| Year | Team Name | League | Division | W | L | Pct | Rank | Overall | Managers | Stadium | Top Draft Pick | Playoffs | |
| 2012 | College of William and Mary | Tribe | CAA | - | 12 | 18 | .400 | 9 | 31-25 | Frank Leoni | Plumeri Park | Matt Davenport (#1054) | dnq |
| 2011 | College of William and Mary | Tribe | CAA | - | 16 | 14 | .533 | 6 | 26-29 | Frank Leoni | Plumeri Park | dnq | |
| 2010 | College of William and Mary | Tribe | CAA | - | 10 | 14 | .417 | 8 | 27-24 | Frank Leoni | Plumeri Park | dnq | |
| 2009 | College of William and Mary | Tribe | CAA | - | 9 | 14 | .391 | 9 | 24-25 | Frank Leoni | Plumeri Park | Kevin Landry (#626) | dnq |
| 2008 | College of William and Mary | Tribe | CAA | - | 16 | 13 | .552 | 4 | 36-21 | Frank Leoni | Plumeri Park | Mike Sheridan (#143) | dnq |
| 2007 | College of William and Mary | Tribe | CAA | - | 13 | 16 | .448 | 7 | 29-25 | Frank Leoni | Plumeri Park | Greg Sexton (#305) | dnq |
| 2006 | College of William and Mary | Tribe | CAA | - | 11 | 19 | .367 | 9 | 23-29 | Frank Leoni | Plumeri Park | Joe Kantakevich (#381) | dnq |
| 2005 | College of William and Mary | Tribe | CAA | - | 9 | 15 | .375 | 7 | 27-27 | Jim Farr | Plumeri Park | Chris Rahl (#141) | dnq |
| 2004 | College of William and Mary | Tribe | CAA | - | 14 | 10 | .583 | 3 | 37-20 | Jim Farr | Plumeri Park | Bill Bray (#13) | dnq |
| 2003 | College of William and Mary | Tribe | CAA | Colonial | 12 | 4 | .750 | 2 | 31-20 | Jim Farr | Plumeri Park | Chris Ray (#74) | dnq |
| 2002 | College of William and Mary | Tribe | CAA | Colonial | 12 | 9 | .571 | 4 | 32-26 | Plumeri Park | dnq | ||