Yearly RecordS = Statistics D = Draft Picks R = Rosters O = Organizational Rosters Box = Boxscores
| 2009 | NYPL | McNamara | S - R | 47 | 29 | .618 | - | 1 | NYY | | League Champions | | 2008 | NYPL | McNamara | S - R | 49 | 26 | .653 | - | 1 | NYY | Pat McMahon | Lost in Semi-Finals | | 2007 | NYPL | McNamara | S - R | 47 | 28 | .627 | 2.5 | 2 | NYY | Mike Gillespie | Lost in Semi-Finals | | 2006 | NYPL | McNamara | S - R | 45 | 29 | .608 | - | 1 | NYY | Gaylen Pitts | League Champions | | 2005 | NYPL | McNamara | S - R | 52 | 24 | .684 | | | NYY | | League Champions | | 2004 | NYPL | McNamara | S - R | 28 | 44 | .389 | 14.0 | 6 | NYY | Tommy John | dnq | | 2003 | NYPL | McNamara | S - R | 29 | 43 | .403 | 16.5 | 6 | NYY | Andy Stankiewicz | dnq | | 2002 | NYPL | McNamara | S - R | 48 | 26 | .649 | - | 1 | NYY | Derek Shelton | League Champions | | 2001 | NYPL | Stedler | S - R | 48 | 28 | .632 | 4.0 | 2 | NYY | David Jorn | Lost in Semi-Finals | | 2000 | NYPL | Stedler | S - R | 46 | 28 | .622 | 0.5 | 2 | NYY | Joe Arnold | League Champions | | 1999 | NYPL | McNamara | S - R | 39 | 35 | .527 | 2.0 | 5 | NYY | Joe Arnold | dnq |
|