| |
|
| Player Name | Born Date | Pos | High Level | MLB Years | Last Active | High School | College |
| |
| Eddie Basinski | 11/4/1922 | SS-2B | MLB | 1944-1947 | 1947 | | |
| Babe Birrer | 7/4/1928 | P | MLB | 1955-1958 | 1958 | Kensington (Buffalo,NY) | SUNY-Buffalo |
| Frank Bork | 7/13/1940 | P | MLB | 1964-1964 | 1964 | | |
| Frank Cipriani | 4/14/1941 | OF | MLB | 1961-1961 | 1961 | | |
| Chris Clapinski | 8/20/1971 | 2B-3B | MLB | 1999-2000 | 2006 | Palm Desert (Palm Desert,CA) | Louisiana State University |
| Jimmy Collins | 1/16/1870 | 3B | MLB | 1903-1908 | 1908 | | |
| Glen Cook | 9/8/1959 | P | MLB | 1985-1985 | 1987 | | |
| Mickey Corcoran | 8/26/1882 | 2B | MLB | 1910-1910 | 1910 | | |
| George Daly | 7/28/1887 | P | MLB | 1909-1909 | 1909 | | |
| Emerson Dickman | 11/12/1914 | P | MLB | 1936-1941 | 1941 | | |
| Frank Drews | 5/25/1916 | 2B | MLB | 1944-1945 | 1945 | | |
| Al Fitzmorris | 3/21/1946 | P | MLB | 1969-1978 | 1979 | | |
| Joe Gallagher | 3/7/1914 | OF | MLB | 1939-1940 | 1940 | | Manhattan College |
| Geoff Geary | 8/26/1976 | P | MLB | 2003-2007 | 2007 | Grossmont (El Cajon,CA) | University of Oklahoma |
| Huck Geary | 1/22/1917 | SS | MLB | 1942-1943 | 1943 | South Park (Buffalo,NY) | |
| Mark Guthrie | 9/22/1965 | P | MLB | 1989-2003 | 2003 | Venice (Venice,FL) | Louisiana State University |
| Pete Hamm | 9/20/1947 | P | MLB | 1970-1971 | 1971 | Soquel (Soquel,CA) | Stanford University |
| Babe Herman | 6/26/1903 | OF | MLB | 1926-1945 | 1945 | | |
| Orel Hershiser | 9/16/1958 | P | MLB | 1983-2000 | 2000 | Cherry Hill East (Cherry Hill,NJ) | Bowling Green State University |
| Bill Hunter | | OF | MLB | 1912-1912 | 1912 | | Towson University |
| George Hunter | 7/8/1887 | OF-P | MLB | 1909-1910 | 1910 | | |
| Stan Jok | 5/3/1926 | 3B | MLB | 1954-1955 | 1955 | | |
| Mike Jurewicz | 9/20/1945 | P | MLB | 1965-1965 | 1965 | | |
| Kevin Kobel | 10/2/1953 | P | MLB | 1973-1980 | 1982 | St. Francis (Hamburg,NY) | |
| Frank Kreutzer | 2/7/1939 | P | MLB | 1962-1969 | 1969 | | |
| Jack Kubiszyn | 12/19/1936 | SS-3B | MLB | 1961-1962 | 1962 | | |
| Dan Lewandowski | 1/6/1928 | P | MLB | 1951-1951 | 1951 | | |
| Walt Lynch | 4/15/1897 | C | MLB | 1922-1922 | 1922 | | |
| Ed MacGamwell | 1/10/1879 | 1B | MLB | 1905-1905 | 1905 | | |
| Tom Makowski | 12/22/1950 | P | MLB | 1975-1975 | 1975 | | |
| Phil Mankowski | 1/9/1953 | 3B | MLB | 1976-1982 | 1982 | | |
| David Manning | 8/14/1972 | P | MLB | 2003-2003 | 2006 | | Palm Beach Community College |
| Sandy McDougal | 5/21/1874 | P | MLB | 1905-1905 | 1905 | | |
| Billy Milligan | 8/19/1878 | P | MLB | 1904-1904 | 1904 | | |
| George Mohart | 3/6/1892 | P | MLB | 1920-1921 | 1921 | | |
| Johnny Mokan | 9/23/1895 | OF | MLB | 1921-1927 | 1927 | | |
| Ray Peters | 8/27/1946 | P | MLB | 1970-1970 | 1970 | | Harvard University |
| Frankie Pytlak | 7/30/1908 | C | MLB | 1932-1946 | 1946 | | |
| Lou Raymond | 12/11/1894 | 2B | MLB | 1919-1919 | 1919 | | |
| Jim Riley | 11/10/1886 | OF | MLB | 1910-1910 | 1910 | | |
| Buddy Rosar | 7/3/1914 | C | MLB | 1939-1951 | 1951 | | |
| Chet Ross | 4/1/1917 | OF | MLB | 1939-1944 | 1944 | | |
| Hack Schumann | 8/13/1884 | P | MLB | 1906-1906 | 1906 | | |
| Bill Schuster | 8/4/1912 | SS | MLB | 1937-1945 | 1945 | | |
| Monk Sherlock | 10/26/1904 | 1B | MLB | 1930-1930 | 1930 | | |
| Vince Sherlock | 3/27/1910 | 2B | MLB | 1935-1935 | 1935 | | |
| Sibby Sisti | 7/26/1920 | 2B-3B | MLB | 1939-1954 | 1954 | | |
| Warren Spahn | 4/23/1921 | P | MLB | 1942-1965 | 1965 | South Park (Buffalo,NY) | |
| Joe Winkelsas | 9/14/1973 | P | MLB | 1999-2006 | 2007 | Bishop Timon (Buffalo,NY) | Elon University |
| Matt Winters | 3/18/1960 | RF | MLB | 1989-1989 | 1989 | Williamsville (Williamsville,NY) | |
| Elmer Zacher | 9/17/1883 | OF | MLB | 1910-1910 | 1910 | | |
| |
| |
|
| Player Name | Born Date | Pos | High Level | MLB Years | Last Active | High School | College |
| |
| Jim Burt | 4/23/1981 | 1B | A | | 2006 | | University of Miami (Florida) |
| Pete Capello | 6/5/1965 | SS | AA | | 1989 | Spring Valley (NY) | Pace University |
| Paul Daddario | 8/13/1962 | 2B | A | | 1985 | | SUNY-Buffalo |
| Patrick Frawley | 3/25/1977 | P | Rookie | | 2001 | | University of Central Florida |
| Joe Gannon | 3/15/1975 | P | AAA | | 2007 | | Canisius College |
| Gordi Gronkowski | 6/26/1983 | 1B | Rookie | | 2007 | | Jacksonville University |
| Paul Hollins | 4/3/1959 | OF | AA | | 1986 | Orchard Park (Orchard Park,NY) | University of South Carolina |
| Brett Illig | 9/4/1977 | 3B | A+ | | 2000 | Phoenixville Area (Phoenixville,PA) | |
| Tony Kirbis | 2/16/1985 | P | A- | | 2007 | Kenmore East (Tonawanda,NY) | University-Albany |
| Aaron Krawiec | 3/17/1979 | P | AA | | 2005 | St. Francis (Flushing,NY) | Villanova University |
| Jim Negrych | 3/2/1985 | 2B | A | | 2007 | | University of Pittsburgh |
| Carmen Panaro | 9/21/1975 | C | A+ | | 1997 | | Niagara University |
| David Pyc | 2/11/1971 | P | AAA | | 1999 | Maryvale (Cheektowaga,NY) | University of Charleston (West Virginia) |
| Nathan Rewers | 11/30/1976 | 2B | Rookie | | 1999 | | University of Richmond |
| Justin Santonocito | 12/15/1976 | SS | A | | 1999 | | Mercyhurst College |
| Chris Snusz | 11/8/1972 | C | AAA | | 2005 | | Mercyhurst College |
| Aaron Sobieraj | 6/3/1981 | 2B | A+ | | 2004 | | University of Florida |
| Tom Stepka | 11/29/1975 | P | A+ | | 2003 | | Le Moyne College |
| Kevin Sweeney | 3/30/1974 | OF | A+ | | 1998 | West Seneca (West Seneca,NY) | Mercyhurst College |
| Derek Zgoda | 4/20/1973 | P | Rookie | | 1999 | Sweet Home (Amherst,NY) | Canisius College |
| |
| |
| College and other players |
|
| Player Name | Born Date | Pos | High Level | MLB Years | Last Active | High School | College |
| |
| Bart Grubbs | 10/1/1968 | P | - | | 0 | Carbon (Price,UT) | Brigham Young University |
| Jim Monin | 9/14/1944 | SS | - | | 0 | | University of Kentucky |
| Drew Pearce | 9/12/1974 | P | - | | 0 | St. Francis (Mountain View,CA) | University of California |
| Anthony Stutz | 8/10/1980 | P | Ind | | 2005 | | Stony Brook University |
| Derek Tarapacki | 8/17/1985 | P | - | | 0 | Saguaro (Scottsdale,AZ) | Yavapai College |
| |