| 96. | Danny Duffy | P | KC | 18 | 12/21/1988 | 6-2 | 185 | L-L | A | | Cabrillo High School (Lompoc,CA) | 8 |
| 100. | Steven Souza | 3B | WAN | 18 | 4/24/1989 | 6-4 | 195 | R-R | A | | Cascade High School (Everett,WA) | 9 |
| 104. | Scott Carroll | P | CIN | 22 | 9/24/1984 | 6-5 | 210 | R-R | A+ | | Southwest Missouri State University | 74 |
| 107. | Brandon Workman | P | PHI | 18 | 8/13/1988 | 6-4 | 195 | R-R | - | | Bowie High School (Arlington,TX) | 2 |
| 109. | Neftali Soto | 3B | CIN | 18 | 2/28/1989 | 6-2 | 180 | R-R | Rookie | | Colegio Marista High School (Manati,PR) | |
| 112. | Daniel Descalso | 3B | STL | 20 | 10/19/1986 | 5-10 | | L-R | A+ | | University of California, Davis | 26 |
| 116. | Austin Gallagher | 3B | LA | 18 | 11/16/1988 | 6-4 | | L-R | A+ | | Manheim Township High School (Lancaster,PA) | |
| 117. | Tommy Toledo | P | SD | 18 | 12/13/1988 | 6-3 | 175 | R-R | - | | Alonso High School (Tampa,FL) | |
| 118. | Matt Harvey | P | LAA | 18 | 3/27/1989 | 6-4 | 210 | R-R | - | | Fitch High School (Groton,CT) | |
| 120. | Sam Demel | P | OAK | 21 | 10/23/1985 | 6-0 | 210 | R-R | A+ | | Texas Christian University | 82 |
| 121. | Luke Putkonen | P | DET | 21 | 5/10/1986 | 6-6 | 200 | R-R | Rookie | | University of North Carolina | 142 |
| 124. | Ryan Pope | P | NYY | 21 | 5/21/1986 | 6-3 | 190 | R-R | A+ | | Savannah College of Art & Design (Ga.) | 1 |