| 2001 | High School | 1st team High School All-American IF | |
| 2003 | Fsl | Florida State League All-Star 3B | |
| 2004 | Minors | Baseball America 2nd team Minor League All-Star 3B | |
| | Level: AA | Double-A All-Star 3B | |
| | | MLB All-Rookie All-Star 3B | |
| | Team | New York Mets Minor League Player of the Year | |
| | Team | New York Mets Player of the Year | |
| 2005 | MLB | Baseball America Second-Team Major League All-Star 3B | |
| | Team | New York Mets Player of the Year | |
| | MLB-NL | NL MVP (Voting Rank: #19) | |
| 2006 | MLB-NL | NL MVP (Voting Rank: #9) | |
| | MLB-NL | Played in MLB All-Star Game (NL) | |
| 2007 | MLB | Major League 2nd All-Star (end of season) 3B | |
| | Team | New York Mets Player of the Year | |
| | MLB-NL | NL Gold Glove Award (3B) | |
| | MLB-NL | NL MVP (Voting Rank: #4) | |
| | MLB-NL | NL Silver Slugger Award (3B) | |
| | MLB-NL | Played in MLB All-Star Game (NL) | |
| 2008 | MLB | Major League 2nd All-Star (end of season) DH | |
| | MLB-NL | NL Gold Glove Award (3B) | |
| | MLB-NL | NL MVP (Voting Rank: #7) | |
| | MLB-NL | NL Silver Slugger Award (3B) | |
| | MLB-NL | Played in MLB All-Star Game (NL) | |
| 2009 | Team | New York Mets Player of the Year | |
| | MLB-NL | Played in MLB All-Star Game (NL) | |
| 2010 | Team | New York Mets Player of the Year | |
| | MLB-NL | NL MVP (Voting Rank: #24) | |
| | MLB-NL | Played in MLB All-Star Game (NL) | |
| 2012 | MLB-NL | NL MVP (Voting Rank: #6) | |
| | MLB-AL | Played in MLB All-Star Game (NL) | |