | dnq |
| 2006 | Wagner College | Seahawks | NEC | - | 15 | 9 | .625 | 3 | 18-34 | Joe Litterio | Dr. Bill Willetts Field | Andrew Bailey (#188) | dnq |
| 2005 | Wagner College | Seahawks | NEC | - | 13 | 10 | .565 | 4 | 22-27 | Joe Litterio | Dr. Bill Willetts Field | Andrew Bailey (#475) | dnq |
| 2004 | Wagner College | Seahawks | NEC | - | 12 | 11 | .522 | 4 | 20-29 | Joe Litterio | Dr. Bill Willetts Field | Conf. Finalists | |
| 2003 | Wagner College | Seahawks | NEC | - | 10 | 16 | .385 | 9 | 11-36 | Joe Litterio | Dr. Bill Willetts Field | dnq | |