CLEVELAND INDIANS 6 @ toronto blue jays 4<span class='h1_View'>Play by Play</span> (1986-05-19)

Boxscore Play by Play

Game Information

Score of Game

Cleveland Indians 6 Toronto Blue Jays 4

Game Date

Monday May 19, 1986

Start Time

Day

Innings

DH Used

Ballpark

Exhibition Stadium (Toronto,Ontario)

Attendance

27,202

Weather

Vis Manager

Pat Corrales (CLE)

Home Manager

Jimy Williams (TOR)

Winning Pitcher

Phil Niekro

Losing Pitcher

Dave Stieb

Save Pitcher

Scott Bailes

Umpires

HP: Rich Garcia 1B: Greg Kosc 2B: Rick Reed 3B: Dale Ford

CLE Record

19-17 -- AL East -- Ranks (Div/Lg/MLB): 5 / 6 / 10

CLE Streak

Win 1

TOR Record

17-21 -- AL East -- Ranks (Div/Lg/MLB): 7 / 11 / 18

TOR Streak

Loss 1

Notable Events

None of note

Get TBC PREMIUM and remove ads, cleaner display, access to research applications, data store discounts and more!

The TBC Newsletter will keep you periodically up-to-date on what is happening at The Baseball Cube.

Play-By-Play

top csv share Sort ✔

Grid Filters		Scoring Play Home Runs Hits Strikeouts Walks Stolen Bases
Top of Inning 1
Inning	Bat Team	Ln	Batter	Pos	Ba	Pit Team	Pitcher	Th	Play Result	Out	Runners	Count	Pitches	Play Description	Seq	Score	Event Notes
1	CLE	1	Otis Nixon	CF	L	TOR	Dave Stieb	R	Strikeout	0	---	0-0	---	Strikeout	1	0-0	---
1	CLE	2	Tony Bernazard	2B	L	TOR	Dave Stieb	R	Lineout	1	---	0-0	---	Lined out to First Base [Willie Upshaw]	2	0-0	---
1	CLE	3	Julio Franco	SS	R	TOR	Dave Stieb	R	Strikeout	2	---	0-0	---	Strikeout	3	0-0	---
Bottom of Inning 1
Inning	Bat Team	Ln	Batter	Pos	Ba	Pit Team	Pitcher	Th	Play Result	Out	Runners	Count	Pitches	Play Description	Seq	Score	Event Notes
1	TOR	1	Damaso Garcia	2B	R	CLE	Phil Niekro	R	Groundout	0	---	0-0	---	Grounded out to Second Base [Tony Bernazard]	4	0-0	---
1	TOR	2	Lloyd Moseby	CF	L	CLE	Phil Niekro	R	Strikeout	1	---	0-0	---	Strikeout	5	0-0	---
1	TOR	3	Rance Mulliniks	3B	L	CLE	Phil Niekro	R	Walk	2	---	0-0	---	Walked	6	0-0	---
1	TOR	4	Willie Upshaw	1B	L	CLE	Phil Niekro	R	Walk	2	1--	0-0	---	Walked ... Rance Mulliniks advanced to second	7	0-0	---
1	TOR	5	George Bell	LF	R	CLE	Phil Niekro	R	Double	2	12-	0-0	---	Doubled on ground ball to Right Field ... Willie Upshaw Scored ... Rance Mulliniks Scored	8	0-0	---
1	TOR	6	Jesse Barfield	RF	R	CLE	Phil Niekro	R	Strikeout	2	-2-	0-0	---	Strikeout	9	2-0	---
Top of Inning 2
Inning	Bat Team	Ln	Batter	Pos	Ba	Pit Team	Pitcher	Th	Play Result	Out	Runners	Count	Pitches	Play Description	Seq	Score	Event Notes
2	CLE	4	Andre Thornton	DH	R	TOR	Dave Stieb	R	Groundout	0	---	0-0	---	Grounded out to Third Base [Rance Mulliniks]	10	0-2	---
2	CLE	5	Mel Hall	LF	L	TOR	Dave Stieb	R	Triple	1	---	0-0	---	Tripled on ground ball to Left Field	11	0-2	---
2	CLE	6	Pat Tabler	1B	R	TOR	Dave Stieb	R	Single	1	--3	0-0	---	Infield Single to	12	0-2	---
2	CLE	7	Joe Carter	RF	R	TOR	Dave Stieb	R	Flyout	1	1-3	0-0	---	Flied out to Second Base [Damaso Garcia]	13	0-2	---
2	CLE	8	Brook Jacoby	3B	R	TOR	Dave Stieb	R	Walk	2	1-3	0-0	---	Walked ... Pat Tabler advanced to second	14	0-2	---
2	CLE	9	Chris Bando	C	L	TOR	Dave Stieb	R	Walk	2	123	0-0	---	Walked ... Mel Hall Scored ... Brook Jacoby advanced to second ... Pat Tabler advanced to third	15	0-2	---
2	CLE	1	Otis Nixon	CF	L	TOR	Dave Stieb	R	Groundout	2	123	0-0	---	Grounded out to Pitcher [Dave Stieb] ... Pat Tabler forced out at home	16	1-2	---
Bottom of Inning 2
Inning	Bat Team	Ln	Batter	Pos	Ba	Pit Team	Pitcher	Th	Play Result	Out	Runners	Count	Pitches	Play Description	Seq	Score	Event Notes
2	TOR	7	Cliff Johnson	DH	R	CLE	Phil Niekro	R	Walk	0	---	0-0	---	Walked	17	2-1	---
2	TOR	8	Ernie Whitt	C	L	CLE	Phil Niekro	R	Flyout	0	1--	0-0	---	Flied out to Shortstop [Julio Franco]	18	2-1	---
2	TOR	9	Tony Fernandez	SS	L	CLE	Phil Niekro	R	Groundout	1	1--	0-0	---	Grounded out to Second Base [Tony Bernazard] ... Cliff Johnson forced out at second base	19	2-1	---
2	TOR	1	Damaso Garcia	2B	R	CLE	Phil Niekro	R	Flyout	2	1--	0-0	---	Flied out to Right Field [Joe Carter]	20	2-1	---
Top of Inning 3
Inning	Bat Team	Ln	Batter	Pos	Ba	Pit Team	Pitcher	Th	Play Result	Out	Runners	Count	Pitches	Play Description	Seq	Score	Event Notes
3	CLE	2	Tony Bernazard	2B	L	TOR	Dave Stieb	R	Flyout	0	---	0-0	---	Flied out to Center Field [Lloyd Moseby]	21	1-2	---
3	CLE	3	Julio Franco	SS	R	TOR	Dave Stieb	R	Single	1	---	0-0	---	Singled on fly ball to Center Field	22	1-2	---
3	CLE	4	Andre Thornton	DH	R	TOR	Dave Stieb	R	Single	1	1--	0-0	---	Singled on fly ball to Center Field ... Julio Franco advanced to second	23	1-2	---
3	CLE	5	Mel Hall	LF	L	TOR	Dave Stieb	R	Double	1	12-	0-0	---	Doubled on fly ball to Center Field; Andre Thornton advanced to third ... Julio Franco Scored ... Andre Thornton advanced to third	24	1-2	---
3	CLE	6	Pat Tabler	1B	R	TOR	Dave Stieb	R	Hit by Pitch	1	-23	0-0	---	Hit by Pitch	25	2-2	---
3	CLE	7	Joe Carter	RF	R	TOR	Dave Stieb	R	Single	1	123	0-0	---	Singled on fly ball to Center Field ... Mel Hall Scored ... Andre Thornton Scored ... Pat Tabler advanced to third	26	2-2	---
3	CLE	8	Brook Jacoby	3B	R	TOR	Dave Stieb	R	Strikeout	1	1-3	0-0	---	Strikeout	27	4-2	---
3	CLE	9	Chris Bando	C	L	TOR	Dave Stieb	R	Walk	2	1-3	0-0	---	Walked ... Joe Carter advanced to second	28	4-2	---
3	CLE	1	Otis Nixon	CF	L	TOR	Dave Stieb	R	Groundout	2	123	0-0	---	Grounded out to Shortstop [Tony Fernandez] ... Chris Bando forced out at second base	29	4-2	---
Bottom of Inning 3
Inning	Bat Team	Ln	Batter	Pos	Ba	Pit Team	Pitcher	Th	Play Result	Out	Runners	Count	Pitches	Play Description	Seq	Score	Event Notes
3	TOR	2	Lloyd Moseby	CF	L	CLE	Phil Niekro	R	Single	0	---	0-0	---	Singled on ground ball to Right Field	30	2-4	---
3	TOR	3	Rance Mulliniks	3B	L	CLE	Phil Niekro	R	Flyout	0	1--	0-0	---	Flied out to Left Field [Mel Hall]	31	2-4	---
3	TOR	4	Willie Upshaw	1B	L	CLE	Phil Niekro	R	Lineout	1	1--	0-0	---	Lined out to Right Field [Joe Carter]	32	2-4	---
3	TOR	5	George Bell	LF	R	CLE	Phil Niekro	R	Stolen Base	2	1--	0-0	---	Lloyd Moseby Stole 2B [Phil Niekro/Chris Bando]	33	2-4	Non-Batter Event
3	TOR	5	George Bell	LF	R	CLE	Phil Niekro	R	Flyout	2	-2-	0-0	---	Flied out to Center Field [Otis Nixon]	34	2-4	---
Top of Inning 4
Inning	Bat Team	Ln	Batter	Pos	Ba	Pit Team	Pitcher	Th	Play Result	Out	Runners	Count	Pitches	Play Description	Seq	Score	Event Notes
4	CLE	2	Tony Bernazard	2B	L	TOR	Dave Stieb	R	Strikeout	0	---	0-0	---	Strikeout	35	4-2	---
4	CLE	3	Julio Franco	SS	R	TOR	Dave Stieb	R	Groundout	1	---	0-0	---	Grounded out to Pitcher [Dave Stieb]	36	4-2	---
4	CLE	4	Andre Thornton	DH	R	TOR	Dave Stieb	R	Flyout	2	---	0-0	---	Flied out to Center Field [Lloyd Moseby]	37	4-2	---
Bottom of Inning 4
Inning	Bat Team	Ln	Batter	Pos	Ba	Pit Team	Pitcher	Th	Play Result	Out	Runners	Count	Pitches	Play Description	Seq	Score	Event Notes
4	TOR	6	Jesse Barfield	RF	R	CLE	Phil Niekro	R	Single	0	---	0-0	---	Singled on fly ball to Center Field	38	2-4	---
4	TOR	7	Cliff Johnson	DH	R	CLE	Phil Niekro	R	Single	0	1--	0-0	---	Singled on fly ball to Right Field ... Jesse Barfield advanced to second	39	2-4	---
4	TOR	8	Ernie Whitt	C	L	CLE	Phil Niekro	R	Flyout	0	12-	0-0	---	Flied out to Center Field [Otis Nixon]	40	2-4	---
4	TOR	9	Tony Fernandez	SS	L	CLE	Phil Niekro	R	Flyout	1	12-	0-0	---	Flied out to Third Base [Brook Jacoby]	41	2-4	---
4	TOR	1	Damaso Garcia	2B	R	CLE	Phil Niekro	R	Single	2	12-	0-0	---	Singled on fly ball to Left Field ... Jesse Barfield Scored ... Cliff Johnson advanced to third ... Damaso Garcia advanced to second	42	2-4	---
4	TOR	2	Lloyd Moseby	CF	L	CLE	Phil Niekro	R	Flyout	2	-23	0-0	---	Flied out to Second Base [Tony Bernazard]	43	3-4	---
Top of Inning 5
Inning	Bat Team	Ln	Batter	Pos	Ba	Pit Team	Pitcher	Th	Play Result	Out	Runners	Count	Pitches	Play Description	Seq	Score	Event Notes
5	CLE	5	Mel Hall	LF	L	TOR	Dave Stieb	R	Single	0	---	0-0	---	Singled on fly ball to Right Field	44	4-3	---
5	CLE	6	Pat Tabler	1B	R	TOR	Dave Stieb	R	Strikeout	0	1--	0-0	---	Strikeout	45	4-3	---
5	CLE	7	Joe Carter	RF	R	TOR	Dave Stieb	R	Flyout	1	1--	0-0	---	Flied out to Right Field [Jesse Barfield]	46	4-3	---
5	CLE	8	Brook Jacoby	3B	R	TOR	Dave Stieb	R	Single	2	1--	0-0	---	Singled on fly ball to Center Field ... Mel Hall advanced to second	47	4-3	---
5	CLE	9	Chris Bando	C	L	TOR	Dave Stieb	R	Single	2	12-	0-0	---	Singled on fly ball to Center Field ... Mel Hall Scored ... Brook Jacoby advanced to second	48	4-3	---
5	CLE	1	Otis Nixon	CF	L	TOR	Dave Stieb	R	Flyout	2	12-	0-0	---	Flied out to Center Field [Lloyd Moseby]	49	5-3	---
Bottom of Inning 5
Inning	Bat Team	Ln	Batter	Pos	Ba	Pit Team	Pitcher	Th	Play Result	Out	Runners	Count	Pitches	Play Description	Seq	Score	Event Notes
5	TOR	3	Rance Mulliniks	3B	L	CLE	Phil Niekro	R	Flyout	0	---	0-0	---	Flied out to Left Field [Mel Hall]	50	3-5	---
5	TOR	4	Willie Upshaw	1B	L	CLE	Phil Niekro	R	Strikeout	1	---	0-0	---	Strikeout	51	3-5	---
5	TOR	5	George Bell	LF	R	CLE	Phil Niekro	R	Single	2	---	0-0	---	Singled on fly ball to Left Field	52	3-5	---
Top of Inning 6
Inning	Bat Team	Ln	Batter	Pos	Ba	Pit Team	Pitcher	Th	Play Result	Out	Runners	Count	Pitches	Play Description	Seq	Score	Event Notes
6	CLE	2	Tony Bernazard	2B	L	TOR	Dave Stieb	R	Groundout	0	---	0-0	---	Grounded out to First Base [Willie Upshaw]	53	5-3	---
6	CLE	3	Julio Franco	SS	R	TOR	Dave Stieb	R	Flyout	1	---	0-0	---	Flied out to Right Field [Jesse Barfield]	54	5-3	---
6	CLE	4	Andre Thornton	DH	R	TOR	Dave Stieb	R	Walk	2	---	0-0	---	Walked	55	5-3	---
6	CLE	5	Mel Hall	LF	L	TOR	Dave Stieb	R	Single	2	1--	0-0	---	Singled on fly ball to Left Field ... Andre Thornton advanced to second	56	5-3	---
6	CLE	6	Pat Tabler	1B	R	TOR	Dave Stieb	R	Groundout	2	12-	0-0	---	Grounded out to Shortstop [Tony Fernandez]	57	5-3	---
Bottom of Inning 6
Inning	Bat Team	Ln	Batter	Pos	Ba	Pit Team	Pitcher	Th	Play Result	Out	Runners	Count	Pitches	Play Description	Seq	Score	Event Notes
6	TOR	6	Jesse Barfield	RF	R	CLE	Phil Niekro	R	Groundout	0	---	0-0	---	Grounded out to Shortstop [Julio Franco]	58	3-5	---
6	TOR	7	Cliff Johnson	DH	R	CLE	Phil Niekro	R	Flyout	1	---	0-0	---	Flied out to Second Base [Tony Bernazard]	59	3-5	---
6	TOR	8	Ernie Whitt	C	L	CLE	Phil Niekro	R	Single	2	---	0-0	---	Singled on fly ball to Right Field	60	3-5	---
6	TOR	9	Tony Fernandez	SS	L	CLE	Phil Niekro	R	Single	2	1--	0-0	---	Singled on fly ball to Left Field ... Ernie Whitt advanced to second	61	3-5	---
6	TOR	1	Damaso Garcia	2B	R	CLE	Phil Niekro	R	Lineout	2	12-	0-0	---	Lined out to Shortstop [Julio Franco]	62	3-5	---
Top of Inning 7
Inning	Bat Team	Ln	Batter	Pos	Ba	Pit Team	Pitcher	Th	Play Result	Out	Runners	Count	Pitches	Play Description	Seq	Score	Event Notes
7	CLE	7	Joe Carter	RF	R	TOR	Dave Stieb	R	Strikeout	0	---	0-0	---	Strikeout	63	5-3	---
7	CLE	8	Brook Jacoby	3B	R	TOR	Dave Stieb	R	Walk	1	---	0-0	---	Walked	64	5-3	---
7	CLE	9	Chris Bando	C	L	TOR	Dave Stieb	R	Groundout	1	1--	0-0	---	Grounded out to Shortstop [Tony Fernandez]. Double Play ... Brook Jacoby out at 2b.	65	5-3	---
Bottom of Inning 7
Inning	Bat Team	Ln	Batter	Pos	Ba	Pit Team	Pitcher	Th	Play Result	Out	Runners	Count	Pitches	Play Description	Seq	Score	Event Notes
7	TOR	2	Lloyd Moseby	CF	L	CLE	Phil Niekro	R	Strikeout	0	---	0-0	---	Strikeout	66	3-5	---
7	TOR	3	Rance Mulliniks	3B	L	CLE	Phil Niekro	R	Groundout	1	---	0-0	---	Grounded out to First Base [Pat Tabler]	67	3-5	---
7	TOR	4	Willie Upshaw	1B	L	CLE	Phil Niekro	R	Flyout	2	---	0-0	---	Flied out to Center Field [Otis Nixon]	68	3-5	---
Top of Inning 8
Inning	Bat Team	Ln	Batter	Pos	Ba	Pit Team	Pitcher	Th	Play Result	Out	Runners	Count	Pitches	Play Description	Seq	Score	Event Notes
8	CLE	1	Otis Nixon	CF	L	TOR	Jim Acker	R	Single	0	---	0-0	---	Infield Single to Third Base	69	5-3	---
8	CLE	2	Tony Bernazard	2B	L	TOR	Jim Acker	R	Groundout	0	1--	0-0	---	Sacrifice Hit to Catcher [Ernie Whitt] ... Otis Nixon advanced to second	70	5-3	---
8	CLE	3	Julio Franco	SS	R	TOR	Jim Acker	R	Caught Stealing	1	-2-	0-0	---	Otis Nixon Caught Stealing 3B [Jim Acker/Ernie Whitt]	71	5-3	Non-Batter Event
8	CLE	3	Julio Franco	SS	R	TOR	Jim Acker	R	Groundout	2	---	0-0	---	Grounded out to Shortstop [Tony Fernandez]	72	5-3	---
Bottom of Inning 8
Inning	Bat Team	Ln	Batter	Pos	Ba	Pit Team	Pitcher	Th	Play Result	Out	Runners	Count	Pitches	Play Description	Seq	Score	Event Notes
8	TOR	5	George Bell	LF	R	CLE	Phil Niekro	R	Flyout	0	---	0-0	---	Flied out to Right Field [Joe Carter]	73	3-5	---
8	TOR	6	Jesse Barfield	RF	R	CLE	Phil Niekro	R	Groundout	1	---	0-0	---	Grounded out to Second Base [Tony Bernazard]	74	3-5	---
8	TOR	7	Cliff Johnson	DH	R	CLE	Phil Niekro	R	Home Run	2	---	0-0	---	Home Run on ground ball to Left Field	75	3-5	---
8	TOR	8	Ernie Whitt	C	L	CLE	Phil Niekro	R	Flyout	2	---	0-0	---	Flied out to Catcher [Chris Bando]	76	4-5	---
Top of Inning 9
Inning	Bat Team	Ln	Batter	Pos	Ba	Pit Team	Pitcher	Th	Play Result	Out	Runners	Count	Pitches	Play Description	Seq	Score	Event Notes
9	CLE	4	Andre Thornton	DH	R	TOR	Jim Acker	R	Groundout	0	---	0-0	---	Grounded out to Pitcher [Jim Acker]	77	5-4	---
9	CLE	5	Mel Hall	LF	L	TOR	Jim Acker	R	Walk	1	---	0-0	---	Walked	78	5-4	---
9	CLE	6	Pat Tabler	1B	R	TOR	Jim Acker	R	Stolen Base	1	1--	0-0	---	Brett Butler Stole 2B [Jim Acker/Ernie Whitt]	79	5-4	Non-Batter Event
9	CLE	6	Pat Tabler	1B	R	TOR	Jim Acker	R	Strikeout	1	-2-	0-0	---	Strikeout	80	5-4	---
9	CLE	7	Joe Carter	RF	R	TOR	Jim Acker	R	Single	2	-2-	0-0	---	Singled on ground ball to Left Field ... Brett Butler Scored	81	5-4	---
9	CLE	8	Brook Jacoby	3B	R	TOR	Jim Acker	R	Single	2	1--	0-0	---	Singled on ground ball to Left Field ... Joe Carter advanced to second	82	6-4	---
9	CLE	9	Chris Bando	C	L	TOR	Jim Acker	R	Strikeout	2	12-	0-0	---	Strikeout	83	6-4	---
Bottom of Inning 9
Inning	Bat Team	Ln	Batter	Pos	Ba	Pit Team	Pitcher	Th	Play Result	Out	Runners	Count	Pitches	Play Description	Seq	Score	Event Notes
9	TOR	9	Tony Fernandez	SS	L	CLE	Phil Niekro	R	Double	0	---	0-0	---	Doubled on ground ball to Center Field	84	4-6	---
9	TOR	1	Damaso Garcia	2B	R	CLE	Scott Bailes	L	Strikeout	0	-2-	0-0	---	Strikeout	85	4-6	---
9	TOR	2	Lloyd Moseby	CF	L	CLE	Scott Bailes	L	Single	1	-2-	0-0	---	Infield Single to Second Base ... Tony Fernandez advanced to third	86	4-6	---
9	TOR	3	Kelly Gruber	PH	R	CLE	Scott Bailes	L	Flyout	1	1-3	0-0	---	Flied out to Center Field [Brett Butler]	87	4-6	---
9	TOR	4	Willie Upshaw	1B	L	CLE	Scott Bailes	L	Flyout	2	1-3	0-0	---	Flied out to Second Base [Tony Bernazard]	88	4-6	---
88 record(s)

About the Newsletter

CLEVELAND INDIANS 6 @ toronto blue jays 4Play by Play

Play-By-Play