| 2012-04-06 | Nolan Reimold (lf) | J.J. Hardy (ss) | Nick Markakis (rf) | Adam Jones (cf) | Matt Wieters (c) | Wilson Betemit (dh) | Mark Reynolds (3b) | Chris Davis (1b) | Robert Andino (2b) |
| 2012-04-07 | Nolan Reimold (lf) | J.J. Hardy (ss) | Nick Markakis (rf) | Adam Jones (cf) | Matt Wieters (c) | Mark Reynolds (3b) | Nick Johnson (1b) | Ronny Paulino (dh) | Robert Andino (2b) |
| 2012-04-08 | Endy Chavez (lf) | J.J. Hardy (ss) | Nick Markakis (rf) | Adam Jones (cf) | Matt Wieters (c) | Nick Johnson (dh) | Wilson Betemit (3b) | Chris Davis (1b) | Robert Andino (2b) |
| 2012-04-09 | Nolan Reimold (lf) | J.J. Hardy (ss) | Nick Markakis (rf) | Adam Jones (cf) | Matt Wieters (c) | Mark Reynolds (3b) | Wilson Betemit (dh) | Chris Davis (1b) | Robert Andino (2b) |
| 2012-04-10 | Endy Chavez (lf) | J.J. Hardy (ss) | Nick Markakis (rf) | Adam Jones (cf) | Matt Wieters (c) | Nick Johnson (dh) | Mark Reynolds (3b) | Chris Davis (1b) | Robert Andino (2b) |
| 2012-04-11 | Nolan Reimold (lf) | J.J. Hardy (ss) | Nick Markakis (rf) | Adam Jones (cf) | Matt Wieters (c) | Mark Reynolds (3b) | Ronny Paulino (dh) | Wilson Betemit (1b) | Robert Andino (2b) |
| 2012-04-13 | Nolan Reimold (lf) | J.J. Hardy (ss) | Nick Markakis (rf) | Adam Jones (cf) | Matt Wieters (c) | Wilson Betemit (3b) | Mark Reynolds (dh) | Chris Davis (1b) | Robert Andino (2b) |
| 2012-04-14 | Nolan Reimold (lf) | J.J. Hardy (ss) | Nick Markakis (rf) | Adam Jones (cf) | Matt Wieters (c) | Wilson Betemit (3b) | Mark Reynolds (dh) | Chris Davis (1b) | Robert Andino (2b) |
| 2012-04-15 | Endy Chavez (lf) | Nick Johnson (dh) | Nick Markakis (rf) | Adam Jones (cf) | Wilson Betemit (3b) | Chris Davis (1b) | Ronny Paulino (c) | Ryan Flaherty (2b) | Robert Andino (ss) |
| 2012-04-16 | Endy Chavez (lf) | J.J. Hardy (ss) | Nick Markakis (rf) | Adam Jones (cf) | Matt Wieters (c) | Nick Johnson (dh) | Mark Reynolds (3b) | Chris Davis (1b) | Robert Andino (2b) |
| 2012-04-17 | Nolan Reimold (lf) | J.J. Hardy (ss) | Nick Markakis (rf) | Adam Jones (cf) | Matt Wieters (c) | Mark Reynolds (dh) | Wilson Betemit (3b) | Chris Davis (1b) | Robert Andino (2b) |
| 2012-04-18 | Nolan Reimold (lf) | J.J. Hardy (ss) | Nick Markakis (dh) | Adam Jones (cf) | Matt Wieters (c) | Endy Chavez (rf) | Mark Reynolds (3b) | Chris Davis (1b) | Robert Andino (2b) |
| 2012-04-19 | Endy Chavez (lf) | J.J. Hardy (ss) | Nick Markakis (rf) | Adam Jones (cf) | Nick Johnson (dh) | Mark Reynolds (3b) | Chris Davis (1b) | Ronny Paulino (c) | Robert Andino (2b) |
| 2012-04-20 | Nolan Reimold (lf) | J.J. Hardy (ss) | Nick Markakis (rf) | Adam Jones (cf) | Matt Wieters (c) | Wilson Betemit (3b) | Mark Reynolds (dh) | Chris Davis (1b) | Robert Andino (2b) |
| 2012-04-21 | Endy Chavez (lf) | J.J. Hardy (ss) | Nick Markakis (rf) | Adam Jones (cf) | Matt Wieters (c) | Nick Johnson (dh) | Mark Reynolds (3b) | Chris Davis (1b) | Robert Andino (2b) |
| 2012-04-22 | Endy Chavez (lf) | J.J. Hardy (ss) | Nick Markakis (rf) | Adam Jones (cf) | Chris Davis (1b) | Mark Reynolds (dh) | Wilson Betemit (3b) | Ronny Paulino (c) | Robert Andino (2b) |
| 2012-04-24 | Endy Chavez (lf) | J.J. Hardy (ss) | Nick Markakis (rf) | Adam Jones (cf) | Matt Wieters (c) | Chris Davis (1b) | Wilson Betemit (dh) | Ryan Flaherty (3b) | Robert Andino (2b) |
| 2012-04-25 | Endy Chavez (lf) | J.J. Hardy (ss) | Nick Markakis (rf) | Adam Jones (cf) | Matt Wieters (c) | Chris Davis (1b) | Wilson Betemit (3b) | Mark Reynolds (dh) | Ryan Flaherty (2b) |
| 2012-04-26 | Nolan Reimold (lf) | J.J. Hardy (ss) | Nick Markakis (rf) | Adam Jones (cf) | Matt Wieters (c) | Chris Davis (dh) | Mark Reynolds (3b) | Nick Johnson (1b) | Ryan Flaherty (2b) |
| 2012-04-27 | Nolan Reimold (lf) | J.J. Hardy (ss) | Nick Markakis (rf) | Adam Jones (cf) | Matt Wieters (c) | Chris Davis (1b) | Mark Reynolds (dh) | Ryan Flaherty (3b) | Robert Andino (2b) |
| 2012-04-28 | Nolan Reimold (lf) | J.J. Hardy (ss) | Nick Markakis (dh) | Adam Jones (cf) | Wilson Betemit (3b) | Chris Davis (1b) | Ronny Paulino (c) | Ryan Flaherty (rf) | Robert Andino (2b) |
| 2012-04-29 | Nolan Reimold (lf) | J.J. Hardy (ss) | Nick Markakis (rf) | Adam Jones (cf) | Matt Wieters (c) | Chris Davis (dh) | Wilson Betemit (3b) | Mark Reynolds (1b) | Robert Andino (2b) |
| 2012-04-30 | Nolan Reimold (lf) | J.J. Hardy (ss) | Nick Markakis (rf) | Adam Jones (cf) | Matt Wieters (c) | Chris Davis (1b) | Wilson Betemit (3b) | Mark Reynolds (dh) | Robert Andino (2b) |
| 2012-05-01 | Endy Chavez (lf) | J.J. Hardy (ss) | Nick Markakis (rf) | Adam Jones (cf) | Matt Wieters (c) | Chris Davis (1b) | Wilson Betemit (3b) | Nick Johnson (dh) | Robert Andino (2b) |
| 2012-05-02 | Endy Chavez (lf) | J.J. Hardy (ss) | Nick Markakis (rf) | Adam Jones (cf) | Matt Wieters (c) | Chris Davis (1b) | Nick Johnson (dh) | Mark Reynolds (3b) | Robert Andino (2b) |
| 2012-05-04 | Robert Andino (2b) | J.J. Hardy (ss) | Nick Markakis (rf) | Adam Jones (cf) | Matt Wieters (dh) | Wilson Betemit (lf) | Chris Davis (1b) | Mark Reynolds (3b) | Ronny Paulino (c) |
| 2012-05-05 | Endy Chavez (lf) | J.J. Hardy (ss) | Nick Markakis (rf) | Adam Jones (cf) | Matt Wieters (c) | Chris Davis (1b) | Wilson Betemit (dh) | Mark Reynolds (3b) | Robert Andino (2b) |
| 2012-05-06 | Ryan Flaherty (lf) | J.J. Hardy (ss) | Nick Markakis (rf) | Adam Jones (cf) | Matt Wieters (c) | Chris Davis (dh) | Mark Reynolds (3b) | Nick Johnson (1b) | Robert Andino (2b) |
| 2012-05-07 | Robert Andino (2b) | J.J. Hardy (ss) | Nick Markakis (rf) | Adam Jones (cf) | Matt Wieters (dh) | Mark Reynolds (3b) | Wilson Betemit (lf) | Chris Davis (1b) | Luis Exposito (c) |
| 2012-05-08 | Endy Chavez (lf) | J.J. Hardy (ss) | Nick Markakis (rf) | Adam Jones (cf) | Matt Wieters (c) | Chris Davis (1b) | Wilson Betemit (3b) | Mark Reynolds (dh) | Robert Andino (2b) |
| 2012-05-10 | Ryan Flaherty (lf) | J.J. Hardy (ss) | Nick Markakis (rf) | Adam Jones (cf) | Matt Wieters (c) | Wilson Betemit (3b) | Chris Davis (dh) | Mark Reynolds (1b) | Robert Andino (2b) |
| 2012-05-10 | Robert Andino (2b) | J.J. Hardy (ss) | Nick Markakis (rf) | Adam Jones (cf) | Matt Wieters (dh) | Wilson Betemit (lf) | Mark Reynolds (1b) | Steven Tolleson (3b) | Luis Exposito (c) |
| 2012-05-11 | Ryan Flaherty (3b) | J.J. Hardy (ss) | Nick Markakis (rf) | Adam Jones (cf) | Matt Wieters (c) | Wilson Betemit (lf) | Chris Davis (1b) | Nick Johnson (dh) | Robert Andino (2b) |
| 2012-05-12 | Robert Andino (2b) | J.J. Hardy (ss) | Nick Markakis (rf) | Adam Jones (cf) | Matt Wieters (dh) | Wilson Betemit (1b) | Bill Hall (lf) | Steven Tolleson (3b) | Luis Exposito (c) |
| 2012-05-13 | Xavier Avery (lf) | J.J. Hardy (ss) | Nick Markakis (rf) | Adam Jones (cf) | Matt Wieters (c) | Nick Johnson (dh) | Chris Davis (1b) | Robert Andino (2b) | Ryan Flaherty (3b) |
| 2012-05-14 | Xavier Avery (lf) | J.J. Hardy (ss) | Nick Markakis (rf) | Adam Jones (cf) | Matt Wieters (c) | Wilson Betemit (3b) | Chris Davis (1b) | Nick Johnson (dh) | Robert Andino (2b) |
| 2012-05-15 | Robert Andino (2b) | J.J. Hardy (ss) | Nick Markakis (rf) | Adam Jones (cf) | Matt Wieters (c) | Wilson Betemit (1b) | Bill Hall (dh) | Steven Tolleson (3b) | Xavier Avery (lf) |
| 2012-05-16 | Xavier Avery (lf) | J.J. Hardy (ss) | Nick Markakis (rf) | Adam Jones (cf) | Matt Wieters (c) | Nick Johnson (dh) | Wilson Betemit (3b) | Chris Davis (1b) | Robert Andino (2b) |
| 2012-05-17 | Xavier Avery (lf) | J.J. Hardy (ss) | Nick Markakis (rf) | Adam Jones (cf) | Wilson Betemit (dh) | Chris Davis (1b) | Robert Andino (2b) | Ryan Flaherty (3b) | Luis Exposito (c) |
| 2012-05-18 | Xavier Avery (lf) | J.J. Hardy (ss) | Nick Markakis (rf) | Adam Jones (cf) | Matt Wieters (c) | Wilson Betemit (3b) | Chris Davis (1b) | Robert Andino (2b) | Jake Arrieta (p) |
| 2012-05-19 | Robert Andino (2b) | J.J. Hardy (ss) | Nick Markakis (rf) | Adam Jones (cf) | Matt Wieters (c) | Wilson Betemit (1b) | Steven Tolleson (3b) | Xavier Avery (lf) | Jason Hammel (p) |
| 2012-05-20 | Xavier Avery (lf) | J.J. Hardy (ss) | Nick Markakis (rf) | Adam Jones (cf) | Wilson Betemit (3b) | Chris Davis (1b) | Robert Andino (2b) | Luis Exposito (c) | Wei-Yin Chen (p) |
| 2012-05-21 | Xavier Avery (lf) | J.J. Hardy (ss) | Nick Markakis (rf) | Adam Jones (cf) | Matt Wieters (c) | Chris Davis (1b) | Wilson Betemit (3b) | Nick Johnson (dh) | Robert Andino (2b) |
| 2012-05-22 | Robert Andino (2b) | J.J. Hardy (ss) | Nick Markakis (rf) | Adam Jones (cf) | Matt Wieters (c) | Wilson Betemit (1b) | Chris Davis (dh) | Steven Tolleson (3b) | Xavier Avery (lf) |
| 2012-05-23 | Xavier Avery (lf) | Robert Andino (ss) | Nick Markakis (rf) | Adam Jones (cf) | Chris Davis (1b) | Wilson Betemit (3b) | Nick Johnson (dh) | Ryan Flaherty (2b) | Luis Exposito (c) |
| 2012-05-25 | Robert Andino (2b) | J.J. Hardy (ss) | Nick Markakis (rf) | Adam Jones (cf) | Matt Wieters (c) | Wilson Betemit (1b) | Chris Davis (dh) | Steven Tolleson (3b) | Xavier Avery (lf) |
| 2012-05-26 | Xavier Avery (lf) | J.J. Hardy (ss) | Nick Markakis (rf) | Adam Jones (cf) | Matt Wieters (c) | Chris Davis (1b) | Wilson Betemit (3b) | Nick Johnson (dh) | Robert Andino (2b) |
| 2012-05-27 | Xavier Avery (lf) | J.J. Hardy (ss) | Nick Markakis (rf) | Adam Jones (cf) | Matt Wieters (c) | Chris Davis (1b) | Wilson Betemit (3b) | Nick Johnson (dh) | Robert Andino (2b) |
| 2012-05-28 | Xavier Avery (lf) | J.J. Hardy (ss) | Nick Markakis (rf) | Adam Jones (cf) | Matt Wieters (c) | Wilson Betemit (3b) | Chris Davis (1b) | Mark Reynolds (dh) | Robert Andino (2b) |
| 2012-05-29 | Robert Andino (2b) | J.J. Hardy (ss) | Nick Markakis (rf) | Adam Jones (cf) | Matt Wieters (c) | Mark Reynolds (1b) | Chris Davis (dh) | Wilson Betemit (lf) | Steven Tolleson (3b) |
| 2012-05-30 | Endy Chavez (lf) | J.J. Hardy (ss) | Chris Davis (dh) | Adam Jones (cf) | Matt Wieters (c) | Mark Reynolds (1b) | Wilson Betemit (3b) | Ryan Flaherty (rf) | Robert Andino (2b) |
| 2012-06-01 | Robert Andino (2b) | Steven Tolleson (lf) | J.J. Hardy (ss) | Adam Jones (cf) | Matt Wieters (c) | Mark Reynolds (1b) | Chris Davis (dh) | Wilson Betemit (3b) | Bill Hall (rf) |
| 2012-06-02 | Endy Chavez (lf) | J.J. Hardy (ss) | Chris Davis (dh) | Adam Jones (cf) | Matt Wieters (c) | Mark Reynolds (1b) | Wilson Betemit (3b) | Ryan Flaherty (rf) | Robert Andino (2b) |
| 2012-06-03 | Robert Andino (2b) | Endy Chavez (lf) | J.J. Hardy (ss) | Adam Jones (cf) | Matt Wieters (c) | Mark Reynolds (1b) | Ronny Paulino (dh) | Steven Pearce (rf) | Steven Tolleson (3b) |
| 2012-06-05 | Robert Andino (2b) | J.J. Hardy (ss) | Adam Jones (cf) | Matt Wieters (c) | Mark Reynolds (1b) | Steven Pearce (lf) | Ronny Paulino (dh) | Steven Tolleson (3b) | Endy Chavez (rf) |
| 2012-06-06 | Endy Chavez (rf) | J.J. Hardy (ss) | Adam Jones (cf) | Matt Wieters (c) | Chris Davis (dh) | Mark Reynolds (1b) | Wilson Betemit (3b) | Ryan Flaherty (lf) | Robert Andino (2b) |
| 2012-06-07 | Endy Chavez (rf) | J.J. Hardy (ss) | Adam Jones (cf) | Matt Wieters (c) | Chris Davis (dh) | Mark Reynolds (1b) | Wilson Betemit (3b) | Ryan Flaherty (lf) | Robert Andino (2b) |
| 2012-06-08 | Endy Chavez (lf) | J.J. Hardy (ss) | Adam Jones (cf) | Matt Wieters (c) | Chris Davis (dh) | Wilson Betemit (3b) | Mark Reynolds (1b) | Ryan Flaherty (rf) | Robert Andino (2b) |
| 2012-06-09 | Endy Chavez (lf) | J.J. Hardy (ss) | Chris Davis (dh) | Adam Jones (cf) | Matt Wieters (c) | Nick Johnson (1b) | Wilson Betemit (3b) | Ryan Flaherty (rf) | Robert Andino (2b) |
| 2012-06-10 | Robert Andino (2b) | J.J. Hardy (ss) | Adam Jones (cf) | Matt Wieters (dh) | Ronny Paulino (c) | Mark Reynolds (1b) | Steven Pearce (lf) | Steven Tolleson (3b) | Endy Chavez (rf) |
| 2012-06-12 | Brian Roberts (2b) | J.J. Hardy (ss) | Chris Davis (dh) | Adam Jones (cf) | Matt Wieters (c) | Wilson Betemit (3b) | Mark Reynolds (1b) | Steven Pearce (lf) | Endy Chavez (rf) |
| 2012-06-13 | Brian Roberts (2b) | J.J. Hardy (ss) | Chris Davis (dh) | Adam Jones (cf) | Matt Wieters (c) | Mark Reynolds (1b) | Wilson Betemit (3b) | Steven Pearce (lf) | Ryan Flaherty (rf) |
| 2012-06-14 | Brian Roberts (2b) | J.J. Hardy (ss) | Chris Davis (dh) | Adam Jones (cf) | Matt Wieters (c) | Mark Reynolds (1b) | Steven Pearce (rf) | Steven Tolleson (lf) | Robert Andino (3b) |
| 2012-06-15 | Brian Roberts (2b) | J.J. Hardy (ss) | Chris Davis (rf) | Adam Jones (cf) | Matt Wieters (c) | Mark Reynolds (1b) | Wilson Betemit (3b) | Steven Pearce (lf) | Brian Matusz (p) |
| 2012-06-16 | Brian Roberts (2b) | J.J. Hardy (ss) | Chris Davis (rf) | Adam Jones (cf) | Matt Wieters (c) | Mark Reynolds (1b) | Wilson Betemit (3b) | Steven Pearce (lf) | Jason Hammel (p) |
| 2012-06-17 | Robert Andino (2b) | J.J. Hardy (ss) | Chris Davis (rf) | Adam Jones (cf) | Wilson Betemit (3b) | Mark Reynolds (1b) | Ronny Paulino (c) | Steven Pearce (lf) | Wei-Yin Chen (p) |
| 2012-06-18 | Brian Roberts (2b) | J.J. Hardy (ss) | Chris Davis (rf) | Adam Jones (cf) | Matt Wieters (c) | Mark Reynolds (1b) | Wilson Betemit (3b) | Steven Pearce (lf) | Jake Arrieta (p) |
| 2012-06-19 | Brian Roberts (2b) | J.J. Hardy (ss) | Adam Jones (cf) | Matt Wieters (c) | Mark Reynolds (1b) | Steven Pearce (rf) | Steven Tolleson (lf) | Robert Andino (3b) | Tommy Hunter (p) |
| 2012-06-20 | Brian Roberts (2b) | J.J. Hardy (ss) | Chris Davis (rf) | Adam Jones (cf) | Matt Wieters (c) | Nick Johnson (1b) | Wilson Betemit (3b) | Ryan Flaherty (lf) | Brian Matusz (p) |
| 2012-06-22 | Brian Roberts (2b) | J.J. Hardy (ss) | Chris Davis (rf) | Adam Jones (cf) | Matt Wieters (c) | Wilson Betemit (3b) | Mark Reynolds (1b) | Nick Johnson (dh) | Steven Pearce (lf) |
| 2012-06-23 | Brian Roberts (2b) | J.J. Hardy (ss) | Chris Davis (rf) | Adam Jones (cf) | Matt Wieters (c) | Wilson Betemit (3b) | Mark Reynolds (1b) | Nick Johnson (dh) | Steven Pearce (lf) |
| 2012-06-24 | Brian Roberts (2b) | J.J. Hardy (ss) | Adam Jones (cf) | Matt Wieters (c) | Mark Reynolds (1b) | Steven Pearce (rf) | Ronny Paulino (dh) | Steven Tolleson (lf) | Robert Andino (3b) |
| 2012-06-26 | Brian Roberts (2b) | J.J. Hardy (ss) | Adam Jones (cf) | Matt Wieters (c) | Mark Reynolds (dh) | Wilson Betemit (1b) | Steven Pearce (rf) | Steven Tolleson (lf) | Robert Andino (3b) |
| 2012-06-27 | Brian Roberts (2b) | J.J. Hardy (ss) | Chris Davis (rf) | Adam Jones (cf) | Matt Wieters (c) | Wilson Betemit (3b) | Mark Reynolds (1b) | Nick Johnson (dh) | Steven Pearce (lf) |
| 2012-06-28 | Brian Roberts (2b) | Xavier Avery (lf) | J.J. Hardy (ss) | Adam Jones (cf) | Chris Davis (dh) | Matt Wieters (c) | Wilson Betemit (3b) | Mark Reynolds (1b) | Ryan Flaherty (rf) |
| 2012-06-29 | Brian Roberts (2b) | Xavier Avery (lf) | J.J. Hardy (ss) | Adam Jones (cf) | Wilson Betemit (1b) | Chris Davis (dh) | Matt Wieters (c) | Ryan Flaherty (rf) | Robert Andino (3b) |
| 2012-06-30 | Brian Roberts (2b) | Xavier Avery (lf) | J.J. Hardy (ss) | Adam Jones (cf) | Wilson Betemit (1b) | Chris Davis (rf) | Matt Wieters (c) | Mark Reynolds (dh) | Ryan Flaherty (3b) |
| 2012-07-01 | Brian Roberts (2b) | J.J. Hardy (ss) | Chris Davis (rf) | Adam Jones (cf) | Jim Thome (dh) | Wilson Betemit (1b) | Ryan Flaherty (lf) | Ronny Paulino (c) | Robert Andino (3b) |
| 2012-07-02 | Robert Andino (2b) | J.J. Hardy (ss) | Wilson Betemit (3b) | Adam Jones (cf) | Jim Thome (dh) | Matt Wieters (c) | Chris Davis (rf) | Mark Reynolds (1b) | Steven Pearce (lf) |
| 2012-07-03 | Xavier Avery (lf) | J.J. Hardy (ss) | Chris Davis (rf) | Adam Jones (cf) | Jim Thome (dh) | Matt Wieters (c) | Wilson Betemit (1b) | Ryan Flaherty (3b) | Robert Andino (2b) |
| 2012-07-04 | Xavier Avery (lf) | J.J. Hardy (ss) | Chris Davis (rf) | Adam Jones (cf) | Jim Thome (dh) | Matt Wieters (c) | Wilson Betemit (3b) | Mark Reynolds (1b) | Robert Andino (2b) |
| 2012-07-05 | Xavier Avery (lf) | J.J. Hardy (ss) | Matt Wieters (c) | Adam Jones (cf) | Jim Thome (dh) | Wilson Betemit (3b) | Mark Reynolds (1b) | Ryan Flaherty (rf) | Robert Andino (2b) |
| 2012-07-06 | Robert Andino (2b) | J.J. Hardy (ss) | Adam Jones (cf) | Matt Wieters (c) | Wilson Betemit (3b) | Mark Reynolds (1b) | Steven Pearce (rf) | Ronny Paulino (dh) | Xavier Avery (lf) |
| 2012-07-07 | Xavier Avery (lf) | J.J. Hardy (ss) | Chris Davis (rf) | Adam Jones (cf) | Jim Thome (dh) | Matt Wieters (c) | Wilson Betemit (3b) | Joe Mahoney (1b) | Robert Andino (2b) |
| 2012-07-08 | Robert Andino (2b) | J.J. Hardy (ss) | Matt Wieters (dh) | Adam Jones (cf) | Mark Reynolds (1b) | Chris Davis (rf) | Steven Pearce (lf) | Steven Tolleson (3b) | Ronny Paulino (c) |
| 2012-07-13 | Nick Markakis (rf) | J.J. Hardy (ss) | Jim Thome (dh) | Adam Jones (cf) | Matt Wieters (c) | Chris Davis (lf) | Mark Reynolds (1b) | Wilson Betemit (3b) | Robert Andino (2b) |
| 2012-07-14 | Nick Markakis (rf) | J.J. Hardy (ss) | Jim Thome (dh) | Adam Jones (cf) | Matt Wieters (c) | Chris Davis (lf) | Mark Reynolds (1b) | Wilson Betemit (3b) | Robert Andino (2b) |
| 2012-07-15 | Nick Markakis (rf) | J.J. Hardy (ss) | Jim Thome (dh) | Adam Jones (cf) | Chris Davis (lf) | Wilson Betemit (3b) | Mark Reynolds (1b) | Taylor Teagarden (c) | Robert Andino (2b) |
| 2012-07-16 | Nick Markakis (rf) | J.J. Hardy (ss) | Adam Jones (cf) | Matt Wieters (c) | Mark Reynolds (1b) | Steven Pearce (lf) | Chris Davis (dh) | Wilson Betemit (3b) | Steven Tolleson (2b) |
| 2012-07-17 | Nick Markakis (rf) | J.J. Hardy (ss) | Jim Thome (dh) | Adam Jones (cf) | Matt Wieters (c) | Mark Reynolds (1b) | Chris Davis (lf) | Wilson Betemit (3b) | Ryan Flaherty (2b) |
| 2012-07-18 | Nick Markakis (rf) | J.J. Hardy (ss) | Adam Jones (cf) | Matt Wieters (dh) | Mark Reynolds (1b) | Steven Pearce (lf) | Wilson Betemit (3b) | Taylor Teagarden (c) | Steven Tolleson (2b) |
| 2012-07-19 | Nick Markakis (rf) | J.J. Hardy (ss) | Jim Thome (dh) | Adam Jones (cf) | Matt Wieters (c) | Wilson Betemit (3b) | Chris Davis (lf) | Mark Reynolds (1b) | Ryan Flaherty (2b) |
| 2012-07-20 | Nick Markakis (rf) | J.J. Hardy (ss) | Jim Thome (dh) | Adam Jones (cf) | Matt Wieters (c) | Wilson Betemit (3b) | Chris Davis (lf) | Mark Reynolds (1b) | Ryan Flaherty (2b) |
| 2012-07-21 | Nick Markakis (rf) | J.J. Hardy (ss) | Jim Thome (dh) | Adam Jones (cf) | Matt Wieters (c) | Wilson Betemit (3b) | Chris Davis (lf) | Mark Reynolds (1b) | Ryan Flaherty (2b) |
| 2012-07-22 | Nick Markakis (rf) | J.J. Hardy (ss) | Jim Thome (dh) | Adam Jones (cf) | Wilson Betemit (3b) | Chris Davis (lf) | Mark Reynolds (1b) | Ryan Flaherty (2b) | Taylor Teagarden (c) |
| 2012-07-23 | Nick Markakis (rf) | Endy Chavez (lf) | Jim Thome (dh) | Adam Jones (cf) | Matt Wieters (c) | Wilson Betemit (3b) | Chris Davis (1b) | Ryan Flaherty (2b) | Omar Quintanilla (ss) |
| 2012-07-24 | Nick Markakis (rf) | J.J. Hardy (ss) | Jim Thome (dh) | Adam Jones (cf) | Matt Wieters (c) | Wilson Betemit (3b) | Chris Davis (lf) | Mark Reynolds (1b) | Omar Quintanilla (2b) |
| 2012-07-25 | Nick Markakis (rf) | J.J. Hardy (ss) | Adam Jones (cf) | Matt Wieters (dh) | Wilson Betemit (3b) | Mark Reynolds (1b) | Taylor Teagarden (c) | Omar Quintanilla (2b) | Steven Tolleson (lf) |
| 2012-07-26 | Nick Markakis (rf) | J.J. Hardy (ss) | Jim Thome (dh) | Adam Jones (cf) | Matt Wieters (c) | Chris Davis (lf) | Wilson Betemit (3b) | Mark Reynolds (1b) | Omar Quintanilla (2b) |
| 2012-07-27 | Nick Markakis (rf) | J.J. Hardy (ss) | Jim Thome (dh) | Adam Jones (cf) | Chris Davis (lf) | Wilson Betemit (3b) | Mark Reynolds (1b) | Omar Quintanilla (2b) | Taylor Teagarden (c) |
| 2012-07-28 | Nick Markakis (rf) | J.J. Hardy (ss) | Chris Davis (dh) | Adam Jones (cf) | Wilson Betemit (3b) | Endy Chavez (lf) | Mark Reynolds (1b) | Omar Quintanilla (2b) | Taylor Teagarden (c) |
| 2012-07-29 | Nick Markakis (rf) | J.J. Hardy (ss) | Adam Jones (cf) | Matt Wieters (c) | Lew Ford (lf) | Mark Reynolds (1b) | Chris Davis (dh) | Wilson Betemit (3b) | Omar Quintanilla (2b) |
| 2012-07-30 | Nick Markakis (rf) | J.J. Hardy (ss) | Chris Davis (dh) | Adam Jones (cf) | Matt Wieters (c) | Lew Ford (lf) | Wilson Betemit (3b) | Mark Reynolds (1b) | Omar Quintanilla (2b) |
| 2012-07-31 | Nick Markakis (rf) | J.J. Hardy (ss) | Chris Davis (dh) | Adam Jones (cf) | Matt Wieters (c) | Lew Ford (lf) | Wilson Betemit (3b) | Mark Reynolds (1b) | Omar Quintanilla (2b) |
| 2012-08-01 | Nick Markakis (rf) | J.J. Hardy (ss) | Chris Davis (dh) | Adam Jones (cf) | Matt Wieters (c) | Wilson Betemit (3b) | Mark Reynolds (1b) | Endy Chavez (lf) | Omar Quintanilla (2b) |
| 2012-08-03 | Nick Markakis (rf) | J.J. Hardy (ss) | Adam Jones (cf) | Matt Wieters (c) | Chris Davis (dh) | Mark Reynolds (1b) | Lew Ford (lf) | Omar Quintanilla (2b) | Robert Andino (3b) |
| 2012-08-04 | Nick Markakis (rf) | J.J. Hardy (ss) | Chris Davis (dh) | Adam Jones (cf) | Matt Wieters (c) | Wilson Betemit (3b) | Nate McLouth (lf) | Mark Reynolds (1b) | Omar Quintanilla (2b) |
| 2012-08-05 | Nick Markakis (rf) | Robert Andino (3b) | J.J. Hardy (ss) | Adam Jones (cf) | Matt Wieters (dh) | Lew Ford (lf) | Mark Reynolds (1b) | Omar Quintanilla (2b) | Taylor Teagarden (c) |
| 2012-08-06 | Nick Markakis (rf) | Robert Andino (3b) | J.J. Hardy (ss) | Adam Jones (cf) | Matt Wieters (c) | Chris Davis (dh) | Lew Ford (lf) | Mark Reynolds (1b) | Omar Quintanilla (2b) |
| 2012-08-07 | Nick Markakis (rf) | J.J. Hardy (ss) | Chris Davis (dh) | Adam Jones (cf) | Matt Wieters (c) | Wilson Betemit (3b) | Nate McLouth (lf) | Mark Reynolds (1b) | Omar Quintanilla (2b) |
| 2012-08-08 | Nick Markakis (rf) | J.J. Hardy (ss) | Chris Davis (dh) | Adam Jones (cf) | Matt Wieters (c) | Wilson Betemit (3b) | Nate McLouth (lf) | Mark Reynolds (1b) | Omar Quintanilla (2b) |
| 2012-08-09 | Nick Markakis (rf) | J.J. Hardy (ss) | Adam Jones (cf) | Matt Wieters (c) | Lew Ford (lf) | Mark Reynolds (1b) | Chris Davis (dh) | Robert Andino (2b) | Manny Machado (3b) |
| 2012-08-10 | Nick Markakis (rf) | J.J. Hardy (ss) | Chris Davis (dh) | Adam Jones (cf) | Matt Wieters (c) | Wilson Betemit (1b) | Nate McLouth (lf) | Manny Machado (3b) | Omar Quintanilla (2b) |
| 2012-08-11 | Nick Markakis (rf) | J.J. Hardy (ss) | Nate McLouth (lf) | Adam Jones (cf) | Matt Wieters (c) | Wilson Betemit (1b) | Chris Davis (dh) | Manny Machado (3b) | Omar Quintanilla (2b) |
| 2012-08-12 | Nick Markakis (rf) | J.J. Hardy (ss) | Nate McLouth (cf) | Adam Jones (dh) | Lew Ford (lf) | Mark Reynolds (1b) | Manny Machado (3b) | Robert Andino (2b) | Taylor Teagarden (c) |
| 2012-08-14 | Nick Markakis (rf) | J.J. Hardy (ss) | Nate McLouth (lf) | Adam Jones (cf) | Matt Wieters (c) | Chris Davis (dh) | Mark Reynolds (1b) | Manny Machado (3b) | Omar Quintanilla (2b) |
| 2012-08-15 | Nick Markakis (rf) | J.J. Hardy (ss) | Nate McLouth (lf) | Adam Jones (cf) | Matt Wieters (c) | Chris Davis (dh) | Mark Reynolds (1b) | Manny Machado (3b) | Omar Quintanilla (2b) |
| 2012-08-16 | Nick Markakis (rf) | J.J. Hardy (ss) | Nate McLouth (lf) | Adam Jones (cf) | Matt Wieters (c) | Chris Davis (dh) | Mark Reynolds (1b) | Manny Machado (3b) | Omar Quintanilla (2b) |
| 2012-08-17 | Nick Markakis (rf) | J.J. Hardy (ss) | Nate McLouth (lf) | Adam Jones (cf) | Matt Wieters (c) | Chris Davis (dh) | Mark Reynolds (1b) | Manny Machado (3b) | Omar Quintanilla (2b) |
| 2012-08-18 | Nick Markakis (rf) | J.J. Hardy (ss) | Nate McLouth (lf) | Adam Jones (cf) | Matt Wieters (c) | Chris Davis (dh) | Mark Reynolds (1b) | Manny Machado (3b) | Robert Andino (2b) |
| 2012-08-19 | Nick Markakis (rf) | J.J. Hardy (ss) | Nate McLouth (lf) | Adam Jones (cf) | Chris Davis (dh) | Mark Reynolds (1b) | Manny Machado (3b) | Omar Quintanilla (2b) | Taylor Teagarden (c) |
| 2012-08-20 | Nick Markakis (rf) | Robert Andino (2b) | Nate McLouth (lf) | Adam Jones (cf) | Matt Wieters (c) | Chris Davis (dh) | Mark Reynolds (1b) | Omar Quintanilla (ss) | Manny Machado (3b) |
| 2012-08-21 | Nick Markakis (rf) | J.J. Hardy (ss) | Nate McLouth (lf) | Adam Jones (cf) | Matt Wieters (c) | Chris Davis (dh) | Mark Reynolds (1b) | Omar Quintanilla (2b) | Manny Machado (3b) |
| 2012-08-22 | Nick Markakis (rf) | J.J. Hardy (ss) | Adam Jones (cf) | Matt Wieters (c) | Mark Reynolds (1b) | Lew Ford (dh) | Nate McLouth (lf) | Manny Machado (3b) | Robert Andino (2b) |
| 2012-08-24 | Nick Markakis (rf) | J.J. Hardy (ss) | Nate McLouth (lf) | Adam Jones (cf) | Matt Wieters (c) | Chris Davis (dh) | Mark Reynolds (1b) | Ryan Flaherty (2b) | Manny Machado (3b) |
| 2012-08-25 | Nick Markakis (rf) | J.J. Hardy (ss) | Nate McLouth (lf) | Adam Jones (cf) | Matt Wieters (c) | Chris Davis (dh) | Mark Reynolds (1b) | Ryan Flaherty (2b) | Manny Machado (3b) |
| 2012-08-27 | Nick Markakis (rf) | J.J. Hardy (ss) | Adam Jones (cf) | Matt Wieters (c) | Lew Ford (dh) | Mark Reynolds (1b) | Nate McLouth (lf) | Manny Machado (3b) | Robert Andino (2b) |
| 2012-08-28 | Nick Markakis (rf) | J.J. Hardy (ss) | Adam Jones (cf) | Matt Wieters (c) | Lew Ford (dh) | Mark Reynolds (1b) | Nate McLouth (lf) | Manny Machado (3b) | Robert Andino (2b) |
| 2012-08-29 | Nick Markakis (rf) | J.J. Hardy (ss) | Nate McLouth (lf) | Adam Jones (cf) | Matt Wieters (c) | Chris Davis (dh) | Mark Reynolds (1b) | Omar Quintanilla (2b) | Manny Machado (3b) |
| 2012-08-30 | Nick Markakis (rf) | J.J. Hardy (ss) | Adam Jones (cf) | Mark Reynolds (1b) | Lew Ford (dh) | Nate McLouth (lf) | Manny Machado (3b) | Robert Andino (2b) | Taylor Teagarden (c) |
| 2012-08-31 | Nick Markakis (rf) | J.J. Hardy (ss) | Nate McLouth (lf) | Adam Jones (cf) | Matt Wieters (c) | Chris Davis (dh) | Mark Reynolds (1b) | Omar Quintanilla (2b) | Manny Machado (3b) |
| 2012-09-01 | Nick Markakis (rf) | J.J. Hardy (ss) | Nate McLouth (lf) | Adam Jones (cf) | Matt Wieters (c) | Chris Davis (dh) | Mark Reynolds (1b) | Omar Quintanilla (2b) | Manny Machado (3b) |
| 2012-09-02 | Nick Markakis (rf) | J.J. Hardy (ss) | Nate McLouth (lf) | Adam Jones (cf) | Matt Wieters (c) | Mark Reynolds (1b) | Chris Davis (dh) | Manny Machado (3b) | Robert Andino (2b) |
| 2012-09-03 | Nick Markakis (rf) | J.J. Hardy (ss) | Adam Jones (cf) | Matt Wieters (c) | Mark Reynolds (1b) | Manny Machado (3b) | Nate McLouth (lf) | Lew Ford (dh) | Robert Andino (2b) |
| 2012-09-04 | Nick Markakis (rf) | J.J. Hardy (ss) | Nate McLouth (lf) | Adam Jones (cf) | Matt Wieters (c) | Chris Davis (dh) | Mark Reynolds (1b) | Manny Machado (3b) | Robert Andino (2b) |
| 2012-09-05 | Nick Markakis (rf) | J.J. Hardy (ss) | Nate McLouth (lf) | Adam Jones (cf) | Matt Wieters (c) | Chris Davis (dh) | Mark Reynolds (1b) | Omar Quintanilla (2b) | Manny Machado (3b) |
| 2012-09-06 | Nick Markakis (rf) | J.J. Hardy (ss) | Nate McLouth (lf) | Adam Jones (cf) | Matt Wieters (c) | Mark Reynolds (1b) | Chris Davis (dh) | Manny Machado (3b) | Robert Andino (2b) |
| 2012-09-07 | Nick Markakis (rf) | J.J. Hardy (ss) | Nate McLouth (lf) | Adam Jones (cf) | Matt Wieters (c) | Mark Reynolds (1b) | Chris Davis (dh) | Manny Machado (3b) | Robert Andino (2b) |
| 2012-09-08 | Nick Markakis (rf) | Robert Andino (2b) | J.J. Hardy (ss) | Adam Jones (cf) | Mark Reynolds (1b) | Lew Ford (lf) | Manny Machado (3b) | Steven Tolleson (dh) | Taylor Teagarden (c) |
| 2012-09-09 | Nate McLouth (lf) | J.J. Hardy (ss) | Wilson Betemit (dh) | Adam Jones (cf) | Matt Wieters (c) | Mark Reynolds (1b) | Chris Davis (rf) | Manny Machado (3b) | Robert Andino (2b) |
| 2012-09-11 | Nate McLouth (lf) | J.J. Hardy (ss) | Adam Jones (cf) | Matt Wieters (c) | Mark Reynolds (1b) | Chris Davis (dh) | Lew Ford (rf) | Manny Machado (3b) | Robert Andino (2b) |
| 2012-09-12 | Nate McLouth (lf) | J.J. Hardy (ss) | Adam Jones (cf) | Matt Wieters (c) | Wilson Betemit (dh) | Mark Reynolds (1b) | Chris Davis (rf) | Manny Machado (3b) | Robert Andino (2b) |
| 2012-09-13 | Nate McLouth (lf) | J.J. Hardy (ss) | Wilson Betemit (dh) | Adam Jones (cf) | Chris Davis (rf) | Manny Machado (3b) | Mark Reynolds (1b) | Robert Andino (2b) | Taylor Teagarden (c) |
| 2012-09-14 | Nate McLouth (lf) | J.J. Hardy (ss) | Adam Jones (cf) | Matt Wieters (c) | Lew Ford (rf) | Mark Reynolds (1b) | Chris Davis (dh) | Manny Machado (3b) | Robert Andino (2b) |
| 2012-09-15 | Nate McLouth (lf) | J.J. Hardy (ss) | Matt Wieters (c) | Adam Jones (cf) | Chris Davis (dh) | Mark Reynolds (1b) | Manny Machado (3b) | Endy Chavez (rf) | Robert Andino (2b) |
| 2012-09-16 | Nate McLouth (lf) | J.J. Hardy (ss) | Chris Davis (dh) | Adam Jones (cf) | Matt Wieters (c) | Mark Reynolds (1b) | Manny Machado (3b) | Endy Chavez (rf) | Robert Andino (2b) |
| 2012-09-17 | Nate McLouth (lf) | J.J. Hardy (ss) | Chris Davis (dh) | Adam Jones (cf) | Matt Wieters (c) | Mark Reynolds (1b) | Manny Machado (3b) | Endy Chavez (rf) | Robert Andino (2b) |
| 2012-09-18 | Nate McLouth (lf) | J.J. Hardy (ss) | Chris Davis (dh) | Adam Jones (cf) | Matt Wieters (c) | Mark Reynolds (1b) | Manny Machado (3b) | Endy Chavez (rf) | Robert Andino (2b) |
| 2012-09-19 | Endy Chavez (rf) | J.J. Hardy (ss) | Nate McLouth (lf) | Adam Jones (cf) | Chris Davis (dh) | Mark Reynolds (1b) | Manny Machado (3b) | Robert Andino (2b) | Taylor Teagarden (c) |
| 2012-09-21 | Nate McLouth (lf) | J.J. Hardy (ss) | Adam Jones (cf) | Matt Wieters (c) | Mark Reynolds (1b) | Lew Ford (dh) | Manny Machado (3b) | Endy Chavez (rf) | Robert Andino (2b) |
| 2012-09-22 | Nate McLouth (lf) | J.J. Hardy (ss) | Adam Jones (cf) | Matt Wieters (c) | Jim Thome (dh) | Mark Reynolds (1b) | Chris Davis (rf) | Manny Machado (3b) | Ryan Flaherty (2b) |
| 2012-09-23 | Nate McLouth (lf) | J.J. Hardy (ss) | Adam Jones (cf) | Matt Wieters (c) | Mark Reynolds (1b) | Lew Ford (rf) | Chris Davis (dh) | Manny Machado (3b) | Robert Andino (2b) |
| 2012-09-24 | Nate McLouth (lf) | J.J. Hardy (ss) | Chris Davis (rf) | Adam Jones (cf) | Matt Wieters (c) | Jim Thome (dh) | Mark Reynolds (1b) | Ryan Flaherty (2b) | Manny Machado (3b) |
| 2012-09-24 | Nate McLouth (lf) | J.J. Hardy (ss) | Adam Jones (cf) | Chris Davis (dh) | Mark Reynolds (1b) | Manny Machado (3b) | Endy Chavez (rf) | Robert Andino (2b) | Taylor Teagarden (c) |
| 2012-09-25 | Nate McLouth (lf) | J.J. Hardy (ss) | Adam Jones (cf) | Matt Wieters (c) | Mark Reynolds (1b) | Chris Davis (rf) | Manny Machado (3b) | Steven Tolleson (dh) | Robert Andino (2b) |
| 2012-09-26 | Nate McLouth (lf) | J.J. Hardy (ss) | Chris Davis (rf) | Adam Jones (cf) | Matt Wieters (c) | Jim Thome (dh) | Mark Reynolds (1b) | Ryan Flaherty (2b) | Manny Machado (3b) |
| 2012-09-28 | Nate McLouth (lf) | J.J. Hardy (ss) | Chris Davis (rf) | Adam Jones (cf) | Jim Thome (dh) | Mark Reynolds (1b) | Manny Machado (3b) | Ryan Flaherty (2b) | Taylor Teagarden (c) |
| 2012-09-29 | Nate McLouth (lf) | J.J. Hardy (ss) | Adam Jones (cf) | Matt Wieters (c) | Chris Davis (rf) | Mark Reynolds (1b) | Manny Machado (3b) | Lew Ford (dh) | Robert Andino (2b) |
| 2012-09-30 | Nate McLouth (lf) | J.J. Hardy (ss) | Chris Davis (rf) | Adam Jones (cf) | Matt Wieters (c) | Jim Thome (dh) | Mark Reynolds (1b) | Ryan Flaherty (2b) | Manny Machado (3b) |
| 2012-10-01 | Nate McLouth (lf) | J.J. Hardy (ss) | Chris Davis (rf) | Adam Jones (cf) | Matt Wieters (c) | Jim Thome (dh) | Mark Reynolds (1b) | Ryan Flaherty (2b) | Manny Machado (3b) |
| 2012-10-02 | Nate McLouth (lf) | J.J. Hardy (ss) | Chris Davis (rf) | Adam Jones (cf) | Matt Wieters (c) | Jim Thome (dh) | Mark Reynolds (1b) | Ryan Flaherty (2b) | Manny Machado (3b) |
| 2012-10-03 | Nate McLouth (lf) | J.J. Hardy (ss) | Chris Davis (rf) | Adam Jones (cf) | Matt Wieters (c) | Jim Thome (dh) | Mark Reynolds (1b) | Ryan Flaherty (2b) | Manny Machado (3b) |