| Year | Team Name | League | Division | Affilate | W | L | Pct | Rank | Managers | Stadium | Playoffs | |
| 2013 | Princeton | Rays | App | East | TB | 0 | 0 | -- | 0 | H.P. Hunnicut Field | dnq | |
| 2012 | Princeton | Rays | App | East | TB | 36 | 32 | .529 | 3 | Mike Johns | H.P. Hunnicut Field | dnq |
| 2011 | Princeton | Rays | App | East | TB | 30 | 38 | .441 | 4 | Mike Johns | H.P. Hunnicut Field | dnq |
| 2010 | Princeton | Rays | App | East | TB | 33 | 35 | .485 | 4 | Mike Johns | H.P. Hunnicut Field | dnq |
| 2009 | Princeton | Rays | App | East | TB | 36 | 31 | .537 | 2 | Jared Sandberg | H.P. Hunnicut Field | dnq |
| 2008 | Princeton | Devil Rays | App | East | TB | 24 | 38 | .387 | 4 | Joe Szekely | H.P. Hunnicut Field | dnq |
| 2007 | Princeton | Devil Rays | App | East | TB | 33 | 35 | .485 | 3 | Jamie Nelson | H.P. Hunnicut Field | dnq |
| 2006 | Princeton | Devil Rays | App | East | TB | 28 | 36 | .438 | 5 | Jamie Nelson | H.P. Hunnicut Field | dnq |
| 2005 | Princeton | Devil Rays | App | Eastern | TB | 34 | 31 | .523 | 3 | Jamie Nelson | H.P. Hunnicut Field | dnq |
| 2004 | Princeton | Devil Rays | App | Eastern | TB | 23 | 44 | .343 | 5 | Jamie Nelson | H.P. Hunnicut Field | dnq |
| 2003 | Princeton | Devil Rays | App | Eastern | TB | 23 | 41 | .359 | 5 | Jamie Nelson | H.P. Hunnicut Field | dnq |
| 2002 | Princeton | Devil Rays | App | Eastern | TB | 19 | 49 | .279 | 5 | Edwin Rodriguez | H.P. Hunnicut Field | dnq |
| 2001 | Princeton | Devil Rays | App | North | TB | 28 | 39 | .418 | 5 | Edwin Rodriguez | H.P. Hunnicut Field | dnq |
| 2000 | Princeton | Devil Rays | App | North | TB | 34 | 34 | .500 | 2 | Edwin Rodriguez | H.P. Hunnicut Field | dnq |
| 1999 | Princeton | Devil Rays | App | North | TB | 25 | 45 | .357 | 4 | Bobby Ramos | H.P. Hunnicut Field | dnq |
| 1998 | Princeton | Devil Rays | App | North | TB | 38 | 30 | .559 | 1 | David Howard | H.P. Hunnicut Field | Lost in Finals |
| 1997 | Princeton | Devil Rays | App | North | TB | 39 | 30 | .565 | 2 | Charlie Montoyo | H.P. Hunnicut Field | dnq |
| 1996 | Princeton | Reds | App | North | CIN | 28 | 40 | .412 | 4 | Mark Wagner | H.P. Hunnicut Field | dnq |
| 1995 | Princeton | Reds | App | North | CIN | 31 | 32 | .492 | 2 | Brad Kelley | H.P. Hunnicut Field | dnq |
| 1994 | Princeton | Reds | App | North | CIN | 41 | 25 | .621 | 1 | John Stearns | H.P. Hunnicut Field | League Champions |
| 1993 | Princeton | Reds | App | North | CIN | 26 | 42 | .382 | 4 | Tom Dunbar | H.P. Hunnicut Field | dnq |
| 1992 | Princeton | Reds | App | Northern | CIN | 34 | 31 | .523 | 3 | Sam Mejias | H.P. Hunnicut Field | dnq |
| 1991 | Princeton | Reds | App | - | CIN | 24 | 40 | .375 | 9 | Sam Mejias | H.P. Hunnicut Field | dnq |
| 1990 | Princeton | Patriots | App | - | - | 31 | 36 | .463 | 7 | Eli Grba | H.P. Hunnicut Field | dnq |
| 1989 | Princeton | Pirates | App | Northern | PIT | 32 | 37 | .464 | 2 | Julio Garcia | H.P. Hunnicut Field | dnq |
| 1988 | Princeton | Pirates | App | Northern | PIT | 33 | 37 | .471 | 3 | Jim Thrift | H.P. Hunnicut Field | dnq |