| 1955 | Johnny Podres (World Series Most Valuable Player) |
| 1956 | Don Larsen (World Series Most Valuable Player) |
| 1957 | Lew Burdette (World Series Most Valuable Player) |
| 1958 | Bob Turley (World Series Most Valuable Player) |
| 1959 | Larry Sherry (World Series Most Valuable Player) |
| 1960 | Bobby Richardson (World Series Most Valuable Player) |
| 1961 | Whitey Ford (World Series Most Valuable Player) |
| 1962 | Ralph Terry (World Series Most Valuable Player) |
| 1963 | Sandy Koufax (World Series Most Valuable Player) |
| 1964 | Bob Gibson (World Series Most Valuable Player) |
| 1965 | Sandy Koufax (World Series Most Valuable Player) |
| 1966 | Frank Robinson (World Series Most Valuable Player) |
| 1967 | Bob Gibson (World Series Most Valuable Player) |
| 1968 | Mickey Lolich (World Series Most Valuable Player) |
| 1969 | Donn Clendenon (World Series Most Valuable Player) |
| 1970 | Brooks Robinson (World Series Most Valuable Player) |
| 1971 | Roberto Clemente (World Series Most Valuable Player) |
| 1972 | Gene Tenace (World Series Most Valuable Player) |
| 1973 | Reggie Jackson (World Series Most Valuable Player) |
| 1974 | Rollie Fingers (World Series Most Valuable Player) |
| 1975 | Pete Rose (World Series Most Valuable Player) |
| 1976 | Johnny Bench (World Series Most Valuable Player) |
| 1977 | Dusty Baker (NLCS Most Valuable Player), Reggie Jackson (World Series Most Valuable Player) |
| 1978 | Bucky Dent (World Series Most Valuable Player), Steve Garvey (NLCS Most Valuable Player) |
| 1979 | Willie Stargell (World Series Most Valuable Player), Willie Stargell (NLCS Most Valuable Player) |
| 1980 | Mike Schmidt (World Series Most Valuable Player), Manny Trillo (NLCS Most Valuable Player), Frank White (ALCS Most Valuable Player) |
| 1981 | Ron Cey (World Series Most Valuable Player), Pedro Guerrero (World Series Most Valuable Player), Burt Hooton (NLCS Most Valuable Player), Graig Nettles (ALCS Most Valuable Player), Steve Yeager (World Series Most Valuable Player) |
| 1982 | Fred Lynn (ALCS Most Valuable Player), Darrell Porter (World Series Most Valuable Player), Darrell Porter (NLCS Most Valuable Player) |
| 1983 | Mike Boddicker (ALCS Most Valuable Player), Rick Dempsey (World Series Most Valuable Player), Gary Matthews (NLCS Most Valuable Player) |
| 1984 | Steve Garvey (NLCS Most Valuable Player), Kirk Gibson (ALCS Most Valuable Player), Alan Trammell (World Series Most Valuable Player) |
| 1985 | George Brett (ALCS Most Valuable Player), Bret Saberhagen (World Series Most Valuable Player), Ozzie Smith (NLCS Most Valuable Player) |
| 1986 | Marty Barrett (ALCS Most Valuable Player), Ray Knight (World Series Most Valuable Player), Mike Scott (NLCS Most Valuable Player) |
| 1987 | Gary Gaetti (ALCS Most Valuable Player), Jeff Leonard (NLCS Most Valuable Player), Frank Viola (World Series Most Valuable Player) |
| 1988 | Dennis Eckersley (ALCS Most Valuable Player), Orel Hershiser (World Series Most Valuable Player), Orel Hershiser (NLCS Most Valuable Player) |
| 1989 | Will Clark (NLCS Most Valuable Player), Rickey Henderson (ALCS Most Valuable Player), Dave Stewart (World Series Most Valuable Player) |
| 1990 | Rob Dibble (NLCS Most Valuable Player), Randy Myers (NLCS Most Valuable Player), Jose Rijo (World Series Most Valuable Player), Dave Stewart (ALCS Most Valuable Player) |
| 1991 | Steve Avery (NLCS Most Valuable Player), Jack Morris (World Series Most Valuable Player), Kirby Puckett (ALCS Most Valuable Player) |
| 1992 | Roberto Alomar (ALCS Most Valuable Player), Pat Borders (World Series Most Valuable Player), John Smoltz (NLCS Most Valuable Player) |
| 1993 | Paul Molitor (World Series Most Valuable Player), Curt Schilling (NLCS Most Valuable Player), Dave Stewart (ALCS Most Valuable Player) |
| 1995 | Mike Devereaux (NLCS Most Valuable Player), Tom Glavine (World Series Most Valuable Player), Orel Hershiser (ALCS Most Valuable Player) |
| 1996 | Javy Lopez (NLCS Most Valuable Player), John Wetteland (World Series Most Valuable Player), Bernie Williams (ALCS Most Valuable Player) |
| 1997 | Marquis Grissom (ALCS Most Valuable Player), Livan Hernandez (World Series Most Valuable Player), Livan Hernandez (NLCS Most Valuable Player) |
| 1998 | Scott Brosius (World Series Most Valuable Player), Sterling Hitchcock (NLCS Most Valuable Player), David Wells (ALCS Most Valuable Player) |
| 1999 | Orlando Hernandez (ALCS Most Valuable Player), Eddie Perez (NLCS Most Valuable Player), Mariano Rivera (World Series Most Valuable Player) |
| 2000 | Mike Hampton (NLCS Most Valuable Player), Derek Jeter (World Series Most Valuable Player), Dave Justice (ALCS Most Valuable Player) |
| 2001 | Craig Counsell (NLCS Most Valuable Player), Randy Johnson (World Series Most Valuable Player), Andy Pettitte (ALCS Most Valuable Player), Curt Schilling (World Series Most Valuable Player) |
| 2002 | Troy Glaus (World Series Most Valuable Player), Adam Kennedy (ALCS Most Valuable Player), Benito Santiago (NLCS Most Valuable Player) |
| 2003 | Josh Beckett (World Series Most Valuable Player), Mariano Rivera (ALCS Most Valuable Player), Ivan Rodriguez (NLCS Most Valuable Player) |
| 2004 | David Ortiz (ALCS Most Valuable Player), Albert Pujols (NLCS Most Valuable Player), Manny Ramirez (World Series Most Valuable Player) |
| 2005 | Jermaine Dye (World Series Most Valuable Player), Paul Konerko (ALCS Most Valuable Player), Roy Oswalt (NLCS Most Valuable Player) |
| 2006 | David Eckstein (World Series Most Valuable Player), Placido Polanco (ALCS Most Valuable Player), Jeff Suppan (NLCS Most Valuable Player) |
| 2007 | Josh Beckett (ALCS Most Valuable Player), Matt Holliday (NLCS Most Valuable Player), Mike Lowell (World Series Most Valuable Player) |
| 2008 | Matt Garza (ALCS Most Valuable Player), Cole Hamels (World Series Most Valuable Player), Cole Hamels (NLCS Most Valuable Player) |
