| Rk | Team | Nickname | W | L | Pct | Gbl | Overall | RF | RA | Manager | Stadium | Top Batter | Top Pitcher | Playoffs |
| 1 | Louisville | Cardinals | 21 | 6 | .778 | -- | 50-14 | 473 | 285 | Dan McDonnell | Jim Patterson Stadium | Phil Wunderlich (6) | Neil Holland (3) | CWS Regionals |
| 2 | Connecticut | Huskies | 20 | 6 | .769 | -- | 48-16 | 542 | 284 | Jim Penders | J.O. Christian Field | George Springer (1) | Scott Oberg (6) | Conference Finalists,CWS Regionals |
| 3 | Pittsburgh | Panthers | 18 | 8 | .692 | 2.5 | 38-18 | 531 | 362 | Joe Jordano | Trees Field | Joe Leonard (7) | Corey Baker (8) | |
| 4 | St. John's ** | Red Storm | 16 | 11 | .593 | 5.0 | 43-20 | 494 | 385 | Edward Blankmeyer | Jack Kaiser Stadium | Jeremy Baltz (2) | Kyle Hansen (5) | Conference Champion,CWS Regionals |
| 5 | South Florida | Bulls | 16 | 11 | .593 | 5.0 | 26-32 | 360 | 344 | Lelo Prado | Red McEwan Field | Stephen Hunt (35) | Randy Fontanez (1) | |
| 6 | Rutgers | Scarlett Knights | 15 | 12 | .556 | 6.0 | 30-26 | 402 | 237 | Fred Hill | Bainton Field | Pat Biserta (15) | Casey Gaynor (58) | |
| 7 | Cincinnati | Bearcats | 13 | 14 | .481 | 8.0 | 29-29 | 287 | 328 | Brian Cleary | Marge Schott Stadium | Kevin Johnson (38) | Andrew Strenge (10) | |
| 8 | West Virginia | Mountaineers | 10 | 17 | .370 | 11.0 | 27-30 | 377 | 422 | Greg Van Zant | Hawley Field | Jedd Gyorko (3) | Jarryd Summers (11) | |
| 9 | Notre Dame | Fighting Irish | 10 | 17 | .370 | 11.0 | 22-32 | 293 | 380 | Dave Schrage | Frank Eck Stadium | Ryan Connolly (21) | David Mills (18) | |
| 10 | Villanova | Wildcats | 9 | 18 | .333 | 12.0 | 29-23 | 347 | 269 | Joe Godri | Villanova Ballpark at Ply | Matt Szczur (14) | Brian Streilein (24) | |
| 11 | Seton Hall | Pirates | 8 | 19 | .296 | 13.0 | 19-30-1 | 225 | 272 | Rob Sheppard | Owen T. Carroll Field | Bobby Abreu (46) | Joe Dirocco (14) | |
| 12 | Georgetown | Hoyas | 5 | 22 | .185 | 16.0 | 24-31 | 356 | 393 | Pete Wilk | Shirley Povich Field | Tommy Lee (28) | Tim Adleman (42) |