| Bradley Shaban | IF | 2010-2013 | James Madison |
| Josh Shabram | IF | 2010-2010 | Gardner-Webb |
| Austin Shackelford | OF | 2010-2011 | Utah, Whitman College |
| John Shackelford | IF | 2004-2006 | Oklahoma, Cowley College |
| Carson Shacklett | OF | 2019-2020 | Belmont |
| Jay Shadday | P | 2017-2017 | Georgia Tech |
| Brian Shade | P | 2000-2002 | Marshall, Colby CC |
| Leon Shade | OF | 2000-2003 | Rutgers |
| Andy Shadid | OF | 2016-2019 | Bradley |
| Luke Shadid | IF | 2017-2020 | Bradley |
| Ronnie Shaeffer | C | 2009-2013 | UC Irvine |
| John Shafer | C | 1968-1969 | Auburn |
| Alex Shaffer | P | 2014-2014 | Incarnate Word, Everett CC |
| Brock Shaffer | P | 2000-2002 | Towson |
| Darryl Shaffer | P | 2006-2007 | LSU |
| J.J. Shaffer | OF | 2015-2017 | Auburn |
| John Shaffer | IF | 2006-2009 | San Jose State |
| Jordan Shaffer | P-IF | 2015-2015 | Northwestern State |
| Trey Shaffer | OF - | 2018-2020 | SE Louisiana |
| Logan Shaftner | P | 2012-2015 | Northwestern State, Parkland College, Carson-Newman |
| Ankur Shah | P | 2014-2017 | Illinois-Chicago, UW Whitewater |
| Nick Shah | C | 2015-2018 | Lafayette College |
| Evan Shahak | OF | 2003-2005 | Texas Tech, Glendale CC AZ, Loyola Marymount |
| Toran Shahidi | C | 2015-2019 | USC-Upstate, Kirkwood CC, St. Cloud State |
| Sam Shaikin | IF | 2016-2019 | Valparaiso |
| Cole Shain | P | 2009-2012 | William and Mary |
| Faiz Shakir | 2B | 2001-2002 | Harvard |
| Mark Shallenberger | IF-P | 2020-2020 | Evansville |
| Kyle Shambaugh | P-OF | 2011-2015 | Oklahoma, Northeastern State |
| David Shambley | C | 2008-2011 | UNC Wilmington |
| Grant Shambley | OF | 2011-2014 | Wake Forest |
| Connor Shamblin | P | 2019-2020 | Alabama |
| Tyler Shambora | P | 2016-2017 | Virginia |
| Kraig Shambough | P | 2002-2002 | Louisiana-Lafayette |
| Drew Shamrock | P-OF | 2006-2006 | College of Charleston, Denison |
| Dennis Shanahan | OF | 2002-2002 | Creighton, CC of San Francisco |
| Matt Shane | P | 2018-2019 | Central Ct State |
| Jeff Shanfeldt | C | 2016-2019 | Lehigh |
| Clayton Shank | OF | 2006-2007 | UC Santa Barbara, Sacramento City College |
| Nate Shank | OF | 2013-2015 | Saint Joseph's |
| Jacob Shanks | C | 2019-2020 | UC Riverside |
| Tom Shanley | IF | 2003-2006 | George Washington |
| Erik Shannahan | P | 2012-2013 | Missouri State, John A. Logan College |
| Gregory Shannahan | P | 2015-2019 | Jacksonville |
| Ben Shannon | OF | 2002-2003 | Tennessee Tech, Meridian CC, Mississippi State |
| Brian Shannon | P | 2008-2010 | Hawaii-Hilo, Seattle |
| Cameron Shannon | OF | 2017-2019 | Grambling State, North Iowa Area CC, Northwestern-OH |
| Chad Shannon | OF | 2013-2015 | Lipscomb, Johnson County CC, Missouri Southern State University |
| Greg Shannon | P | 2006-2007 | San Jose State |
| Ian Shannon | C | 2005-2007 | Princeton |
| Jack Shannon | P | 2011-2013 | San Diego, Grossmont College |
| Nick Shannon | P-IF | 2010-2011 | Cal State Bakersfield, Chandler-Gilbert CC |
| Robert Shannon | P | 2006-2007 | Miami |
| Tim Shannon | P | 2015-2017 | Minnesota, Michigan |
| Tom Shannon | OF | 2003-2004 | Fresno State, Miami, Fresno City College |
| Tresco Shannon | P | 2014-2015 | USC-Upstate, Florence-Darlington Tech |
| TJ Shantz | IF-OF | 2010-2013 | Florida Intl |
| Matt Shao | 2B | 2007-2007 | Vanderbilt |
| Vaughn Shapen | IF-C | 2014-2017 | Middle Tenn State, Bossier Parish CC, Northwestern State, LSU-Shreveport |
| Brian Shapiro | P | 2008-2009 | Holy Cross |
| Collin Shapiro | OF | 2019-2019 | Massachusetts |
| Dan Shapiro | 1B-OF | 2006-2009 | Brown |
| Matt Shapiro | P | 2007-2010 | Holy Cross |
| Scott Shapiro | P | 2002-2004 | Santa Clara, Vanderbilt |
| Jonathan Shapland | OF | 2005-2006 | St. Petersburg College, Florida Atlantic |
| Eliot Shapleigh | OF | 2015-2017 | Stetson, Rollins |
| Jared Share | IF-OF | 2018-2018 | Old Dominion |
| Victor Sharek | 3B-P | 1973-1974 | Auburn |
| Eric Sharff | P | 2014-2014 | Delaware State |
| David Sharfstein | P | 2003-2003 | Cornell |
| Josh Sharik | P | 2014-2017 | Rider |
| Anthony Sharkas | OF | 2020-2020 | Eastern Michigan |
| Mike Sharkevich | P | 2004-2004 | Maryland |
| Jimmy Sharkey | P | 2017-2019 | Fairleigh Dickinson, Iona College |
| Joey Sharkey | C | 2010-2013 | Bethune-Cookman, Lynn |
| Jason Sharman | C | 2019-2020 | UNLV |
| Josh Sharman | P | 2020-2020 | UNLV |
| Ryan Sharman | OF | 2005-2005 | Nevada, UNC-Greensboro |
| Chris Sharp | IF | 2004-2006 | Grambling State |
| Cody Sharp | --- | 2020-2020 | Marshall |
| Collin Sharp | P | 2015-2018 | Baylor, McLennan CC |
| Dan Sharp | P | 2007-2007 | Fairleigh Dickinson |
| Dane Sharp | P | 2008-2011 | Memphis |
| David Sharp | P | 2018-2018 | Savannah State |
| Donnie Sharp | P | 2001-2002 | East Tennessee State |
| Fred Sharp | C | 2012-2013 | Bowling Green State |
| Jason Sharp | SS | 1997-2000 | Eastern Kentucky |
| John Sharp | SS | 2007-2007 | Grambling State |
| Kegan Sharp | P | 2009-2010 | San Diego State, Palomar College |
| Matt Sharp | P | 2013-2016 | South Alabama |
| Brandon Sharpe | 1B-OF | 2015-2015 | Georgia Southern, Darton College |
| Davis Sharpe | 3B | 2019-2020 | Clemson |
| John Sharpe | IF | 2017-2019 | Lipscomb, Cleveland State CC, Carson-Newman |
| Kenny Sharpe | P | 2012-2012 | Florida Atlantic, Palm Beach State College |
| Scott Sharpe | P | 2002-2005 | Ark-Little Rock |
| Zarion Sharpe | P | 2017-2020 | UNC Wilmington |
| Blane Sharpless | P | 1999-2002 | Bucknell |
| Ryan Sharpley | P | 2008-2010 | Notre Dame |
| Zack Sharpley | C | 2016-2018 | USC |
| Bill Sharpton | P | 2000-2002 | Georgia |
| Robert Sharpton | P-OF | 2001-2002 | Charleston Southern |
| Jo Jo Sharrar | C | 2009-2012 | Utah |
| Jake Sharrock | UT | 2008-2011 | Jacksonville State |
| Todd Sharrock | IF | 2006-2008 | Morehead State |
| Cody Sharrow | IF | 2013-2016 | South Dakota State |
| Owen Sharts | P | 2019-2020 | Nevada |
| Kent Shartzer | COACH | 2001-2005 | Bellarmine |
| Jim Sharwarko | C | 2004-2005 | Illinois |
| Joe Shashaty | 2B | 2015-2016 | Hartford |
| Adam Shatkun | P | 2002-2006 | Binghamton |
| Bryce Shattie | 1B-OF | 2007-2008 | Vermont |
| Jared Shatto | OF | 2016-2016 | South Dakota State |
| Josh Shatto | P | 2009-2009 | Indiana U.-Purdue U.-FW, Ancilla College |
| Matt Shatto | C | 2017-2019 | UMD-Baltimore Cty |
| Sam Shaughnessy | OF | 2008-2009 | Boston College |
| Derek Shaver | 3B | 2020-2020 | Wichita State |
| Derrick Shaver | P | 2004-2004 | Tennessee Tech |
| Jackson Shaver | IF | 2010-2013 | William and Mary |
| Jackson Shaver | P | 2016-2019 | Eastern Michigan, Grand Rapids CC |
| Kyle Shaver | P | 2010-2012 | San Diego State, Grossmont College, Pacific |
| Nate Shaver | OF | 2009-2010 | New Mexico State, Mt. Hood CC |
| Bobby Shaw | IF-P | 2004-2004 | Maryland-Eastern Shore |
| Brandon Shaw | P | 2002-2002 | Texas Tech, Grayson County College |
| Brandon Shaw | OF | 2002-2003 | New Mexico State, El Paso CC |
| Clayton Shaw | IF | 2007-2009 | Portland |
| Dan Shaw | P | 1970-1973 | Stanford |
| Daniel Shaw | P | 2015-2017 | Tennessee-Martin, Jackson State CC, East Tennessee State |
| Derek Shaw | OF | 2006-2008 | Louisiana Tech, Panola College, Grayson County College |
| Derek Shaw | P | 2007-2009 | Florida Gulf Coast |
| Drew Shaw | P | 2010-2010 | Temple |
| Hal Shaw | P-1B | 2017-2018 | Sacred Heart |
| Jake Shaw | P | 2014-2017 | Northern Kentucky, Indianapolis |
| Jay Shaw | P | 2011-2015 | Alabama |
| Jeremy Shaw | P | 2004-2007 | Manhattan College |
| Jose Shaw | P | 2003-2005 | UC Riverside |
| Kieran Shaw | P | 2017-2019 | Harvard |
| Landon Shaw | --- | 2020-2020 | Presbyterian College |
| Michael Shaw | P | 2007-2010 | Mercer |
| Nathan Shaw | SS | 2012-2012 | St. Bonaventure |
| R.T. Shaw | P | 2002-2005 | Evansville |
| Ryan Shaw | P | 2005-2005 | Delaware State |
| Ryan Shaw | C-IF | 2017-2018 | Richmond |
| Tate Shaw | IF | 2016-2019 | Texas |
| Taylor Shaw | C | 2010-2013 | Southern Utah, Indiana State |
| Ted Shaw | IF | 2014-2017 | Sacred Heart |
| Trent Shaw | IF | 2012-2016 | UNC Asheville, Alderson-Broaddus College |
| Willie Shaw | 1B-OF | 2013-2015 | William and Mary, Cypress College |
| Greg Shawgo | P | 2002-2002 | Western Illinois |
| Evan Shawver | P | 2019-2020 | Cincinnati |
| Jeremy Shay | C-IF | 2011-2014 | Bowling Green State |
| Corey Shaylor | IF | 2008-2011 | UNC Charlotte |
| Brendan Shea | P | 2015-2019 | Massachusetts-Lowell, William Peace |
| Chris Shea | P-OF | 2003-2003 | Michigan State |
| Corey Shea | P | 2008-2011 | Lafayette College |
| Dan Shea | OF | 2013-2017 | Monmouth |
| Ryan Shea | IF | 2009-2009 | Charleston Southern |
| John Sheaks | P | 2015-2019 | Long Beach State, Saddleback College |
| Boone Shear | OF | 2011-2012 | Troy, Lurleen B. Wallace CC |
| Brandon Shearer | IF | 2016-2019 | Loyola Marymount |
| Patrick Shearer | P | 2020-2020 | Saint Joseph's |
| Jamey Shearin | OF | 1999-2001 | NC State |
| Andrew Shebloski | OF | 2017-2020 | St. Mary's (CA) |
| Tyler Shedler-Mcavoy | OF | 2017-2020 | Seton Hall |
| Pat Shedlock | P | 2010-2013 | Cleveland State, Youngstown State, Cuyahoga CC |
| Cody Sheedy | IF-OF | 2013-2013 | Georgia |
| Bodie Sheehan | P | 2016-2019 | William and Mary |
| Casey Sheehan | OF | 2015-2018 | UC Riverside, Northwest Nazarene |
| Charlie Sheehan | P | 2017-2020 | Saint Louis |
| Chris Sheehan | P | 2014-2017 | Wofford |
| Danny Sheehan | IF | 2013-2017 | San Diego State |
| Emmet Sheehan | P | 2019-2020 | Boston College |
| Jack Sheehan | P | 2017-2019 | Notre Dame |
| Jeremy Sheehan | P | 2007-2008 | Centenary College, Cowley College |
| Michael Sheehan | C | 2004-2004 | Rhode Island |
| Pat Sheehan | OF | 2010-2011 | Illinois |
| Patrick Sheehan | IF | 2008-2008 | Marist |
| Shaun Sheehan | P | 2005-2005 | Tennessee Tech |
| Tim Sheehan | C-1B | 2001-2003 | Fairfield |
| Tommy Sheehan | P-IF | 2018-2020 | Notre Dame |
| Will Sheehan | OF | 2005-2006 | Navy |
| Brian Sheekey | P | 1970-1971 | Union County College, Rhode Island |
| Jay Sheely | IF | 2013-2016 | New Mexico State, Glendale CC CA |
| Robert Sheeren | H | 2002-2002 | Western Illinois |
| Joe Sheets | P | 2007-2008 | Western Michigan, Kellogg CC |
| Brady Sheetz | OF | 2012-2014 | Hartford |
| Austin Sheffield | IF | 2008-2011 | Manhattan College |
| Brad Sheffield | OF | 2004-2004 | Troy, Lurleen B. Wallace CC |
| Chaney Sheffield | P | 2001-2002 | Harvard |
| Charles Sheffield | OF | 2012-2015 | Georgia Tech, Georgia Perimeter College, Georgia Southern |
| Paul Sheffield | P | 2017-2018 | Savannah State, FSC at jacksonville |
| Trey Sheffield | 1B-P | 2006-2007 | East Tennessee State |
| Ryan Sheflott | P | 2005-2008 | Fordham |
| Chad Sheiner | P | 2008-2008 | Air Force |
| Jordan Sheinkop | P | 2014-2018 | George Washington |
| Aaron Shelbourne | IF-P | 2000-2003 | Eastern Illinois, Kankakee CC, Indiana State |
| Troy Shelby | OF | 2000-2003 | Western Illinois |
| Dan Sheldon | IF | 2013-2013 | Marist |
| Jack Sheldon | C | 2019-2019 | Lafayette College |
| Seaton Sheldon | C | 2017-2017 | Western Kentucky, Lincoln Trail College |
| Jacob Sheldon-Collins | SS | 2013-2016 | Hawaii, Iowa Western CC |
| Steve Shelinsky | OF-1B | 2010-2014 | Pittsburgh |
| Bennett Shell | OF | 2019-2020 | South Alabama |
| Chase Shell | P | 2017-2018 | South Alabama |
| Thomas Shell | OF-P | 2004-2004 | Fairleigh Dickinson |
| William Shell | P | 2014-2014 | Troy, Jefferson Davis CC |
| Bryant Shellenbarger | --- | 2020-2020 | Akron |
| Ben Shelley | C | 2006-2007 | Alabama-Birmingham, Wallace CC |
| John Shelley | OF-IF | 1970-1970 | Oklahoma |
| Michael Shelley | P | 2000-2000 | Troy |
| Tom Shelley | IF | 2007-2007 | Delaware State, Parkland College |
| Travis Shelley | P | 2014-2016 | Winthrop, Lancaster Bible |
| Brian Shellhamer | P | 2007-2007 | Maryland |
| John Marc Shelly | P | 2014-2014 | Mississippi State |
| Alex Shelton | P | 2007-2010 | UNC-Greensboro |
| Bobby Shelton | P | 2010-2012 | Longwood |
| Brandon Shelton | IF | 2009-2012 | Old Dominion |
| Caleb Shelton | P | 2011-2011 | NC A&T State |
| Chase Shelton | 1B-P | 2012-2015 | Charleston Southern |
| Cody Shelton | P | 2016-2018 | Samford |
| Cole Shelton | 1B-C | 2008-2009 | Memphis, Dyersburg State CC |
| Cole Shelton | IF | 2018-2019 | Yale |
| Dee Shelton | IF | 2018-2019 | Stetson, Hillsborough CC, Sam Houston State |
| Ethan Shelton | OF-IF | 2019-2020 | East Tennessee State |
| Jon Ross Shelton | P | 2004-2005 | Delta State, Murray State, SE ILL College |
| Matt Shelton | P | 2006-2009 | Indiana State |
| Robert Shelton | 3B | 1999-2002 | Louisiana-Lafayette, Mississippi |
| Tanner Shelton | P | 2014-2016 | Georgia Tech |
| Thomas Shelton | C | 2010-2012 | Illinois |
| Todd Shelton | IF | 2005-2007 | Oregon State, Bakersfield College, Cal State Northridge |
| Trent Shelton | OF | 2014-2017 | Oral Roberts, Panola College |
| Tripp Shelton | IF | 2015-2018 | UNC-Greensboro |
| Tyler Shelton | 3B | 2000-2001 | Memphis |
| Will Shelton | OF | 2002-2002 | Louisville |
| James Sheltrown | IF | 2010-2014 | Akron |
| Jared Shemper | P | 2020-2020 | Mississippi State |
| Rob Shenk | P | 2004-2007 | Davidson College |
| John Samuel Shenker | --- | 2020-2020 | Auburn |
| Brandon Shepard | IF | 1999-2003 | Kansas, Sacramento City College, San Francisco |
| Clifford Shepard | OF | 2009-2010 | Centenary College, Western Nevada CC |
| Colin Shepard | C | 2011-2011 | Bryant University, Stonehill College |
| Gabe Shepard | P | 2019-2020 | Southern Miss |
| Jeff Shepard | P | 2003-2004 | Canisius College |
| Shaefer Shepard | SS | 2014-2017 | Georgia, Francis Marion, Catawba College. |
| Shane Shepard | IF | 2015-2018 | NC State |
| Aidan Shepardson | --- | 2020-2020 | Central Michigan |
| Andy Shepherd | IF | 2006-2007 | Oakland, Northeastern Junior College |
| Bobby Shepherd | OF | 2009-2010 | Sacred Heart |
| Bryce Shepherd | IF | 2014-2017 | Incarnate Word |
| Cam Shepherd | SS | 2017-2020 | Georgia |
| Chandler Shepherd | P | 2003-2004 | Murray State |
| Chris Shepherd | SS-2B | 2002-2004 | Illinois State |
| Cody Shepherd | UT | 2013-2013 | Brigham Young, Columbia Basin College |
| Colin Shepherd | P | 2008-2008 | Air Force |
| Conner Shepherd | IF | 2017-2020 | Florida Intl, Mount San Antonio College, Texas Christian |
| Craig Shepherd | IF | 2017-2020 | Evansville |
| Jeremiah Shepherd | P | 2006-2007 | Southern, Texarkana College |
| Justin Shepherd | 3B | 2007-2010 | Lafayette College |
| Kevin Shepherd | IF | 2012-2012 | Oregon, Lane CC OR |
| Matt Shepherd | P | 2007-2008 | Texas-Pan American, Howard College |
| Matthew Shepherd | P | 2009-2009 | Tennessee Tech |
| Stuart Shepherd | P-1B | 2002-2002 | Marshall |
| Tyler Shepherd | OF | 2013-2014 | Indiana U.-Purdue U.-FW, San Joaquin Delta College |
| Will Shepherd | OF-IF | 2014-2017 | Liberty |
| Ryan Sheplak | IF-P | 2011-2013 | Florida A&M |
| Scott Sheplak | 3B | 2010-2013 | Florida A&M |
| Josh Shepley | P | 2014-2016 | Canisius College |
| Aaron Sheppard | P | 2017-2017 | Louisiana Tech |
| Bobby Sheppard | IF | 2015-2016 | University at Buffalo, Prairie State College |
| Bobby Sheppard | IF | 2019-2020 | Seton Hall |
| Carter Sheppard | --- | 2020-2020 | High Point |
| Dan Sheppard | C | 2010-2013 | Iowa |
| Darryn Sheppard | OF | 2014-2017 | Baylor |
| Garrett Sheppard | C | 2018-2019 | Coastal Carolina, St. Johns River CC |
| Michael Sheppard | P | 2013-2016 | St. John's |
| Renzo Sheppard | P | 2006-2007 | North Florida, FSC at jacksonville |
| Tripp Sheppard | P | 2014-2015 | Georgia Southern, Georgia College & State |
| Connor Sheppeard | P-SS | 2014-2017 | Miss. Valley St |
| Garrett Shepperd | P | 2010-2012 | Texas State |
| Jake Shepski | IF-OF | 2015-2019 | Notre Dame, Xavier |
| Brendan Sher | IF | 2019-2020 | Iowa |
| Pat Sherald | COACH | 2000-2001 | Lamar, Frederick CC |
| Dennis Sherba | P | 2007-2010 | St. Bonaventure |
| J.T. Sherba | C-OF | 2009-2012 | Fairleigh Dickinson |
| Mike Sherburne | OF | 2013-2015 | Rhode Island, CC of Rhode Island |
| Logan Sherer | P-IF | 2014-2017 | UNC Charlotte |
| Michael Shereyk | P | 2016-2019 | SIU-Edwardsville |
| Tevis Sherfield | IF | 2011-2013 | Tennessee Tech |
| Kyle Sherick | OF | 2019-2020 | Seattle |
| Andy Sheridan | P | 2002-2002 | SE Missouri State |
| Drew Sheridan | P | 2008-2011 | Wofford |
| Jim Sheridan | OF | 2003-2004 | Fairfield |
| John Sheridan | P | 2010-2013 | Brown |
| Joseph Sheridan | P | 2017-2020 | Central Florida |
| TJ Sheridan | P | 2004-2008 | Le Moyne, Texas-Pan American |
| Peyton Sherlin | P | 2018-2020 | Dallas Baptist |
| John Sherman | P | 2018-2020 | Morehead State |
| Randy Sherman | OF | 2005-2006 | Dartmouth |
| Ron Sherman | IF | 2015-2016 | Pittsburgh, Lackawanna College |
| Zach Sherman | P-OF | 2018-2020 | Arizona |
| Alex Shermer | OF | 2013-2016 | Nicholls State, Jones County Junior College |
| Garrett Sherrell | P | 2014-2014 | Ark-Little Rock |
| Brady Sherrill | C-OF | 2020-2020 | Troy |
| Zach Sherrill | IF | 2012-2015 | The Citadel |
| Alex Sherrod | P | 2009-2012 | USC |
| Mark Sherrod | P | 2007-2010 | Savannah State |
| Adam Sherry | P | 2002-2002 | SE Missouri State, Truman State |
| Austin Sherry | P | 2016-2019 | Oakland |
| Greg Sherry | IF | 2008-2011 | Notre Dame |
| Dan Sherwood | OF | 2008-2011 | Toledo |
| Matt Sherwood | P | 1994-1994 | Blinn College, Texas A&M |
| Joe Shetler | OF | 1998-2002 | Marshall |
| Andre Shewcraft | P | 2014-2018 | Texas-San Antonio |
| Ashton Shewey | P | 2007-2007 | Troy, Chandler-Gilbert CC |
| Christian Shewey | C | 1993-1996 | Washington |
| Ben Shields | P | 2018-2018 | Massachusetts |
| Drew Shields | 3B-2B | 2011-2013 | Georgia State, Darton College |
| John Shields | --- | 2020-2020 | Lipscomb |
| Julian Shields | IF | 2013-2013 | Alabama State |
| Kyle Shields | P | 2012-2015 | North Carolina Central, Brunswick CC |
| Taylor Shields | P | 2013-2014 | Jacksonville State, Calhoun CC |
| Mitchell Shifflet | OF | 2011-2012 | Virginia |
| Derek Shifflett | P | 2015-2015 | James Madison |
| Shane Shifflett | IF-OF | 2018-2018 | Florida, South Carolina |
| Sheldon Shifflett | P | 2012-2014 | Va Military Inst. |
| Wes Shifflett | P | 2007-2010 | Towson |
| Stone Shiffman | P-OF | 2019-2019 | Cal State Northridge |
| Joey Shiflett | P | 1999-2002 | Jacksonville State |
| Tanner Shiflett | P | 2010-2010 | Houston, Eastfield College |
| Brandon Shileikis | P | 2014-2018 | Quinnipiac |
| Alex Shilliday | P | 1996-1999 | Notre Dame |
| Luke Shilling | P | 2016-2017 | Illinois |
| Shevis Shima | IF | 2008-2009 | Cal State Fullerton, Saddleback College |
| Corey Shimada | OF | 2006-2009 | Utah |
| Brett Shimanovsky | P | 2014-2017 | Saint Louis |
| James Shimashita | P-OF | 2019-2020 | San Jose State |
| J.J. Shimko | OF | 2015-2019 | USC-Upstate |
| Rick Shimko | IF | 2000-2003 | Cleveland State |
| Anthony Shimkus | P | 2013-2017 | Southern Illinois |
| Doug Shimokawa | P | 2001-2004 | Yale |
| Kyle Shimp | P | 2017-2019 | Iowa |
| Keith Shinaberry | P | 2006-2009 | Texas |
| Matt Shindlebower | P | 2016-2017 | Arkansas-Pine Bluff |
| AJ Shindler | IF | 2008-2009 | Michigan State, Indian Hills CC-Centerville |
| Pat Shine | COACH | 1995-1995 | Gonzaga |
| Ian Shiner | P | 2012-2012 | Norfolk State |
| Tyler Shingledecker | P | 2019-2020 | Penn State |
| Anton Shinhoster | OF-1B | 2003-2006 | Jackson State |
| Blake Shinkle | IF | 2016-2019 | Kansas |
| Eric Shinn | P | 2009-2010 | Ohio State |
| Cole Shinsky | P | 2018-2019 | Ohio, Murray State College |
| Kyle Shiplett | P | 2002-2002 | Appalachian State |
| Harry Shipley | SS-2B | 2015-2018 | Purdue |
| Zach Shipley | C-1B | 2003-2003 | Arkansas State |
| Robert Shipman | OF | 2010-2015 | Georgia, Mount Olive College |
| Torrence Shipp | P | 2004-2004 | Chicago State |
| Jonathan Shippee | P | 2009-2013 | Monmouth |
| David Shipps | P | 2001-2002 | Central Florida, Manatee-Sarasota |
| Eric Shippy | OF | 2003-2003 | Kentucky |
| Brandon Shipwash | P | 2002-2004 | NC State |
| Will Shirah | P-OF | 2018-2019 | Georgia Tech |
| Phil Shirek | P | 2002-2005 | Nebraska |
| Dugan Shirer | OF | 2015-2017 | Washington State, College of Southern Idaho |
| Zach Shirey | P | 2016-2016 | Lipscomb |
| Jack Shirk | IF | 2016-2019 | Marist, Pitt Johnstown |
| Allen Shirley | C | 2001-2003 | South Florida |
| Austin Shirley | OF | 2015-2019 | Georgetown, DePauw |
| Craig Shirley | P-IF | 2013-2013 | Auburn |
| Dustin Shirley | IF | 2015-2018 | Dartmouth |
| Jason Shirley | OF | 2012-2015 | Youngstown State |
| Jon Shirley | P | 1997-2000 | California |
| Scott Shirrell | SS | 2001-2004 | Dartmouth |
| Andrew Shisila | P | 2005-2007 | Ohio |
| Cade Shissler | IF | 2020-2020 | Stetson |
| Garett Shitanishi | 2B | 1999-2003 | UNLV |
| Andrew Shivak | P | 2018-2019 | Youngstown State, Tallahassee CC |
| Corbin Shive | P | 2010-2014 | UNC Charlotte |
| Christian Shiver | P | 2017-2018 | College of Charleston |
| Frank Shivers | P | 2010-2014 | New Jersey Tech |
| Gabe Shivers | OF | 2012-2012 | Georgia State, Young Harris College, Emory |
| Austin Shives | IF | 2013-2015 | Stony Brook, Azusa Pacific |
| Bryant Shives | SS-2B | 2019-2019 | Mount Saint Mary |
| DJ Shives | P | 2013-2015 | Mercer, Hillsborough CC |
| Grant Shives | P | 2016-2016 | Pacific |
| Ruben Shives | 3B | 2005-2008 | Texas-Pan American |
| Ty Shoaff | P | 2016-2019 | Missouri, West Virginia, Notre Dame College |
| Matt Shobe | P | 2017-2019 | Bucknell |
| Ryan Shober | IF | 2009-2013 | Valparaiso, Illinois-Chicago |
| Brady Shockey | OF | 2017-2020 | USC |
| Colin Shockey | OF-P | 2004-2005 | Creighton, Nebraska, Iowa Western CC |
| Jason Shockey | IF | 2003-2003 | Ohio, Indian Hills CC-Centerville |
| Brandon Shockley | IF | 2001-2001 | Saint Louis |
| Ryan Shockley | P | 2006-2008 | Villanova |
| Scott Shockley | OF | 2006-2009 | Delaware |
| Tony Shockley | OF | 2001-2003 | Air Force |
| Zachary Shockley | P | 2013-2013 | Marshall |
| Brendon Shoemake | P | 2013-2014 | Youngstown State, Santa Barbara City College |
| Kyle Shoemaker | P | 2002-2003 | Texas Christian, Seminole State College |
| Matt Shoemaker | UT | 2009-2009 | Virginia Tech, Christopher Newport |
| Nate Shoemaker | P | 2018-2019 | Creighton |
| John Shoemate | 1B | 2004-2004 | Ark-Little Rock, Chattanooga State Technical CC |
| Dylan Shoffner | P | 2014-2016 | Louisville, Volunteer State CC |
| Caleb Shofner | IF | 2008-2010 | Texas A&M |
| Landon Shofner | IF | 2018-2019 | Texas A&M-Corpus Christi, Texas-Tyler |
| Cody Shook | OF-C | 2018-2020 | Georgia Southern, West Liberty University |
| Ryan Shook | P | 2009-2013 | Norfolk State |
| TJ Shook | P | 2015-2017 | Michigan, Oakland |
| TJ Shook | P | 2018-2020 | South Carolina |
| Zane Shook | P | 2003-2003 | Northwestern State, Texas Tech |
| Taylor Shoop | 1B-P | 2003-2007 | Davidson College |
| Michael Shope | P | 2004-2004 | Western Kentucky, Lincoln Trail College |
| Levi Shordon | P | 2012-2013 | Arkansas State |
| Brett Shore | OF | 2006-2009 | Davidson College |
| Jared Shore | P | 2004-2005 | Auburn |
| John-Paul Shore | P | 2004-2006 | Western Illinois |
| Ronnie Shore | IF | 2003-2006 | Davidson College |
| Chris Shores | P | 2003-2004 | Binghamton |
| Eddie Shores | P | 2020-2020 | Davidson College |
| Avery Short | P | 2018-2019 | Siena College |
| Bryce Short | C | 2018-2020 | New Jersey Tech |
| Connor Short | IF | 2014-2018 | Auburn, Alabama |
| Daniel Short | 3B-1B | 2011-2012 | Arkansas State, Arkansas Baptist College |
| J.J. Short | IF-OF | 2009-2009 | Indiana U.-Purdue U.-FW |
| Tim Short | OF | 2002-2005 | Fordham |
| Cody Shorter | C | 2008-2010 | Army |
| Ro'Shard Shorter | 2B | 2004-2006 | Prairie View A&M |
| Robert Shorts | P | 2019-2019 | Delaware State |
| Sam Shorts | P | 2003-2006 | Miami |
| Joe Shortt | P | 2003-2003 | Western Kentucky |
| Ronnie Shotts | OF | 1967-1969 | Stanford, Oklahoma |
| Brian Shoup | 3B | 2004-2007 | Wright State |
| Brian Shoup | P | 2001-2003 | Louisiana-Monroe |
| Brody Shoupe | C | 2017-2020 | Morehead State |
| Jared Shouppe | IF-OF | 2013-2017 | Florida Atlantic, Santa Fe CC |
| Jesse Shovek | IF | 2002-2004 | Indiana U.-Purdue U.-FW |
| Tommy Shovlin | OF | 2008-2009 | USC-Upstate, Daytona Beach CC |
| Brett Showalter | 1B-OF | 2000-2004 | Penn State |
| Justin Showalter | OF | 2004-2004 | Tennessee Tech |
| Justin Showalter | P | 2018-2020 | James Madison |
| Josh Showers | IF | 2003-2006 | Washington |
| Shain Showers | IF | 2013-2016 | Evansville |
| Brandon Showmar | P | 2010-2010 | Memphis |
| Rob Shrawder | IF | 2001-2003 | Ohio |
| Robert Shreck | P | 2016-2016 | Savannah State |
| Brady Shreeves | P | 2018-2018 | George Washington, Salisbury |
| Patrick Shreve | P | 2011-2012 | Nicholls State, Coastal Ala |
| Doug Shribman | 1B-P | 2008-2011 | Bucknell |
| Brian Shrimpton | C-1B | 2010-2010 | Eastern Kentucky, Georgetown College |
| Carson Shrode | C-OF | 2016-2018 | Tennessee-Martin |
| Josh Shrouder | IF | 2018-2019 | Austin Peay, Indian River CC |
| Dillan Shrum | 1B | 2017-2020 | Nevada |
| Cameron Shryock | P | 2016-2019 | Western Kentucky, Wabash Valley College, Austin Peay |
| Wes Shryock | IF | 2010-2010 | Northern Illinois, Master's College |
| Levi Shuck | P-IF | 2020-2020 | Florida Gulf Coast |
| Tyler Shuck | P-IF | 2018-2020 | Florida Gulf Coast |
| Luke Shuemaker | P | 2011-2012 | Murray State |
| Hunter Shuff | P | 2016-2019 | Mount Saint Mary, Tallahassee CC, South Carolina-Aiken |
| Dalton Shuffield | IF | 2018-2020 | Texas State |
| Andy Shuford | C | 2009-2009 | Tennessee |
| Nicholas Shuford | P | 2003-2003 | Charleston Southern |
| Shaun Shugart | OF | 2004-2004 | South Alabama |
| Jason Shuger | --- | 2020-2020 | Air Force |
| Craig Shul | C | 2010-2014 | UNLV |
| Kevin Shul | P | 2015-2017 | Eastern Michigan, Southern Nevada |
| John Shuler | OF | 2001-2002 | UMD-Baltimore Cty |
| Brett Shulick | P | 2011-2012 | Fairfield, Connecticut-Avery Point |
| Brandon Shulista | P | 2014-2015 | Iowa, Iowa Central CC |
| Kevin Shull | P | 2003-2007 | New Orleans, San Jose State |
| Ryan Shull | OF | 2015-2018 | Longwood, Indian Hills CC-Centerville |
| Grant Shulman | IF | 2020-2020 | Rutgers |
| Noah Shulman | IF-OF | 2013-2016 | Brown |
| Deven Shulstad | P | 2018-2018 | Florida A&M |
| Eric Shultz | P | 2009-2012 | Yale |
| Michael Shumaker | 1B | 1999-1999 | Florida Southern |
| Kory Shumate | IF | 2014-2017 | Elon, Louisburg College |
| Q Shumpert | H | 2004-2004 | Miss. Valley St |
| Tyler Shumpert | P | 2015-2018 | Dallas Baptist, Galveston College, Baylor, Oklahoma Wesleyan |
| Mizuki Shumsky | IF | 2016-2017 | Miami, Occidental College |
| Dylan Shupe | C-P | 2011-2014 | Delaware, Delaware Technical & CC, Frostburg State |
| Max Shupe | IF | 2009-2010 | Oregon State, San Jose City College, Sonoma State |
| Mickey Shupin | IF | 2004-2007 | George Washington |
| Nick Shur | P | 2017-2018 | UC Riverside, Portland |
| Matt Shurley | P | 2006-2006 | Georgia Southern |
| Kevin Shurtleff | P | 2002-2005 | Marist |
| Brian Shust | OF | 2004-2006 | Wake Forest |
| Jared Shuster | P-OF | 2018-2020 | Wake Forest |
| Jordan Shusteric | IF | 2011-2015 | Miami, Alabama-Huntsville |
| Bill Shuta | P | 1983-1983 | Michigan |
| Dan Shutes | IF-OF | 2011-2014 | Western Michigan |
| Sam Shutes | P | 2014-2018 | Toledo |
| Reed Shuttle | P | 2013-2016 | Rutgers |
| Zach Shutts | P | 2006-2006 | UC Davis |
| Bob Shutz | H | 2003-2004 | Gardner-Webb |
| Cassius Shy | --- | 2020-2020 | Texas A&M-Corpus Christi |
| 493 record(s) |