| Player | Status | High Level | Played | Born | Place | Ht | Wt | Bats | Throws | Draft Information | |||
| Rob Cafiero | Inactive | NCAA | 2011-2011 | 1992 | Bethpage, New York | 5-11 | 190 | Right | Right | ||||
| Dave Compitello | Retired | NCAA | 2005-2005 | 9/14/1985 | Bethpage, New York | 6-2 | 210 | Right | Right | ||||
| Christian Dienna | Inactive | NCAA | 2007-2010 | 12/3/1987 | Old Bethpage, New York | 6-1 | 215 | Left | Left | ||||
| Thomas McGivney | Retired | A | 1978-1979 | 1958 | Bethpage, New York | 6-0 | 190 | Left | Right | 1978 | 3 | 55 | OAK |
| Dan Rodriguez | Retired | NCAA | 2005-2005 | 7/1/1986 | Bethpage, New York | 5-10 | 170 | Right | Right | ||||
| Joe Sambito | Retired | MLB | 1973-1988 | 6/28/1952 | Brooklyn, New York | 6-1 | 190 | Left | Left | 1973 | 17 | 404 | HOU |
| E.J. Smith | Inactive | NCAA | 2010-2010 | 1/10/1988 | Bethpage, New York | 6-0 | 225 | Both | Right | ||||
| Andrew Wernicki | Retired | NCAA | 2006-2009 | Bethpage, New York | 5-11 | 180 | Right | Right | |||||