| Year | Team Name | League | Division | W | L | Pct | Rank | Overall | Managers | Stadium | Top Draft Pick | Playoffs | |
| 2012 | Liberty | Flames | BigSou | - | 14 | 10 | .583 | 3 | 41-19 | Jim Toman | Worthington Stadium | Ian Parmley (#235) | Conference Finalists |
| 2011 | Liberty | Flames | BigSou | - | 18 | 9 | .667 | 2 | 35-24 | Jim Toman | Worthington Stadium | Garrett Baker (#345) | dnq |
| 2010 | Liberty | Flames | BigSou | - | 19 | 8 | .704 | 2 | 42-19 | Jim Toman | Worthington Stadium | Shawn Teufel (#763) | Conference Finalists |
| 2009 | Liberty | Flames | BigSou | - | 17 | 9 | .654 | 3 | 33-21 | Jim Toman | Worthington Stadium | Andrew Wilson (#1078) | dnq |
| 2008 | Liberty | Flames | BigSou | - | 14 | 7 | .667 | 2 | 35-26 | Jim Toman | Worthington Stadium | Ryan Page (#609) | Conf Finalists |
| 2007 | Liberty | Flames | BigSou | - | 14 | 7 | .667 | 3 | 36-25 | Jim Toman | Worthington Stadium | Michael Solbach (#583) | Conf Finalists |
| 2006 | Liberty | Flames | BigSou | - | 14 | 10 | .583 | 4 | 36-19 | Matt Royer | Worthington Stadium | Michael Solbach (#1429) | Conf Finalists |
| 2005 | Liberty | Flames | BigSou | - | 14 | 10 | .583 | 4 | 36-19 | Matt Royer | Worthington Stadium | David Bechtold (#837) | dnq |
| 2004 | Liberty | Flames | BigSou | - | 9 | 15 | .375 | 7 | 25-30 | Matt Royer | Worthington Stadium | Jason Jones (#129) | dnq |
| 2003 | Liberty | Flames | BigSou | - | 7 | 12 | .368 | 6 | 17-37 | Matt Royer | Worthington Stadium | Larry York (#417) | Conf. Finalists |
| 2002 | Liberty | Flames | BigSou | - | 11 | 9 | .550 | 4 | 33-24 | Matt Royer | Worthington Stadium | Joey Monahan (#213) | Conf. Finalists |